Comments on: First Commercial Dog Cloning Operation Yields Five Little “Boogers”

By: Rationalist

Rationalist — Sun, 11 Oct 2009 04:37:15 +0000

This is great. But it’s actual science, not a magical, mystical, miracle.
I hope people won’t use the “soul” argument. For one, your fictitious Bible doesn’t say dogs have them. And two, it’s superstitious hokey for people who are dim enough to think we all survive the death of our brains.
The obscurantists/superstitious/religious(all synonyms) are always against new technologies. Remember, intelligence is the enemy of religion. But this is a beautiful step towards the mastery of genetic codes. That will end suffering and introduce a better humanity. Possibly even give actual, eternal life. (For real, not just living eternally on a cloud with those you love but nobody that annoys you)For now, cloning Fido is a choice one should have. I hope my dog lives as long as possible. And I would gladly love her through as many lives as we can get.

Here’s an idea. Dumb people are so scared of the word “cloning”, so we need to rebrand with a cuter name.

By: Mr.Truthteller

Mr.Truthteller — Sat, 11 Oct 2008 11:52:02 +0000

You people are a bunch of judgemental idiots. Ms. McKinney already HAD five rescue dogs. (How many have you HYPOCRITES rescued?) Booger was chosen to replicate because of his high degree of intelligence. She had her arms amputated and reconstructed; Service Dog Booger was
her “hands”. He could open a door with his teeth, get a towel from the dryer, take off her shoes and socks, and turn off her lights with a toggle switch, and pull her wheelchair when the battery went down. He was never TRAINED to be a service dog; he just WAS one. And everywhere that remarkable dog went, he spread Love and worked his particular brand of magic–at old folks homes where he carried baskets of cookies to people who had no one; to veterans centers as he brushed up against the stumps of a man who had no legs, who wrote a song about him because he was so special. His owner was blessed by God to have known him, and even more bless to have five clones of him who will carry on his Legacy by becoming service dogs like their Clone-Parent. And yes, in dogs, as with human beings, intelligence IS passed onto one’s children. As the cloning scientist said “We came give him a body, you can help re-create the sweet original Booger personality with much Love; and God Himself will give him a soul”. Some people have enough Faith to believe in Miracles. Booger’s owner had this kind of Faith; apparently you people DON’T!

By: Joy

Joy — Fri, 08 Aug 2008 14:47:53 +0000

emm, it’s a common. People apply the term “pit bull” to any mix breed stocky terrier with a common set of features.

I agree with Mary; the woman could have saved thousands of wonderful dogs for the cost of the clones, which are unlikely to be exactly like her Booger. But, since those with more money than common sense are free to do whatever they like, we now have the clones. It’s a sad old world.

By: emm

emm — Wed, 06 Aug 2008 20:56:08 +0000

that pic is not an apbt, its a staffie, or amstaff

By: Mary

Mary — Wed, 06 Aug 2008 02:25:50 +0000

“If by chance we meet again”
This topic was touched upon by both a television and a radio episode of This American Life:

“Ralph and Sandra Fisher run a show-animal business in Texas whose biggest star was an unusually gentle Brahman bull named Chance. They loved Chance, and when he died, they tried to bring him back from the dead using cloning technology being developed up the road at Texas A&M University. It worked. A baby bull was born from Chance’s DNA. He seemed like Chance reincarnated. Except he wasn’t. Which Ralph found out the hard way.”

DNA only provides a blueprint, a set of instructions. An individual’s personality and physical state depends upon how that set of instructions has manifested over time. There are an infinitesimal number of effectors that act upon the initial instructions furnished by DNA. For example, exposure to UV rays may cause skin cancer. Having a bad experience during infancy could effect your personality later in life.

Although Booger’s DNA was used as a starting point, the personality of each of the individual puppies will develop depending upon each one’s experience. Superficially, they will resemble Booger in terms of coat color and build. They may be susceptible to ailments that arise due to faulty DNA instructions – hip dysplasia, hemophilia, deafness – contained in Booger’s DNA. One could, due to environmental factors, develop cancer while the others do not. No doubt the Booger clones will hold different hierarchal positions in their pack; we can expect that their personalities will reflect their social status.

So, in short, Booger’s owner paid a cool 50 Gs for several puppies that LOOK exactly like her dead dog, and that she expects to ACT exactly like her dead dog. She will be disappointed to find that is not the case. Cells are dynamic things; quite a bit can happen from point a to point b.

Anyway, she would have done better to have adopted three discarded pit bull puppies from the shelter. The money she spent to entertain her fantasy of resurrection could have saved hundreds of desperate dogs.