It’s no fun being bullied, but new research supports what many teenagers have long suspected: A victim’s pain may be a bully’s gain. A new brain imaging study of aggressive teenage boys found that watching others being bullied triggered parts of their brains associated with pleasure. “It is entirely possible their brains are lighting in the way they are because they experience seeing pain in others as exciting and fun and pleasurable,”[Reuters] said co-author Dr. Benjamin Lahey.
The study subjects were 16 boys 16 to 18 years old, half of whom had aggressive conduct disorder and half of whom had no behavioral disorder. While their brains were hooked up to functional MRIs, the boys were shown video clips of people getting hurt either by accident, such as having a heavy object dropped on their hands, or by intentional actions by others, such as someone stomping on their feet. Lahey said he expected an emotionally indifferent response to pain from subjects with conduct disorder, a mental disorder characterized by aggressive, destructive or harmful behavior towards other people and animals and can include theft, substance abuse and sexual promiscuity, according to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. Instead, fMRI scans showed a strong but highly atypical emotional response [ABC News].
The aggressive group was not apathetic to the suffering of others, but actually seemed to derive sadistic pleasure. “Aggressive adolescents showed a specific and very strong activation of the amygdala and ventral striatum (an area that responds to feeling rewarded) when watching pain inflicted on others, which suggested that they enjoyed watching pain,” said [co-author] Jean Decety…. Unlike the control group, the youth with conduct disorder did not activate the area of the brain involved in self-regulation (the medial prefrontal cortex and the temporoparietal junction) [LiveScience]. The results of the small study are published in Biological Psychology [subscription required].
While bullying is common during adolescence, conduct disorder only affects 1 to 4 percent of the teenagers, most of them boys. The researchers caution that the study focused on boys with conduct disorder and should not be extrapolated to all bullies, and also note that the results should be verified by a larger study. Using aggressiveness to gain something tangible such as social approval versus personal reward is an important distinction between a regular bully and someone with conduct disorder. Indeed, aggressiveness can be channeled constructively to allow a neurotypical person to excel later in life, in business or athletics, for example [ABC News].
Dr. Michael Eslea, a psychology professor, commented: “A better understanding of the biological basis of these things is good to have but the danger is it causes people to leap to biological solutions – drugs – rather than other behavioural solutions” [BBC News].
Related Content:
DISCOVER: So, You Want to Be the Boss?
DISCOVER: Violence, Genes, and Prejudice
80beats: Teenage Hoodlums Can Blame Bad Behavior on Hormones, Study Says
Image: flickr / Aislinn Ritchie
November 9th, 2008 at 9:08 pm
They needed a STUDY to confirm this!?
I thought everyone knew that!
November 9th, 2008 at 10:32 pm
I agree with Vince. We don’t need entire teams of scientists to tell us that some adolecents enjoy inflicting pain on other people. We should really start focusing on what we can do to prevent this.
November 10th, 2008 at 1:31 pm
Clearly, some of these scientists have been raised in an overly sheltered environment, where negative behaviors and emotions were never observed.
November 10th, 2008 at 3:16 pm
Doesn’t the fact that this trait is part of the genetic make up of bullies mean we need to accept it? Isn’t that the same basis for acceptance of homosexuality.
November 10th, 2008 at 4:57 pm
Is there a study relating these behaviors into adulthood? Sociopathic tendenacys and/or Bi- Polarism
November 21st, 2008 at 1:54 am
Whoa…before everyone assumes this is a genetic trait…what about the question of association???? isn’t it possible that by age 16, the association of pleasure with other’s pain is a learned behavioral response? I would be interested in looking at how it lights up on an MRI in 2, 4, 6 8, and 10 year olds identified as bullies and see if the MRI centers are similiarly being triggered.
October 13th, 2009 at 10:46 pm
I just finished leaving my childs school wiping tears away. My child is 15 now and the sweetest child in the world, would befriend anyone no questions asked and has been picked on, spit on, slapped, and told she stunk. The teachers at the school do not care and they say yes we have seen her being picked on and thats awful but she causes it because of the things she does HAHA to fit in. So, what I want to know is this WHY with all the education we have and all the money being spent on those things that don’t really matter is our children suffering something has seriously went wrong in our society and someone needs to hold these childrens hands and tell them that they do matter and we will give you the tools to use to get this bullying stopped, until this happens it doesnt matter how much pain they inflict or whether its on purpose we the parents of the victims know ITS ON PURPOSE and we would like it stopped as soon as possible. worried mama
October 18th, 2009 at 3:24 pm
I have experienced female bullies (NOT ONLY male ones!) too, as a teenager. They were also enjoying themselves very much, so I reckon it is NOT only a male problem. Perhaps in certain social environments female aggressiveness isn´t accepted, which would explain the outcomes of that experiment. Having been a teenager I had to bully people back to get rid of my bullies, which I had learnt to do over time. A change of the social environment might help too. On the whole I found out, that you can´t be nice nowadays, esp. as a teenager at highschool. You just won´t get away with it. Don´t get me wrong. I am not saying you have to be mean. But you can´t be polite and you shouldn´t be warmhearted towards your school mates. You can have friends at highschool, but they are not your family, so you shouldn´t tell them certain things. You should never trust them. Basically you have to show people you don´t need then. They disrespect you otherwise.