Leftover Embryos at Fertility Clinics Pose Troubling Questions for Patients

By Eliza Strickland | December 5, 2008 10:42 am

cell culturesEven after people struggling with infertility have found a happy ending with in vitro fertilization, another complicated dilemma remains: what to do with extra fertilized embryos created during treatment. A new study found that more than 400,000 of these embryos are currently chilling in the freezers of fertility clinics around the country; while some of those are being stored for women who want more children, many others are being kept on ice because women have qualms about disposing of them. And while some women are willing to donate their embryos to research, that option frequently isn’t offered.

Ethical and personal considerations have led some people to a stalemate. For nearly 15 years, Kim and Walt Best have been paying about $200 a year to keep nine embryos stored in a freezer at a fertility clinic at Duke University — embryos that they no longer need, because they are finished having children but that Ms. Best cannot bear to destroy, donate for research or give away to another couple…. “There is no easy answer,” said Ms. Best, a nurse. “I can’t look at my twins and not wonder sometimes what the other nine would be like” [The New York Times].

In the study, published in the journal Fertility and Sterility [subscription required], researcher Anne Drapkin Lyerly surveyed over 1,000 fertility patients and found widespread dissatisfaction with the options offered regarding the extra embryos. In one surprising result, more than half of the women said they were “very unlikely” to donate the embryos to another couple trying to have a baby. “If you look at the policy debate and the discussion in the literature, there is a presumption that if you respect or care about an embryo, you would want it to become a child,” Lyerly says. But, she says, patients apparently feel responsible for the care of the children resulting from their embryos [USA Today].

Women who don’t want to donate their embryos but who feel a personal or moral obligation to the tiny clumps of cells should be given other options, the study suggested. Two such options that are rarely discussed or offered involve implanting the leftover embryos in the woman’s uterus during a time when she is unlikely to become pregnant or allowing a couple to have a ritual disposal ceremony of the embryos. “These may be the answers to many patients’ desires as they allow the embryos to pass in a way that seems more respectful to them” [Los Angeles Times], Lyerly said.

Meanwhile, women who are willing to donate their embryos to research on embryonic stem cells are often stymied, as many fertility clinics don’t offer that option. Strict federal regulations regarding embryonic stem cell research mean that no federally funded researchers can accept embryos from clinics: “Every week I hear from patients who want to donate embryos for stem cell research, but there’s virtually nowhere to send them (the embryos),” [said] Sean Tipton, a spokesman for the American Society for Reproductive Medicine [Wall Street Journal blog].

Related Content:
80beats: On the Michigan Ballot: Should Human Embryos be Used in Medical Research?
80beats: 5 of 21 Federally Approved Stem Cell Lines Are Ethically Tainted

Image: iStockphoto

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Health & Medicine
  • Mike Kelley

    Why don’t they just kill it? All it is is a human being unable to object or defend him or herself. It is similar in its personal reality situation to Adolph Hitler liking to have experiments on human beings and children for his idea of a greater good. But these are rationalized more pleasantly.

  • http://- Phil Doran

    It’s just a few frozen cells that might become a human being if implanted. It has no “personal reality” as it has no brain or nervous system yet.

    If the parents care about it, let them bury it where they choose and have a ceremony for it if they feel it is appropriate, as some people do for a miscarriage.

    The parents’ feelings should be the first consideration.

    Many naturally fertilized embryos fail to implant, and the mother is unaware that they ever existed.

    (And if you want to bring Hitler into the argument, Nazi Germany totally banned abortion for German women.)


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar