Clever Monkeys Can Recognize Basic Grammar

By Allison Bond | July 8, 2009 5:53 pm

TamarinCotton-top tamarin monkeys can distinguish between “right” and “wrong” grammatical patterns, according to a study published in the journal Biology Letters. The findings suggest that humans share the ability with other species to identify certain patterns that are crucial to spoken communication.

Researchers wanted to find out if the monkeys, which do not communicate using spoken language, could recognize grammatical sequences. To do this, the scientists familiarized the monkeys with a series of sounds and patterns. They did this by first playing recordings of humans saying two-syllable nonsense words, and familiarized the monkeys with either a prefix or a suffix. “In the prefixation condition, they heard ‘shoy-bi’, ‘shoy-la’, ‘shoy-ro’ and so on,” explained Ansgar Endress, lead author of the study. “The idea is that they get used to the pattern if you play it long enough” [BBC News].

The next day the scientists played new words for the prefix monkeys, but this time included some words in which the prefix had been changed to a suffix, like “na-shoy.” (They did the reverse for the suffix monkeys.) The scientists hypothesized that when the monkeys heard this “incorrect” sequence of sounds, they would be more likely to look at the loudspeakers from which the sounds were coming, the same way a human would. For example, if a person said he or she “walked to the store,” and then [used] the word “edwalk” instead of “walked,” the listener, used to hearing “walked” might stare at the speaker as if to say, “Huh?” [Discovery News].

The monkeys responded to the sounds as predicted: when an unfamiliar sequence played, such as na-shoy, the animals looked at the speakers more often, the researchers found. According to Endress, “If they got used to, or bored by, the pattern, then they might be more interested in items that violate (it) – because they are something new – than in items that are consistent with the pattern” [BBC News]. The scientists say this shows that humans might use brain processes to understand language that are based on memory, and which are not specific only to language itself. In fact, humans share the recognition of the order of sounds with other animals, says coauthor Mark Hauser. “In bird song or whale song, for example, there’s a temporal ordering to the notes and that’s critical for communication” [BBC News].

Although the study doesn’t show that monkeys can use or learn language, it does show that they can remember and recognize familiar grammatical patterns. Furthermore, the results of the study not only indicate that human language may have evolved from basic memory processes, but also may give scientists a glimpse into how we learn grammar rules, such as past- and future- verb tenses. Endress explains: “Our results suggest a fairly pedestrian mechanism: human infants, like monkeys, might be particularly prone to track what occurs in the first and the last position of words and other linguistic units. They might use these mechanisms of memory organization for learning affixation rules” [New Scientist].

Related Content:
80beats: Mice With a Human Language Gene Have Altered Squeaks and Brain Structure
80beats: Female Monkeys Chat More Than Males to Maintain Social Ties
80beats: Facial Expressions Provide an Evolutionary Boost

Image: flickr / alistairmcmillan

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Living World, Mind & Brain
  • TraumaPony

    Hah, cool. It’s extremely interesting to see just how similiar monkeys and apes are to us. I wonder, would it be possible to hook up something like a text-to-speech synthesiser to a bonobo’s brain?

  • Nick

    TP: Not currently, but eventually it will be. The future’s gonna be stranger than we can imagine right now.

  • Skeptikor

    I’m not sure I’d want to hear my neighbour’s overstimulated beagle shouting out what he wants to do to my leg.

  • Yuval

    This is very, very far from a natural language grammar.
    This is, at best, a type-2 formal grammar:
    Any skills needed for this type of matching may be viewed as arithmetic in nature, not linguistic.

  • K Ackermann

    I have a monkey in my room right now taking notes on everything I do. It’s kind of creeping me out.

  • Chris

    very basic but still better than many internet users.

  • Natalia Heartz

    My coder is trying to persuade me to move to .net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs. But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using Movable-type on several websites for about a year and am worried about switching to another platform. I have heard excellent things about Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it? Any help would be really appreciated!

  • Luella Pavloski

    I conceive this website has some very great information for everyone : D.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar