Italian Court Convicts Google Execs for Hosting Illegal Video

By Smriti Rao | February 24, 2010 2:28 pm

gAn Italian court in Milan has just convicted three Google executives of criminal charges. The court found them liable for an online video that they did not appear in, film, or have any role in posting, and which the company promptly removed when complaints about it were raised. The Italian court, however, still held them responsible for the video and sentenced them to suspended six-month sentences. Experts say the case sets a dangerous precedent, and could dramatically restrict online content in Italy.

Thousands of people post videos each hour on YouTube and Google Video, and various court cases have questioned whether Google, which owns YouTube, is liable for every video that infringes on someone’s copyright or is deemed offensive to its viewers. Google has argued that it’s only liable if offensive material stays up on its site despite complaints against it, and says that if the company takes complained-about videos down, it has no legal liability–like the rules it faces under U.S. law. Italy apparently disagrees.

The case pertains to a video that was posted to Google Video in 2006 showing four youths in Turin bullying a 17-year old who suffers either from Down Syndrome or autism (reports vary). The video received 12,000 views before the Italian police brought it to Google’s notice. The company immediately took it down, and Google then helped the cops find the person who uploaded it, resulting in the identification (and school expulsion) of the four bullies. But the Google executives, who include David Drummond, Google’s senior vice president and chief legal officer, and George Reyes, Google’s former chief financial officer, were charged and convicted for criminal defamation and a failure to protect the privacy of the bullied teen.

Google plans to appeal the conviction but worries that it sets a bad legal precedent–none of the accused directly handled the video, and the video had been removed after Google received complaints; however, the prosecutors claim that Google should never have allowed the video to be posted in the first place [Mashable].

In a post on its corporate blog, Google wrote that this conviction attacks the very principles of freedom on which the Internet is built, and argued that the person who uploaded the offensive video was responsible for its content. The company declared: If that principle is swept aside and sites like Blogger, YouTube and indeed every social network and any community bulletin board, are held responsible for vetting every single piece of content that is uploaded to them — every piece of text, every photo, every file, every video — then the Web as we know it will cease to exist, and many of the economic, social, political and technological benefits it brings could disappear [The Official Google Blog].

Internet analysts say the Italy conviction implies that Google must start pre-screening all videos uploaded to YouTube before allowing them to go live–or at least it must start doing so in Italy if the convinction stands. That site sees more than 20 hours of video being posted every minute worldwide, which would make the screening process if not entirely impossible, then extremely cumbersome and expensive.

This isn’t the first time Italy has cracked down severely on a tech company. Its tax authorities have demanded that eBay should hand over information about its customers relating to goods sold on the site between 2004 and 2007; Yahoo was fined €12,000 last year after Milan’s public prosecutor demanded information about private emails sent by suspected criminals; and the Italian interior ministry has required Facebook to hand over personal information about users who created groups said to “glorify” Mafia bosses, and again last October over a group said to promote the violent death of Silvio Berlusconi, the prime minister [Guardian].

Related Content:
80beats: Google to China: No More Internet Censorship, or We Leave
80beats: Googlefest Can’t Stop, Won’t Stop: 3 New Ways Google Will Take Over Your Life
DISCOVER: Big Picture: 5 Reasons Science [Hearts] Google
DISCOVER: Google Taught Me How to Cut My Own Hair
DISCOVER: How Google Is Making Us Smarter

Image: Flickr/Manfrys

  • william

    I think that it is ironic that google’s video is what allowed the offenders to be caught. Does Italy just want to stick it’s head in the sand and pretend these things do not happen?

  • Illusions

    I think the solution is simple. Stop giving Italy access. Period. What I would expect is that companies and individuals would pressure their officials to change their stance. If google can censor for China, then they should be able to find a way to restrict access to Italians. It is the Italian citizens responsibility to ensure their leaders are serving their interests. Not Googles.

  • Dan

    I would second what Illusions posted. Google should simply block Italians from accessing its site until Italy changes its laws. An Italian court should not be able to hold the rest of the world hostage by its ruling.

  • Katharine

    They did it for China; they can do it to Italy.

  • Tony

    Illusions post x2


    “…they did not appear it, film, or have any role…” appear “in”.
    “…showing four youths in Turin bulling a 17-year old…” “bullying”
    Does anybody proof their work anymore? What does Italy think Google can do to prevent these postings? Hire 10,000 people to view content of uploads every day? It is through complaint that a random video is brought to light for questionable content and ultimately used to apprehend dumb criminals. They should be thanking Google, not convicting them.

  • Paul Scaglia

    While most of the news media and political commentators are looking at the recent Italian court decision against Google from the freedom of expression angle, the more accurate analysis of the Italian court decision is the power of Silvio Berlusconi, politics and money. As recent events in Italy have undoubtedly shown, the changes to the judicial system that Berlusconi and his cronies in government have pursued are not based on issues related to democracy, the rule of law, or good government but on protecting the financial interests and political power of Silvio Berlusconi and his allies. For people knowledgeable on how Italian society functions, the latest court decision against three Google executives is more about protecting the business and political interests of Silvio Berlusconi and his friends in government than it is about Google and the Internet.

  • Arki

    They should stop the service in Italy. I’m still in shock after reading this…

  • Eliza Strickland

    LLORNKCOR: Sorry about the typos, and thanks for pointing them out. I fixed em.

    Eliza Strickland, online news editor

  • MementoOfLaw


    That’s an interesting take on the internal politics of Italy. I understand that key people may be beyond the reach of the Italian court because of their connections to Berlusconi. But I wonder, how exactly is it in their interest to bring the case against Google in the first place?

    The reason I ask is that it seems all too symptomatic of America envy. Nowhere is that sentiment stronger than in the Internet sector of EU countries. No one minds criminally convicting people of things they didn’t do as long as those people are rich and powerful.

    I found an interesting take on it here:

  • it support guy

    That is so ridiculous!! Just people jealous of the success of Google!

  • online flowers coupon

    Picking out flowers is always tricky, My partner and i can’t predict which kind, coloring, smell, hight connected with plants for getting. Sometimes I merely just click all-around aimlessly and pay attention to what inside budget range and purchase which.

  • Landon Llanet

    I precisely desired to thank you so much again. I do not know the things I could possibly have made to happen in the absence of those techniques contributed by you relating to this topic. Entirely was the intimidating issue in my position, nevertheless seeing this specialised manner you processed it forced me to weep with delight. I am happy for this work as well as hope that you comprehend what a powerful job you are always accomplishing training most people thru your web site. I know that you’ve never met all of us.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar