Bear Fight! Grizzlies Are Creeping Into Polar Bears' Canadian Turf

By Andrew Moseman | February 25, 2010 10:37 am

GrizzlyUp north in the Canadian province of Manitoba, polar bears are receiving some unwelcome guests. Researchers have seen grizzly bears moving into the area for the first time, and that might not be good news for the already-troubled polar bears.

Linda Gormezano and her team, who are publishing the study (pdf) in Canadian Field-Naturalist, weren’t even looking for grizzlies when they started to spot the huge mammals; they were flying around counting fox dens. Before 1996, there was no evidence that grizzly bears encroached on polar bear territory. From that year on, however, there have been at least 12 sightings, negating the prior theory that the barren landscape north of the Hudson Bay was impassable, in terms of resources, for migrating grizzly bears [Discovery News]. If grizzlies can survive there, Gormezano says, they’ll probably want to stay, because there’s a bevy of caribou, fish, and other good things to eat.

This worries Gormezano. She says, “Grizzlies would likely hibernate in polar bear maternity denning habitat. They would come out of hibernation at the same time and can kill polar cubs” [BBC News]. In addition, the geographical proximity would make it more likely that polar and grizzly bears would produce hybrid offspring, labeled “pizzly,” “prizzly,” or “grolar” bears.

Of course, a story about competing grizzlies and polar bears can lead to only one place: nerd-tastic arguments over which would win in a fight. While debating this at length, Canada’s The Globe and Mail asks the experts. Manitoba Wildlands director Gaile Whelan Enns sees the grizzlies with the advantage: “The grizzly is more accustomed to the predator-prey relationship, whereas the polar bears are not quite as aggressive” [The Globe and Mail]. However, she notes, polar bears have the size advantage, outweighing their competitors by hundreds of pounds.

Study author Robert Rockwell says that the two bear species would most likely meet when the polar bears take to their dens to give birth, which could give the grizzlies an easy target. “If it’s a fight between a 1,200-pound male polar bear and a 600-pound grizzly, I think we know who would win,” Dr. Rockwell said. “But in this likeliest of cases, it’s debatable. There are actually reports in the literature where grizzlies have killed denning polar bear females” [The Globe and Mail].

Both kinds of bear receive protection from the province of Manitoba, and Canada lists both as species of special concern. Whether they have special concern for each other should their territories collide remains to be seen.

Related Content:
80beats: Obama Agrees With Bush: Polar Bears Won’t Drive Global Warming Policy
80beats: 2 Trillion Tons of Polar Ice Lost in 5 Years, and Melting Is Accelerating
DISCOVER: Polar Bears (Finally) Make the Endangered Species List
DISCOVER: The Electronic Grizzly, mapping the majestic creatures

Image: Wikimedia Commons / Shellie

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Environment, Living World
  • http://drvitelli.typepad.com Romeo Vitelli

    Does this mean they’ll be jailing grizzlies in Churchill’s Polar Bear Jail now?

    http://www.wayodd.com/canada-expands-polar-bear-jail/v/3341/

  • JD

    My money is on the polar bears. They have the size advantage, and they’re smarter.

  • JMW

    A couple of years ago, an American hunter shot and killed what he thought was a polar bear in the North West Territories. But then he noticed some anatomical anomalies, and had the bear analyzed.

    It turned out to be a pizzly. Half polar bear, half grizzly. Check out http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grizzly%E2%80%93polar_bear_hybrid

    Which makes me wonder…will the intelligent descendents of bears wonder if grizzlies killed polar bears, or mated with them? Kinda like did Homo Sapiens kill Homo Neanderthalis, or mate with them?

  • Mark

    A bit of evolution, we did both as will the bears

  • louis molina

    Its time for Mother Nature to choice a winner or new breed either way it’s up to man to protect them

  • Alaska Jim

    A bit more of evolution — of man. Find something rare and kill it.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

80beats

80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »