Sick Ground Zero Workers Will Get a $650 Million Settlement

By Smriti Rao | March 12, 2010 12:14 pm

393px-Firefigher_Smoke_WorlAfter six years of legal wrangling, a New York judge is set to approve a $657 million settlement package for thousands of rescue workers and volunteers who became sick after working on the cleanup of the World Trade Center site. The workers, who had sued the City of New York and other officials for their subsequent illness, can now settle their injury claims. Marc Bern, one of the lawyers representing the workers, said many of his clients were “first responders” at the site when the twin towers collapsed on September 11, 2001. After the work, some found their health deteriorated, with many suffering from asthma, other respiratory issues and blood cancer [CNN].

The money for the claims will come from a $1 billion federal grant to the WTC Captive Insurance Co., created to indemnify the city and its contractors against the flood of lawsuits [Daily News]. The workers have 90 days to look through the proposed settlement and decide if they like it. If 95 percent of the plaintiffs approve of the package, then the settlement will stand at $575 million. If 100% approve, the settlement goes up to $657 million [Daily News].

The individual payments will be made based on a point system that depends on the severity of the worker’s illness, his past health history, and the role the smoke at Ground Zero played in his current illness. Rescue workers can claim anything from a few thousand dollars to more than one million. The settlement would also fund a special insurance policy, which provides additional compensation to any plaintiff contracting certain types of cancer in the future [CNN]. New York Mayor Mike Bloomberg said the settlement was a “fair and reasonable resolution to a complex set of circumstances.”

DISCOVER has reported in the past that when the twin towers collapsed on September 11, two million tons of dust containing cement, asbestos, glass, lead, and carcinogens rained down on lower Manhattan. Phillip Landrigan, who heads the Department of Preventive and Community Medicine at Mount Sinai, said the concentrations of dust in the air were so high that they overwhelmed all the normal defenses of the human respiratory tract, and people inhaled ounces of dust into their trachea or their bronchi. The apparent results were the persistent “World Trade Center cough,” inflamed sinuses, and in the case of some workers who worked amidst the debris and smoke, thyroid and lung cancer.

For many long-suffering workers, news of the settlement drew mixed reactions. Carpenter James Nolan, who said he helped recover bodies and build ramps for firehoses at the WTC site, said the settlement would help pay the medical bills for his for lung and leg problems–which he claimed were a result of working at Ground Zero.  “We’ve had to fight for what we deserve,” said Nolan, 45. “I’m glad it’s coming to an end” [Associated Press]. Others like Gary Klein, a retired cop with lung scarring and stomach problems, wasn’t so sure. “A million dollars is not a lot of money if you have cancer and need chemotherapy,” Klein said. “What’s going to be left for your family after you die?” [Daily News]

Related Content:
DISCOVER: World Plague Center
DISCOVER: The Top 13 Medicine Stories of 2006
DISCOVER: Pinpointing WTC Pollution
DISCOVER: What We Learned About Tall Buildings from the World Trade Center Collapse

Image: Wikimedia

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Health & Medicine
  • Phil

    So much for altruism. Would love to know how many cases of illness are truly correlated. What about neighbors and workers in the area? Is cause/effect clear for those, or are they just missing a good lawyer? From hero to profiteer, in one single swoop.

  • Albert Bakker

    I find it incomprehensible that you should react in such a manner Phil #1.

    These people were exposed to the most extreme situations imaginable – and beyond – and they did their work and much more. And now they are ill. But you would like them to prove strict causal links between their medical conditions and exposure to that dust? That, as you should know before saying it, is an entirely impossible demand to meet in any individual case.

    As I understand it some of these workers will get about $ 3250,- of which they will finally receive less than $ 2000. I read the laywers are urging their clients to take the deal. They are skimming a third or more. So I guess after paying a crescendo of medical bills for almost 10 years now, they are finally rich, thanks to the warm heartfelt support of their fellow Americans.

    If you really want to be cynical about it, think of it as a way of subsidizing law firms on the backs of those hard workers.

  • hotels near disneyland

    Revealing, very informative post..quite interesting.. I really appreciate every time I saw an eye-opener views..maybe we share links


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar