Proposal to Regulate De-Finning of Sharks De-feated

By Smriti Rao | March 24, 2010 12:31 pm

Shark_finsIn a victory for East Asian nations that consume sharkfin soup, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) has shot down three of four proposals to protect sharks. Member nations of CITES who gathered in Doha, Qatar, rejected proposals that would have required countries to strictly regulate — but not ban — trade in several species of scalloped hammerhead, oceanic whitetip and spiny dogfish sharks [The New York Times]. Japan also lobbied against the protections, because it strongly opposes extending the convention’s protections to any marine species (including the bluefin tuna that is so beloved by Japan’s sushi connoisseurs).

The only proposal that managed to get through was a proposal from the European Union and the island nation of Palau to protect the porbeagle shark, which is prized for its meat. But even this victory is a shallow one, as the proposal passed by a margin of just one vote, and could be overturned at the conference’s final session on Thursday.

Marine biologists have long warned that hammerhead and whitefin sharks are being overfished, particularly by countries like China where sharkfin soup is a prestigious delicacy. Fishermen harvest the fins and typically throw the sharks back into the sea to die. The rate of species decline in some areas is an astounding 90 percent. Japan led opposition to the four measures, arguing that management of shark populations should be left to regional fisheries groups, not CITES [Sydney Morning Herald].

The current CITES meeting has been seen by some conservation experts as a dispiriting sign that the convention isn’t making its decisions about endangered species based on scientific findings, but is instead bowing to politics and economic interests. “It appears that science no longer matters,” said Elizabeth Griffin of wildlife conservation group Oceana, based in Washington. “CITES is not fulfilling its obligation to protect species threatened by international trade” [Sydney Morning Herald].

Stuart Beck, Palau’s ambassador to the United Nations, neatly summed up the anger felt by conservationists after the shark protections failed, saying in a statement: “I am sure that, properly prepared, bald eagle is delicious. But, as civilized people, we simply do not eat it” [The New York Times].

Related Content:
80beats: Endangered Species Meeting Brings Good News for Elephants, Bad News for Coral
80beats: Bluefin Tuna is Still on the Menu: Trade Ban Fails at International Summit
80beats: DNA Forensics Traces Sharks Killed for Their Fins
80beats: Human Appetite for Sharks Pushes Many Toward Extinction

Image: Wikimedia

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Environment, Living World
  • Doug Watts

    Yay … Extinction worked great for the passenger pigeon.

  • Doug Watts

    It’s nice to know that science is taken seriously.

  • Fay Lovecraft

    i suppose the japanese prefer their soup and sushi over their sea creatures.

  • Doug

    Why do they even have these meetings anymore when no amount of data can get a species protected if someone thinks it’s particularly tasty? I’m convinced the only reason the ivory ban stayed in effect is because nobody eats it.

  • Brian Too

    Hmmm, a practice that is wasteful, cruel, and is virtually certain to lead to multiple species extinctions.

    That’s genuinely funny, “…arguing that management of shark populations should be left to regional fisheries groups…”. Oh, so the Japanese can regulate shark fisheries as effectively as they have regulated whaling? Management by not managing?

    Need I point out that hiring people to be in charge of regulating something, and then ensuring that those people can’t or won’t do their jobs, recently led to a worldwide financial crisis? One that led to a global recession and nearly brought on a global depression? One that hurt millions of people?

    Once again the commercial fishing industry proves that it cannot manage it’s resources, it cannot manage international politics, and it does not want to be in business for the long term. The industry itself is heading for extinction.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar