Toads—Yes, Toads—May Know When an Earthquake Is Coming

By Andrew Moseman | March 31, 2010 9:08 am

Bufo_BufoThe wave of high-profile seismic activity so far in 2010 has been another reminder that we humans could use all the help we can get in predicting earthquakes. This week in the Journal of Zoology, biologist Rachel Grant suggests a new way: Watch the toads.

Taking cues from the animal kingdom is not itself a new idea (not by a long shot): Reports of animal earthquake prediction are legion and they date back to at least 373 BCE, when historians record that animals including rats, snakes and weasels flocked out of Helice just days before a quake devastated the Greek city. More recently there have been reports of catfish moving violently, bees leaving their hive in a panic, and fish, rodents, wolves and snakes exhibiting strange behaviour before earthquakes [Nature]. While these anecdotes grab the imagination, the scatter-shot nature of earthquakes previously prevented anyone from documenting such animal behavior before, during, and after a quake.

But Grant did, and by sheer luck. Her team was studying common toads in Italy in April 2009 when the amphibians began to disappear from the study site. This didn’t make much sense to her, the toads abandoning a breeding site in the midst of breeding season. So the researchers tracked them. They found that 96 percent of males — who vastly outnumber females at breeding spots — abandoned the site, 46 miles (74 kilometers) from the quake’s epicenter, five days before it struck on April 6, 2009. The number of toads at the site fell to zero three days before the quake [Washington Post]. Grant says her initial reaction to the mass toad dispersal was annoyance—their flight was holding up her research. However, when they began to return the day after the earthquake, things began to make more sense.

Even in this study, where scientists happened to be in the right place at the right time to catalog this long-rumored animal activity, one can’t know for sure that seismic activity is the direct cause of the toads packing up and taking off. In an evolutionary sense, though, it seems logical: If the toads can pick up environmental clues that a quake is imminent they could flee to higher ground, someplace safer from rock falls and other hazards. Says Grant, “Our findings suggest that toads are able to detect pre-seismic cues such as the release of gases and charged particles, and use these as a form of earthquake early warning system” [BBC News].

Related Content:
Discoblog: Chile Quake Shifted Earth’s Axis, Shortened the Length of a Day
80beats: Science Via Twitter: Post-Earthquake Tweets Can Provide Seismic Data
80beats: Where in the World Will the Next Big Earthquake Strike?
80beats: Satellite Images Show the Extent of Haiti’s Devastation
80beats: The Earth *Really* Moved: Chilean Quake Shifted a City 10 Feet to the West

Image: Wikimedia Commons / Gang65

  • JAM

    Well of course they know.

    Male toads compete territorially by having the lowest frequency croaks, and female toads evidently use bass notes as a proxy for size and the ability to hold a territory.

    Rumbles immediately ahead of quakes must sound like the advent of the God Toad to these males, and so they take off.

  • Brian Too

    I never believed in the HypnoToad. Until now. Toad Power!!

  • earthbutcher

    Brian, quit being such a toady!

  • Jen

    Love the Futurama reference!

  • Jeff Wise

    This isn’t the first time that scientists have claimed that the behavior of amphibians anticipated an earthquake; in the ’70s the Chinese government announced that it had predicted the magnitude 7.3 Haicheng quake based, in part, the behavior of frogs and snakes. But there’s plenty of reason to be skeptical. More here:

  • Thomas Roccetta

    @JAM – Your idea ‘sounds’ good, but sound is not suspected, as it would not be present up to weeks before an event.

    The contenders are: gas emissions, other forms of ionization, and electric or magnetic fields.

    The actual paper from this study, as well as several others, is linked at Sapo’s Joint, in the Seismic SEC project thread:

    Skeptics welcome, as I’m one myself.


  • buy chanel purses

    Fortunately for us lovers of timeless classics, the Chanel reissue 2.55 captures the iconic beauty of Coco Chanel’s creation and brings it to the modern day without any additions or omissions from the original.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar