Contrary to Expectations, Rising Seas Aren't Swallowing Pacific Islands

By Andrew Moseman | June 3, 2010 10:27 am

TuvaluThe tiny islands of the Pacific Ocean appear to be the very the picture of climate change vulnerability—some rise such a short distance above current sea level that it seems like any rise would swallow them up. The Earth’s climate system, though, is a great deal more complex than the simplistic rhetoric that fills the political echo chamber. That’s demonstrated again in a new study that argues some the Pacific’s low-lying islands are actually increasing slightly in land area rather than decreasing. It’s good news, yes—but not without caveats.

First, the specifics. Arthur Webb and Paul Kench published their work, based on decades of aerial and satellite photos, in the journal Global and Planetary Change. During the years spanned by those images, the sea level in the area has been rising by about 2 millimeters per year. Nevertheless, they say that 23 of the 27 Pacific islands they studies either held firm in land area or saw a slight increase. How could this be?

Unlike the sandbars of the eastern US coast, low-lying Pacific islands are made of coral debris. This is eroded from the reefs that typically circle the islands and pushed up onto the islands by winds, waves and currents. Because the corals are alive, they provide a continuous supply of material. “Atolls are composed of once-living material,” says Webb, “so you have a continual growth.” Causeways and other structures linking islands can boost growth by trapping sediment that would otherwise get lost to the ocean [New Scientist].

For the people of places like Kiribati, Tuvalu, and the Federated States of Micronesia, who fear the rising seas will swallow up their homes, the idea that these islands might have some kind of resistance to sea level rise is certainly a reprieve. Says Kench:

“We have now got the evidence to suggest that the physical foundation of these countries will still be there in 100 years, so they perhaps do not need to flee their country” [BBC News].

But even if Webb and Kench are right, it wouldn’t put the islands out danger in the longer term. As Kench notes, just having an island isn’t enough:

“An important question is — if islands still exist, will they still be able to carry human communities?” [AFP].

This study measures only total land area. It doesn’t consider the nature of that land, nor the effects of a shape-shifting island on the people who actually live there.

Even on islands where the total land mass is stable or grows, one area may be eroded while another is being added to. It’s not possible to simply move people living in highly urbanised areas to new land, says Naomi Biribo of the University of Wollongong in New South Wales, Australia [New Scientist].

Furthermore, it’s not known whether that influx of coral sediment that recharges the islands with material could keep up if sea level rise accelerated past its current pace. And the coral reefs themselves that supply this material aren’t in the best of shape, either—marine scientists worry that they won’t be able to cope with the increasing acidification of the ocean, which is another effect of rising carbon dioxide levels.

Related Content:
80beats: Forget the Press Coverage: Conflicting Reports on Rising Oceans Are a Fake Controversy
DISCOVER: The Tide Rises—But It’s Not the Same Everywhere
Discoblog: S.O.S.: Global Warming Will Submerge My Country, President Says
Not Exactly Rocket Science: Bacteria and Languages Reveal How People Spread Through the Pacific

Image: Wikimedia Commons

  • Rob Rasner Facebook

    Appreciating the hard work putting into your site as well as in depth data u offer. It is great to arrive upon a different blog site every once in a while that is not similar out of date re-written material. Excellent info. I’ve bookmarked your blog and I am including this Rss feeds to my Google address.

  • )bb0p

    Everybody knows that everything is atop the huge turtle below who is perched atop another turtle.

    As the oceans rise all that is required is for one or more turtles below to move upwards just a teeny-tiny bit to compensate.

    Balderdash, you spew?

    Is it any harder to believe than a talking snake or world-wide inundations?

  • Jo Diggs

    Wow, you would think the islands would be under water now lol.

  • Willis Eschenbach

    This is old news. I pointed this out in 2004 in an article in Energy and Environment, available here.

    I followed that with a discussion of the reasons why atolls “float” here.

    Finally, the Webb/Kench paper above was discussed last year here.

    Discover was way behind the times on this one.


  • racheal

    100 years from now ? What will it matter anyway ? With 7 Billion people this year and 10 Billion by the end of this century.

  • Olimpia Montejo

    I have acquired some new elements from your website about computer systems. Another thing I have always considered is that computer systems have become an item that each family must have for several reasons. They supply you with convenient ways in which to organize households, pay bills, shop, study, focus on music and in some cases watch television shows. An innovative way to complete these tasks has been a notebook. These pcs are portable ones, small, strong and portable.

  • Salut

    Good Day, Dear Blogger! I’m Andu, I live in Israel and I am a Writer. You wrote an excellent article, I have added it to my rss reader. Part of your information is interesting for my forum. I want re-post some of the info to my site. Are you ok with that? I will backlink to your blog.

  • Daren Czajkowski

    The very next time I become familiar with a blog site, I really hope it does not fail myself as a whole lot since this a single. After all, I recognize it was my choice to understand, nonetheless I personally thought you would have got something fascinating to say. All My partner and i listen to can be a few whimpering about something you may well fix if however you were not too hectic looking for interest.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar