Despite the Diasporas, Jewish Genes Worldwide Show Ancient Connections

By Andrew Moseman | June 4, 2010 4:50 pm

synagogueJust how connected are the Jews, genetically speaking? Despite the fact that pockets of Jewish people are spread around the globe, the new genetic analysis by Harry Ostrer and his team says that they share genetic markers that go back thousands of years.

In the study in the American Journal of Human Genetics, Ostrer investigated Jewish people from all over the world:

Historians divide the world’s 13 million living Jews into three groups: Middle Eastern, or Oriental, Jews; Sephardic Jews from Spain and Portugal; and Ashkenazi Jews from Europe [ScienceNOW].

Taking nuclear DNA samples from 237 Jews—some from each group—the team compared them to samples from more than 400 non-Jewish people who lived in the same regions.

The authors found that not only did the Jewish group as a whole constitute a distinct population cluster, but that one by one each of the three Diaspora subgroups themselves also represented a distinct cluster within the larger Jewish group. They further noted that the two largest subgroups — Middle Eastern Jews and European Jews — were found to have split off from one another about 2,500 years back [BusinessWeek].

Within the Jewish subgroups, the study found, people are about as closely related as fourth or fifth cousins. That isn’t a surprise, but the analysis clears up some of the origin stories of different Jewish peoples. That’s especially the case regarding the Ashkenazi, who account for the vast majority of Jews living in the United States.

Some writers, notably Arthur Koestler in his 1976 book The Thirteenth Tribe, have argued that the Ashkenazis stem from a Turkic tribe in Central Asia called the Khazars, who converted to Judaism in the 8th century. And historian Shlomo Sand of Tel Aviv University in Israel argues in his book The Invention of the Jewish People, translated into English last year, that most modern Jews do not descend from the ancient Land of Israel but from groups that took on Jewish identities long afterward [ScienceNOW].

The relatedness is also a confirmation that history can show up in the genome—even specific events.

Historical records suggest there were about 50,000 Ashkenazi Jews in 1400 and that the number expanded to 5 million by 1800, one of the largest population booms ever recorded, Ostrer says. That bottleneck and population explosion is also recorded in the DNA, his team found [Science News].

Related Content:
DISCOVER: Priestly Plague
DISCOVER: Passover and the Plague
NCBI ROFL: Binge Drinking In Jewish and Non-Jewish White College Students
80beats: To Tell An Englishman from an Irishman, Look at Their Genes

Image: flickr / katmere

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Health & Medicine, Human Origins
  • dreamhunk

    The populations that the samples were taken from are a minority within the Jewish population. This study is deeply flawed by selecting only certain segments of the Jewish population that are more likely to be related to the original Middle Eastern genome population. Just look at how many blue eyed, blonde haired Jews there are. They’re obviously not Middle Eastern. The modern day Jew is mostly of Euroean origin rather than Middle Eastern. Jewish people of Middle Eastern descent are now the minority.

  • Shai

    dreamhunk, is the study flawed because its findings contradicts with your personal views? The study included the three major types of Jews, including Ashkenazi Jews.

    “Just look at how many blue eyed, blonde haired Jews there are”

    Oh really? Can you name one famous blonde haired blue eyed Jew?

  • http://wshun.blogspot.com/ wshun

    How about the Jews in China? They looks very Chinese.

  • dreamhunk

    I don’t believe for a second here is why DNA can be faked

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vsnh29ZG-60

    also ancient Hebrews don’t look white forensic science of ancient Hebrews

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8nUr5Lv7-Y

    Number 2 there were no white in the land at the time

    orry Number 2 there were no white people in the land at the time

    if you believe in creationism the map of ham and shem would be like this

    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/archive/1/15/20080322155334!Middle_East_Shem-Ham.jpg

    If you believe in evaluation who was first blacks or whites

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3aTGcv6eFyM&feature=player_embedded

    this is the ultimate proof that Ashkenazi Jews don’t look like this

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GIFQkhDQTh4

    What this article left out is that Jews are genetically identical to Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Also the article left out that Tay Sachs is just as common in the French in Canada and the Cajuns in the United States. I doubt the comment box will allow me to post sources but legitimate science websites can be found with a quick Google search that confirm this.

    also i recommend looking up historians such as Josephus about the ancient Hebrews

  • dreamhunk

    also where is lembra tribe and Ethiopian Hebrews in this picture?

  • cgray

    Hey dreamhunk–go around saying “heil Hitler” much?

  • Maccabee

    To Dreamhunk: Please do not spread your multiple BS. Get a life! You’re mixing Jews with Arabs like yourself which are not Semites AT ALL with an exception of those who forcefully converted to Islam by the Arab savages since Mohammad’s genocidal conquest on a Hebrew City-State Medina which name was from Hebrew name “Medinat” which stands for a State. The official name of the resurrected from ashes Hebrew State on The Holy Land is Medinat Yisroel. The letter “T” in Medinat is not pronounced. Some genetically similar to Jews Arabs was born from Mohammad and his gang members by impregnating captured by fire and sword Jewish girls from Medina and other Hebrew towns in the Middle East. Arabs never belonged to Semites and never prior Mohammad’s conquest got any land or state and relationship to Jews and Abraham. Therefore, Quoran is a fraud.

  • dreamhunk

    I hear the Talmud is very raciest towards blacks

  • dreamhunk

    You did not like my links on racism towards blacks form” white Jews”! But it’s OK for people to call me Hitler. It’s good to know Ethiopian Jews are treated like dirt because of their skin color. There were no white people in the land in those days. I am sorry but it’s the truth. I gave just some of the list of reasons. It has nothing to do with hate it’s called facts and truth.

  • Ani

    http://www.ourbeacon.com

    Knowledge is the only cure for ignorance.

  • cturgenson

    @ Maccabee+cgray

    People defending their position and calling them Hitler is a cheap shot and ignorance on their own. and to call Arabs savages? Sounds like the bile The Nazi’s themselves would spew about Jews being vermin. Ignorance and Racism is no defense to attack a person. This blog is for the purpose of debate. Not scurrying yourselves to put down people or act like a 5 year old bully in a play pen with too much to prove.

    If there’s any rebuttal to dremhunks’ statement (and opinion) do it with intelligence. Don’t let your own insecurity turn you into The Nazi’s and Arab Savages you hate.

  • Araberber

    A group of people can lie about its origin but not about its language, and Yiddish language speaking by the Azkenazis is a slavo germanic language of no Semite origin. Also in this article of Dr Harry Ostrer there ‘s a link not only between Sepharad and Azkenazi but also to Italian.Apparently they share the same kind of genetic basic. So where does it stop at? Taking samples from 200 people out of 15 millions of jews is ”infinitesimal” and can not be a tool of modelisation. Otherwise by chain reaction and extrapolation all the mediteranean people are caucassian and this closes the debate. He took also samples from people from the middle east apparently. Well, most of the libanese and Syrians have turkish origin and this after 6 centuries of Ottoman presence over there. Although the Khazar are known also to be of Turkish origin. If the study would be made on a more wide level it can be a major point. What about the Khazar origin as being from Ham, in the Bible. The canaanite were the first ethnic in Palestine also, and the Turks are from Ham as well.
    Last point, Medina original name was YATRIB built by the arabic tribe of beni Qar wa Qarn who converted to Judaism, nothing else, as about 5 major arabic tribes were Jewish by cnversion. The Arabs are Semite from Ihmael (The book of Jubilee).

  • dreamhunk

    I have done much research or studying of the Hebrew language but people are saying that Hebrews has roots into Africa.

    If you believe in evolution this holds true

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wDknzZ9b6rg

    if you believe in creationism this hold true

    http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_QkkqpkEosyw/SrzXnZZ9R9I/AAAAAAAAA9o/6kR_hDy3-kI/s400/670px-Middle_East_Shem-Ham.jpg

  • dreamhunk

    I just want to add the Arab’s and language where it cam from

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LL-Bn8aNIVU

  • Julian

    Unfortunately, not one of you so called intelligent persons have probably read the original paper regarding the Cohanin Modal Haplotype (“CMH”) and obviously unable to comment on its strengths or limitations. Additionally, I have not seen any comments or references to any scientific studies that contradict the original findings. Like most, you heard something on the news or by some other medium, and you are simply repeating those sources without any independent verification on your part. I will not waste my time citing for you such resources, and they do exist, because most of you have made up your mind already. But try this at least, read the TORAH, it sets forth the true prophecies regarding the Children of Israel and their position in the latter and last days, and then compare the scriptures to those who say they are Israel seeds, and decide for yourself. The Children of Israel are of the seed Shem (EBER)then Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Ya knows his hidden ones and at that of their unveiling many faces will drop when they are revealed. The very people you call a no people, slaves, foresaken, and every byword known to man, are his people, and all nations have had a hand in violence against them, and will pay according to the TORAH. So laugh now while you can, however, the real Israel will be redeemed. Just wait a little longer and believe DNA will not be the litmus test.

  • Rufus

    Julian condemns people for not backing up their statements with sources… and then he follows it up by presenting his archaic version of Mother Goose as being some kind of authoritative source. Well, I have a Spider Man comic here that says you’re full of it, you stupid, superstitious shmendrik.

  • Frances

    Shai: Scarlett Johansson, Lisa Kudrow, Elizabeth Berkley, Dani Behr, Evan Rachel Wood, Ashley Tisdale, Romola Garai, Paul Newman, Kate Hudson…and so on. You idiot.

  • Jazz

    ah, the Tower of Babel rears its ugly head yet again. May I remind all you armchair experts that the first steps toward Wisdom are three words: I DON’T KNOW……. get a little freakin’ humility.

  • madamx

    dreamhunk, read josephus yourself. he gives an eyewitness description of Jesus Christ, a Jew from 2000 years ago, who had BLOND HAIR, fine features, was tall and wasn’t dark skinned. Jews and others in the Levant coast have always had some blond and red haired people although that is the minority coloring for them.

    and here’s an interesting link citing research:

    http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/7061-hair#anchor10

  • madamx

    The letter from Pontius Pilate to Tiberius Caesar

    This is a reprinting of a letter from Pontius Pilate to Tiberius Caesar describing the physical appearance of Jesus. Copies are in the Congressional Library in Washington, D.C.

    TO TIBERIUS CAESAR:

    A young man appeared in Galilee preaching with humble unction, a new law in the Name of the God that had sent Him. At first I was apprehensive that His design was to stir up the people against the Romans, but my fears were soon dispelled. Jesus of Nazareth spoke rather as a friend of the Romans than of the Jews. One day I observed in the midst of a group of people a young man who was leaning against a tree, calmly addressing the multitude. I was told it was Jesus. This I could easily have suspected so great was the difference between Him and those who were listening to Him. His golden colored hair and beard gave to his appearance a celestial aspect. He appeared to be about 30 years of age. Never have I seen a sweeter or more serene countenance. What a contrast between Him and His bearers with their black beards and tawny complexions! Unwilling to interrupt Him by my presence, I continued my walk but signified to my secretary to join the group and listen. Later, my secretary reported that never had he seen in the works of all the philosophers anything that compared to the teachings of Jesus. He told me that Jesus was neither seditious nor rebellious, so we extended to Him our protection. He was at liberty to act, to speak, to assemble and to address the people. This unlimited freedom provoked the Jews — not the poor but the rich and powerful.

    Later, I wrote to Jesus requesting an interview with Him at the Praetorium. He came. When the Nazarene made His appearance I was having my morning walk and as I faced Him my feet seemed fastened with an iron hand to the marble pavement and I trembled in every limb as a guilty culprit, though he was calm. For some time I stood admiring this extraordinary Man. There was nothing in Him that was repelling, nor in His character, yet I felt awed in His presence. I told Him that there was a magnetic simplicity about Him and His personality that elevated Him far above the philosophers and teachers of His day.

    Now, Noble Sovereign, these are the facts concerning Jesus of Nazareth and I have taken the time to write you in detail concerning these matters. I say that such a man who could convert water into wine, change death into life, disease into health; calm the stormy seas, is not guilty of any criminal offense and as others have said, we must agree — truly this is the Son of God.

    Your most obedient servant,
    Pontius Pilate

  • Shakryt

    Nice try. I am not buying it.

    To my knowledge it is not for sale.

    A colleague once told me that it dates from the fourth century but others claim it is just another handy forgery from the Renaissance period. Whatever the case, it seems to be making the rounds on some of the Christian websites of late, usually accompanied by a second “description of Jesus” letter of similar indefinite provenance.

    It’s funny how the effort to make it sound “legitimate” has the opposite impact (kind of like the introduction to most spam emails promoting some hoax.)

  • Robert

    MadamX, your post is an outright lie. Not one historian believes that this “letter” is legitimate; they all agree that it’s a 4th century CE Christian forgery. And your claim that “Copies are in the Congressional Library in Washington, D.C.” is the clincher (there’s no such body; there IS, however, a “Library of Congress”).

  • Michael

    ” Just look at how many blue eyed, blonde haired Jews there are. ” I am blond with blue eyes but still have Middle Eastern Jewish admixture and so? Do you understand Mr Obama had a white mother but he is called “black”? The point is: the looks are deceiving. Look in the genes. To survive holocaust meant to look like the natives. Jews did intermarry. But there is still Middle Eastern blood in them if they have Jewish ancestry, even with blond hair. I can see it on Gedmatch.com admix pages with my own genome and noone can tell it by looking at me. You need to understand how traits are inherited. I do not digest lactose. I have ‘Ashkenazi’ risks for certain diseases. My paternal line is not European but from the ME. But noone can tell this by looking at me and sensing my DNA with the nose.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

80beats

80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »