We’re coming off the first weekend of the NFL season, full of the bone-crunching hits and brain-rattling tackles that fans have come to love. But never before have fans been so attuned to the consequences of that violence, with concussions and other brain injuries in particular gathering more attention than ever at the start of this autumn’s season. And it’s not just at the professional level.
Owen Thomas killed himself this spring. He was 21, a defensive lineman and captain for the University of Pennsylvania football team, and he hanged himself in his apartment. Any out-of-nowhere suicide by a seemingly happy person leaves those left behind grappling for an explanation. But when doctors completed their autopsy of Thomas, they found something startling: evidence of incipient chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), the condition caused by repetitive brain trauma that’s been showing up in many former NFL players.
Doctors in the Boston University group and outside it cautioned that Thomas’s suicide should not be attributed solely or even primarily to the damage in his brain, given the prevalence of suicide among college students in general. But they said that a 21-year-old’s having developed the disease so early raised the possibility that it played a role in his death, and provided arresting new evidence that the brain damage found in N.F.L. veterans can afflict younger players. [The New York Times]
According to the Times, Thomas’ parents—both ministers—wanted his case to become public to alert people about CTE. Thomas reportedly suffered no concussions during his life, but scientists believe the condition is the aggregate of constant collisions throughout a life in football. His mother, Kathy Brearley, says:
“The evidence coming in from Owen — and it will have to be confirmed from much further study — is that this [injury] is not just a question of a person getting big hits and then ignoring them,” Brearley said. “This is a person getting many little hits, starting from a young age. Football linebackers might get 1,000 little hits. Now we’re thinking these are like teaspoons. A thousand teaspoons of water could be the same as a big jug. It’s possible.” [Philadelphia Inquirer]
This season the NFL began dealing more publicly than ever with the big hits—concussions—and placed new posters about brain injury in locker rooms. In the same city where Thomas played his collegiate ball, Philadelphia Eagles starting quarterback Kevin Kolb suffered a concussion in the opening game this weekend; the team and its doctors will have to wrestle with the common question of how long someone must recover from brain injury before they can return to the field.
With all the attention on head injury this year, the million-dollar question hanging in the air is: Is football fixable? Or is brain injury, whether from a huge hit like a concussion or from a thousand small blows, an unavoidable fate for a worrying percentage of those who play the sport?
“It’s pretty hard to make a jump with one case,” said Dr. James Moriarity, the University of Notre Dame’s head physician, who oversees the athletic department’s medical care. “But if it’s true that that happened, it would kill the sport,” he said, referring to an amateur player getting C.T.E. “As a parent, it’s going to be hard to justify kids going out and doing that.” [The New York Times]
Related Content:
DISCOVER: Lights Out: Can Contact Sports Lower Your Intelligence?
80beats: Finally: N.F.L. Issues New Concussion Rules To Protect Players’ Brains
80beats: Is Playing College Football Enough to Damage a Brain for Life?
80beats: Emerging Pattern Shows Football Can Cause Devastating Brain Damage
Image: University of Pennsylvania
September 14th, 2010 at 1:27 pm
I don’t care an iota about football.
That said, if they wanted to do something about brain injury, there could be more done to study recovery in those who already have brain injuries, and for football specifically, they could administer simple cognitive tests, starting with a baseline, and if a player showed significant decrease in cognitive skills at a certain point, they could be removed from play and told to rest for a period of time, periodically being tested until they recover to a baseline score, and in the meantime referred to a neurologist for care.
Have they established precisely which functions decline in ability?
September 15th, 2010 at 6:36 am
There are two ways to use ones brain in colleges:
either learn
or “play” football.
I remember a similar debate from 60ties to 70ties
in Europe about boxing.
As a amateur sport it almost died out since then,
but they import boxers from eastern Europe now.
Regards
Georg
September 15th, 2010 at 2:08 pm
Justin Morneau of the Minnesota Twins baseball team has been out for more than two months for a concussion he suffered while sliding in to second. It’s good that athletes are finally getting some protection. The game should definitely be second to the health of its players.
September 20th, 2010 at 3:07 pm
That’s why they get paid the big bucks. like anything else in this world, it’s risk versus benefit. Sorry kid.
September 20th, 2010 at 9:16 pm
Maybe it’s time to start making the helmets less safe for the players. They feel invincible since the helmets are so safe. If they were less safe there might be less vicious hits because the person inflicting the hit would know there was more of chance that they themselves would be hurt.