An Ocean of Water May Lie Deep Beneath Titan's Lakes of Methane

By Patrick Morgan | May 9, 2011 2:26 pm

What’s the News: Astronomers have known for many years that Saturn’s moon Titan sports lakes of liquid methane. And in the past couple years, scientists have suggested that it also has an underground ocean composed of water and ammonia. Now, based on past observations by NASA’s Cassini spacecraft, astronomers are saying that Titan’s rotation indeed points to an underground sea—and where there’s water, there may also be life. “Our analysis strengthens the possibility that Titan has a subsurface ocean, but it does not prove it undoubtedly,” researcher Rose-Marie Baland told Astrobiology Magazine. “So there is still work to do.”

How the Heck:

  • The researchers started out with two measurements made by the Cassini spacecraft: Titan’s moment of inertia (the moon’s resistance to changes in its rotation), and its obliquity (the angle between the axis of rotation and the axis perpendicular to the orbital plane). Titan’s obliquity, for example is 0.3 degrees, whereas Earth’s is 23 degrees.
  • These two measurements are useful because the Cassini State Model describes a reliable correlation between a moon’s obliquity to its moment of inertia. As Baland told me via email, the model predicted an obliquity of 0.12 degrees, which led her to conclude “that the measured obliquity [of 0.3 degrees] seemed too high.”
  • The astronomers discovered that the best way to reconcile the contradiction between Titan’s obliquity and moment of inertia is to assume that Titan has a solid interior surrounded by liquid water, which is itself surrounded by an ice layer. The estimates of the ocean’s thickness varied greatly, ranging from 3 miles to 264 miles.
  • There was actually one other scenario that fit the astronomers’ model, but that called for a totally solid Titan that was more dense at the surface than at the center, which contradicts “all we know about other planets and satellites and planetary formation processes,” Baland said in a release.

What’s the Context:

  • NASA’s Cassini spacecraft has been studying Saturn and its moons since it locked into orbit in 2004.
  • The first suggestion of an underground ocean of water and ammonia on Titan came in 2008: Comparing the locations of prominent features on Titan’s surface with their past locations, astronomers discovered that many of them had shifted upwards of 19 miles in a geological blink of an eye, suggesting that the crust rested on a liquid.
  • Titan is already a leading candidate for possibly hosting extraterrestrial life; the idea that it may have liquid water may increase its chances even more. If it does sport an ocean of liquid water, Titan would join the ranks of other moons, including Saturn’s Enceladus, that are thought to contain water.

Not So Fast: The astronomers admit that Titan’s rotation could also be explained by a recent collision with a large asteroid or comet, which would have also upset the relationship between the moon’s obliquity and its moment of inertia.

The Future Holds: Now, the astronomers want to use this same method to look at whether Jupiter’s larger satellites—Io, Europa, Ganymede, and Callisto—might also have subsurface water.

Reference: Rose-Marie Baland, Tim Van Hoolst, Marie Yseboodt, Ozgur Karatekin. “Titan’s Obliquity as evidence for a subsurface ocean?” arXiv:1104.2741v1

Image: In this artist’s representation of Titan, the cutaway reveals a light gray layer of ice, a blue layer of ocean underneath, and another light gray layer of ice under that, with a dark gray mixture of rock and ice in the interior. NASA/JPL

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Space
  • http://3dhd1080pmediaplayer.com/platoon Tondre@gmail.com

    omg what the heck is going on! this is a very informative post, thank you for taking the time to write it. just wanted to let everyone know the Olive Garden is giving out free meals for a month for facebook users. check it out americanhealthtoday.com/olive-garden/

  • fintin

    In less than 11 years, we went from vcr’s to tablet computers and finding evidence to liquid water on different moons. What will we find in the next 11 years?

  • Jenn

    I’ve been following research on Titan ever since I graduated high school and my dream job would be to join in on the research once I graduate uni. This is very exciting news; it’s the kind of thing that makes my imagination fly.

  • Bruce

    If you didn’t figure it out, the offer in post #1 is a hoax.

  • http://discovermagazine.com Iain

    fintin – Jimmy Hoffa

  • http://mulberry28.beeplog.com/194015_939283.htm Catalina Kasper

    This kind of actually answered my difficulty, thanks!

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

80beats

80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »