After Tsunami, Japanese People Think Waves Are Less Dangerous. What?

By Veronique Greenwood | December 6, 2011 12:10 pm

earthquake
The wave that washed over the eastern coast of Japan was more than 130 feet high.

You would expect that a disaster of the magnitude of the Tohoku tsunami and earthquake, which killed 15,000 people and caused about $210 billion in property damage, would have people feeling more apt to evacuate when another killer wave approaches. But, strikingly, scientists who interviewed Japanese people a year before the event and afterwards found that the size of the waves they would think dangerous enough to flee had grown. As Adam Mann writes at Wired, people had stopped recognizing the height at which a wave becomes dangerous:

After the 2010 Chilean earthquake, almost exactly one year before the Tohoku disaster, Oki asked Japanese residents a set of questions related to tsunami preparedness. At the time, roughly 70 percent correctly identified that a 10-foot tsunami is a hazard and 60 percent said they would evacuate in the event of one that tall. Even 1.5 feet of swiftly moving water can carry a person off and drown them, and waves only 6.5 feet high can wash away or destroy wooden houses.

But when the same questions were asked again one month after the Tohoku disaster, the numbers had nearly halved. Only 45 percent of respondents knew that a 10-foot tsunami was hazardous and only 31 percent said they would evacuate if they heard a warning that one was coming. People mostly misidentified a 16-foot tsunami as the point at which to evacuate.

The researchers, whose work was presented at the American Geophysical Union meeting this week, think that this effect may be due to what behavioral economists call the anchoring heuristic. Anchoring is what happens when people rely too much on a particular detail while making decisions—for instance, in the classic example, subjects asked what percentage of the United Nations was African countries gave lower percentages if the questioner first asked if it was “greater or less than 10%” and higher if if was “greater or less than 65%.” The Tohoku tsunami was so large–about 130 feet–that it may have dragged people’s expectations of what’s dangerous higher. That’s bad news for tsunami safety, so the researchers suggest some counter-anchoring: tell people in news reports that 6.5 foot waves can wash away houses, to make that the detail that sticks in their minds.

[via Wired]

Image courtesy of Lance Cpl. Ethan Johnson, US Marine Corps, via Wikimedia Commons

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Environment
  • Monique

    I’m not so sure that anchoring is what is happening here. It could be a simple case of “I survived a mindboggling disaster and a wave beyond epic proportions. Now I am not afraid any longer of the “little things”.

    What would be little to them, would still be epic to those of us who had not lived through the Tohoku tsunami.

  • Michelle

    It’s kind of like people in LA calling earthquakes under 5.0 “foot massages” when they can actually cause a heck of a lot of damage, depending on how shallow the earthquake is, how long the shaking goes on, and how sound the structures being shaken are. An earthquake of that magnitude in an area totally unprepared for earthquakes could be a killer quake.

  • Brian Too

    Maybe a lot of the people with better risk appreciation perished? As in preferential mortality. Although I am not able to think of a mechanism by which this might happen, not at the moment anyway.

  • Brevin

    I agree with what the article is saying. The fact that they lived through these experience has blinded them from reality on the dangers of a tsunami.

  • http://www.myresumebook.com Michael

    In response to Moniques comment…..I believe what you are describing is in fact, anchoring. When someone views an event from the standpoint of hindsight they are afforted the oopportunity to approach a situation with a varied notion of what is versus what should be. I agree that if i saw a 130 ft wave a 6 ft wave wouldnt seem so frightening.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

80beats

80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »