Tuberculosis Resistant to All Known TB Drugs Surfaces in India

By Veronique Greenwood | January 14, 2012 9:03 am

When tuberculosis kills lung tissue, it can produce gaping
holes like in the lung on the right.

For a long time, tuberculosis was a gruesome and incurable disease. Antibiotics changed that, but over the last century, as the drugs have been incorrectly used, the tuberculosis bacterium has been developing resistance to them. Multi-drug resistant tuberculosis, which requires a cocktail of many drugs to treat it, has become common. Now Indian doctors have reported in a medical journal that a strain that is resistant to all known drugs for tuberculosis has appeared in Mumbai. Twelve patients so far have been diagnosed with the strain, and it’s likely that they are just the tip of the iceberg in terms of those infected.

At the Superbug blog, Maryn McKenna explains that this is the third time on record that totally drug-resistant TB (TDR-TB) has appeared. The most recent cases were in Iran in 2009, but the earliest cases were in Italy in 2003, in two middle-class Italian women:

They were both diagnosed by local doctors and treated with repeated rounds of the normal TB drugs — three rounds each — before someone recognized that something unusual was happening. They were separately admitted to the Morelli hospital with what the paper calls “a very severe clinical picture (extended bilateral cavities),” which means the TB infection had eaten away the tissue of their lungs, leaving empty dead zones. (If you’d like to see what that looks like, here are some pathology images, not from these women.)

The first woman actually caught multi-drug resistant TB from her mother and gave it to her 14-year-old daughter (who is not the second case in the paper — more on her below). She was treated in three different hospitals, with 17 different antibiotics, for 422 days, or 14 months — and took TB drugs for 94 months before her untreatable disease killed her. The second woman — whether she was related to the first, or lived near her, is not made clear  — was in one other hospital before being admitted to the TB specialty institution in Sondalo. Her inpatient treatment took 625 days and also involved 17 different drugs. After she was discharged, she was on a drug regimen for 60 months before untreatable TB killed her also.

The first woman’s daughter survived her TDR-TB…but only after 3 years of constant treatment and having part of a lung surgically removed. These cases, and those in Iran and India, are reminders of how important it is to treat tuberculosis correctly; thoroughly wiping out the bacterium from each patient can prevent yet more resistant strains from arising. As McKenna writes, the World Health Organization said last year that a third of the countries harboring strains resistant to any of the drugs, let alone all of them, do not have the technology to detect the resistance.

Image courtesy of Yale Rosen /flickr

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Health & Medicine
  • Cathy

    For one of the diseases we’d hope to eventually eradicate, this is a depressing setback.

  • Aidan

    Wow…Maybe with genetic engineering there’s a chance we can create bio-drugs, I think we should seriously consider funding research for it…..As opposed to military spending….

  • Iain

    Worse than a setback, we don’t have anything new in the arsenal and even if we did, somebody would use it incorrectly and create a new strain of resistant bacteria. It’s going to spread folks. Slowly but surely the bacteria are winning the war. Keep on unnecessarily using your anti-bacterial soap, it can’t hurt anything. Can it?

  • Puppetmistress

    I can’t help but think that the abysmal living conditions in India, and the caste system that keeps many people in them, has a lot to do with the developement of this new strain.

  • Dave C.

    (drug resistant TB + planes + trains + automobiles) = Trouble

  • Cody

    Very scary indeed, but there is certainly hope. I’m no expert, but I’m thinking off the top of my head that both bacteriophage therapies and our rapidly increasing understanding and control of molecular and genetic based approaches are promising areas of relevant research.

    If only we didn’t have an electorate so largely illiterate and ignorant of basic science!

  • m

    The disease doesnt soundlike its a planet killer. If it was we would have quaratined Italy by now.

  • Laura

    Why isn’t vitamin D mentioned?

  • Geack

    Puppetmistress –

    So the first known cases were due to the abysmal living conditions of middle-class Italian women? The only “conditions” TB needs are two people in the same place. Drug resistance, as the article points out, comes mainly from sloppy use of existing drugs.

  • Brian

    We can’t keep up…. and time is running out


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar