The Mystery of the Exploding Manure Pits

By Sarah Zhang | February 14, 2012 8:26 am

The only thing worse than a huge stinking pit of manure may be a huge stinking and foaming pit of manure that blows up the barn. Over the past few years, explosions have destroyed several Midwestern pig farms, killing thousands of hogs and causing millions of dollars of damage. Pig farmers and scientists have been at a loss to explain these explosions. Could the culprit be a small microbe?

Methane gas is a natural byproduct of bacteria living in manure pits. It’s odorless (blame hydrogen sulfide for the unpleasant smell), colorless, and just so happens to be very flammable. There has been a recent uptick in reports of foam in these manure pits, rising as high as four feet. What’s trapped in the little bubbles of foam? Methane, of course. With such a high concentration of flammable gas, all it takes is a little spark.

The mystery is why these deep manure pits, standard practice for years, are suddenly foaming over the top. Researchers have noticed a correlation (pdf) between foaming and hogs fed a diet heavy in DDGS, or distiller’s dried grains with solubles. DDGS is the dried leftover mash from making ethanol out of corn. With the dramatic rise of ethanol production in the United States in the past decade thanks to government subsidies, some 3.2 million tons of DDGS is now produced annually. Most of that is fed to cows, but increasingly, also to pigs.

DDGS has a different protein and fat profile than traditional soybean or corn feed, and the FDA has also found significant levels of antibiotics in distiller’s grains. Both of these factors can influence the makeup of the microbial community. Dr. Bo Hu at the University of Minnesota suspects a filamentous bacteria may be the cause of the foaming. His lab is working to identify the bacteria behind it.

Even assuming that this hypothesis is true, we can’t entirely blame a microbe for the problem—after all, it wasn’t they who devised the policy that seems to be giving us tons of excess DDGS and explosive, methane-filled foam.

Image courtesy of MaretH / flickr

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Environment, Living World
  • scribbler

    Talk about some dangerous sh#t…

    Sorry, someone had to do it…


  • Georg

    Are there any regulations on ignition safety around those pits?
    (electric equipment, open fire etc?)

  • Greg

    Maybe this is the microbe that methane producers have been looking for or trying to breed!

  • Ron

    Now we have generated millions of btu’s from manure. This is news? Many companies make simple explosion detection equipment to warn when LEL has been acheive. These people are just to damn cheap to purchase the technology.

  • Brian Too

    Of course if that methane can be captured and used, it goes from a hazard to an asset.

    I saw a profile of an enterprising farmer who did just that.

  • Iain

    @4 Mad Max: Thunderdome – entrepernial psycho was methane farming. So bin dere done dat.
    @3 Nope not looking for an igniter, just something that gives better than a 10% energy return.
    @2 Yes.
    @1 Correct. Serious sh#t indeed.

    My opinion? What has changed is always the question to ask when something suddenly goes sideways. This ethanol corn leftovers feed does seem like a good lead. The pigs are lighting their farts now. Why?

  • Sharon

    Does this also happen with horse manure piles?

  • Johnny

    For the cost of a 20 dollar ventilation fan, you could easily push that methane outdoors and solve the problem. This problem is easily avoidable and very cheaply fixed.

  • Wang-Lo

    I anticipate a future news item:

    adolescent boys banned from purchasing fireworks

    DDGS available at the chemist or feed store

    middle school lavatory plumbing remains at risk



Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar