For an Isolated Tribe, Time Follows the Terrain, and the Future is Uphill

By Valerie Ross | June 1, 2012 11:22 am

When we say “I knew him way back when,” or “the best years are still ahead of you,” we’re using space to set up a timeline, with the past trailing behind us and the future stretching forward. Scientists long assumed that all people envisioned time that same way. But more recent studies have shown that’s not the case: Mandarin Chinese speakers may refer to the past as above them and the future as below. When the Pormpuraawans, a tribe in the Australian outback, think of time’s physical progress, they leave their own location out of it: time flows from east to west, regardless of which way they themselves are facing.

Now, researchers have worked with a group of people who seem think of time’s movement through space in yet another way: by referencing not relative locations or cardinal directions, but topographical features. For the Yupno people in Papua New Guinea, rather than marching ever onward, time wends its way uphill.

The Yupno tribe lives in the mountains of northern Papua New Guinea where, aside from limited contact with teachers and missionaries, they are isolated from the rest of the world. The researchers interviewed 27 adults from the tribe, asking them about various events in the past and future. They found that, wherever they were, the Yupno tended to gesture downhill, towards the mouth of a particular river, when talking about the past, and uphill, towards the river’s source, when referencing the future. Their mental timeline seemed to track the river’s course: The Yupno’s gestures didn’t just indicate opposite directions on a straight line, as you might think, but instead followed the curve of the river, as shown below:

When the researchers repeated the study inside, the results were somewhat different: The Yupno pointed toward the doorway to indicate the past, and opposite it to indicate the future. But the researchers had found, in a previous study, that Yupno tended to think of their doorways as “downhill,” so they might simply be remapping the same sort of timeline onto a smaller space. (It’s also worth nothing that western countries are unusually consistent in our perception of time as a behind-to-before street: There tends to be a lot more variability in these measures in cultures with less education, where timelines and their attendant metaphors aren’t taught and standardized in school, or in languages like Mandarin, which offer a variety of different metaphors to talk about time.)

While this is a small observational study, and thus can only hint at the Yupno’s perceptions, it offers an intriguing window into an entirely new way of envisioning the passage of time. Time and time again, psychologists and anthropologists are finding that many human thoughts and behaviors that were assumed to be universal are anything but. A new way of looking at the world may lie just up ahead—or below, or westward, or uphill.

[via New Scientist]

Time image via Shutterstock

  • Nic Scroggs

    Thanks for adding the “may” to the sentence about mandarin speakers. Although ‘up’ and ‘down’ are common ways to refer to time, they are by no means the only ‘directional’ words mandarin speakers will use to refer to time. 上个月 shang ge yue – last month – uses ‘above’ to mean last, and 下个月 xia ge yue – next month – uses ‘below’ to mean next.

    However, 以后 (yi hou) uses ‘BEHIND’ to mean ‘after’ and 以前 (yi qian) used ‘IN FRONT’ to mean ‘before’. While this is a horizontal progression, it is still different than English. I like to think of it like this; just as you cannot see what’s behind you, you also cannot see the future.

  • http://n/a RICHARD D. STACY

    Is there a psychological connection to the custom of thinking that “heaven is up” and “hell is down” ?

  • Bruce Cox

    The more we learn, the more ignorant we realize we are/have been. Which gives me great pleasure to see our arrogance falter.

  • jimbo

    In some ways their way of looking at how time flows makes sense. It is harder to go up hill then down or stay in place. Like wise as you grow older it is harder on you, so I can see how that works.

  • Iain

    TYPO also worth nothing that western

  • ururu

    What about “planning ahead”? and “before” which is also used to define “in front” spatially.

    The English language views the past as behind you and the future as ahead, but in terms of chronological order, doesn’t it view the relatively past events as being in front of latter ones?

    I wonder if that’s universal, and if not, how other languages and cultures perceive it.

    Speaking of which, I think the Indonesian language does not have any concept of spatial – time association. I might be wrong.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


80beats is DISCOVER's news aggregator, weaving together the choicest tidbits from the best articles covering the day's most compelling topics.

See More

Collapse bottom bar