The horoscope I would write

submit to reddit

Yup. Pretty much dead on accurate.

June 13th, 2007 10:39 AM by Phil Plait in Antiscience, Astronomy, Cool stuff, Debunking, Humor, Science, Skepticism | 30 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

30 Responses to “The horoscope I would write”

  1. 1.   Brum Says:

    Fortunately, I’m a Leo. Leo’s don’t believe in astrology…

  2. 2.   Sticks Says:

    And of course the google adds generated by this blog are for Free Horoscopes.

    Duh!

  3. 3.   Brett McCoy Says:

    Right on!

  4. 4.   Kevin Says:

    They say I’m a “Leo” because of when I was born, but that’s them.

    I don’t however, believe the Gemini panel on there….

    The position of the stars has zero bearing on your life.

    I know for a fact that the position of the stars has a bearing on my life — those stellar positions in the sky tell me when I can go out and observe specific objects!!! :)

  5. 5.   Thomas Siefert Says:

    When I tell people that astrology is a pile of kolort (in the new Firefly series all the swearing will be in Danish), they tell me that I am a doubting Thomas.
    well thank you very much is my reply, that guy had a point.

  6. 6.   Quiet_Desperation Says:

    Hey, I posted the link to this when Phil was moving.

  7. 7.   Evolving Squid Says:

    The position of the moon and the sun had a big bearing on my life, when I was kayaking in the Bay of Fundy.

  8. 8.   Cameron Says:

    Heh heh…

    This reminds me of two things: The Weird Al Yankovic song “Horoscope for Today,” which is now stuck in my head, and the excellent, nationally televised debunking of astrology by the one and only Bill Nye he Science Guy on “The Eyes of Nye.”

  9. 9.   N. Johnson Says:

    >This reminds me of two things: The Weird Al Yankovic song “Horoscope for Today,” which is now stuck in my head…

    And now it’s stuck in mine. Thanks a lot. :-)

  10. 10.   JanieBelle Says:

    I’d like those astrology folks to figure out how to cast my horoscope. I was both conceived and born in late June of last year, but my birthdate is Valentine’s Day 1989.

    That ought to keep ‘em arguing for years!

    LOL

  11. 11.   Shawn S. Says:

    Keep THEM arguing? I’m trying to figure out the circumstances of your birth and my head hurts. Damn non-linear-time fertility clinics!

  12. 12.   Shawn S. Says:

    OHHHH I GET IT! You were born in the TARDIS! XD

  13. 13.   Jerry Anning Says:

    Phil , check out this post on an archaeology blog. http://archaeoblog.blogspot.com/2007/06/two-boooos-for-history-channel-i.html
    I saw those pieces of garbage and this article actually gives them way too much credit. The “science” was beyond absurd. The History Channel really needs a good corrective BA style fact check, and a strong admonition to run show ideas through the woo filter if they want any of their serious stuff to have any credibility.

  14. 14.   Anne Says:

    The comic strip that’s from, Kevin and Kell, is nice, if occasionally a bit twee. In spite of the cute talking animals, it takes on issues of prejudice and discrimination, making it “family-friendly” by casting it all in terms of species.

  15. 15.   Sean O'Hara Says:

    I prefer the horoscope Swift published when he was writing a parody almanac, in which he foretold that a famous astrologer of the day would die on a specific date. When he didn’t, Swift published a screed declaring the astrologer dead and ordering him to stop walking around London.

  16. 16.   Murff Says:

    The picture on the Aquarius one was priceless!

  17. 17.   n1n0 Says:

    gooood!

  18. 18.   Microsiervos Says:

    EL mejor horóscopo del mundo…

    The Kevin & Kell Horoscope © Bill HolbrookAries: Haz con tu vida lo que te plazca. La astrología es un engaño.Tauro: Sí, no es más que un mito.Geminis: La posición de las estrellas no tiene ninguna influencia en tu vida.El……

  19. 19.   Izzy Says:

    Awesome!

  20. 20.   JanieBelle Says:

    Hi Shawn!

    Though I am quite the fan of the good Doctor, I’m afraid my origin and circumstance is much more mundane.

    Nope, perfectly linear, in this time line, in this reality, and literally and factually correct in every detail.

    I just turned 18 on Valentine’s Day, but am just now approaching the first anniversary of my conception and birth (two day gestation) in about two weeks.

    It’s a very creative digital mystery I suppose, but a little research quickly clears it up.

    Kisses,
    JanieBelle

  21. 21.   captain swoop Says:

    By coincidence, ‘In Our time’ on radio 4 was a discussion on the origins of Asrtology and why it fell out of favour in the 17th and 18th Centuries.

  22. 22.   JanieBelle Says:

    @ Jerry Anning,

    Holy crap, the History Channel, Discovery Channel, TLC… they’ve all gone to pot lately IMHO. It’s both frustrating and disappointing. (And don’t even get me started on Sci-Fi and that “Pro-Rasslin’” crap.) It’s really getting hard to find any quality programming at any given point in the day any more.

    Pouty Kisses,
    JanieBelle

  23. 23.   Gary Ansorge Says:

    See Steven Colbert, John Stewart and Bill Maher for quality programming. Yes, there are people in the entertainment industry with a significant degree of intellect. Now all we need is a news program hosted by Cheech and Chong,,,

    Gary 7

  24. 24.   Irishman Says:

    JanieBelle, the best I can come up with is that after conception, you were transplanted to a surrogate. 2 day gestation has be baffled.

  25. 25.   JanieBelle Says:

    Oh, Geez.

    I was trying hard not to be such a blatant and explicit blog whore here, people. (Not that I’m not a blog whore, of course. I just prefer to be slightly more subtle about it…)

    Dr. BA, please forgive me for this, just this once?

    All Good Things

  26. 26.   JanieBelle Says:

    Gary mentioned,

    See Steven Colbert, John Stewart and Bill Maher for quality programming. Yes, there are people in the entertainment industry with a significant degree of intellect. Now all we need is a news program hosted by Cheech and Chong,,,

    Oh, all with you there. ’specially the Cheech and Chong do Nightly News thing.

    It just sometimes seems like if you turn on the Discovery Channel, you’d think you’re seeing the Home Improvement Channel. If you turn on the History Channel, you’d think you’re seeing The Bible Is A History Book Channel or Pseudo-Science and Psychics R Us. If you turn on TLC, you’d think it was the Food Network or the Entertainment Weekly Channel.

    The Science Channel is somewhat better, but much of it is more like The Big Metal Stuff Engineering Channel.

    Kisses,
    JanieBelle

  27. 27.   JanieBelle Says:

    Geez o Pete. To read all that, you’d think I must be in a particularly negative mood today.

    Sorry, didn’t intend to convey that to anyone.

    I LOVE YOU ALL!!!!
    ;)

    Kisses,
    JanieBelle

  28. 28.   Lurchgs Says:

    I am SO glad I’m not the only one who reads Kevin & Kell (though I read that just before I go read Sluggy Freelance).

    Remember, there is no God but Bun-Bun.

    As for TV, I’ve pretty much given up on it. Stargate has gone down the swirly. Heck, with Bones in summer reruns, there isn’t anything at all worth watching.

  29. 29.   Rob Says:

    One of my favourite cartoons from many years ago appeared in “Punch”. It had a typical English couple at home looking at TV where the news announcer said: “The science of astrology took a huge leap forward when, as predicted, everyone born under the sign of Aries (cannot remember which zodiac sign so just insert random one here) was run over by an out-of-control milk float”. Pretty much sums it up.

  30. 30.   Laser Potato Says:

    Turns out a music video’s been made for it:
    http://www.albinoblacksheep.com/flash/horoscope

    “Now you may find it inconceivable or at the very least a bit unlikely that the relative position of the planets and the stars could have a special deep significance or meaning that exclusively applies to only you, but let me give you my assurance that these forecasts and predictions are all based on solid scientific documented evidence so you would have to be some kind of moron not to realize that every single one of them is absolutely tru-WHERE WAS I?”

    The Mothman and UFOs were a nice touch.

Leave a Reply