DISCOVER Magazine. Science, Technology and The Future
Current Issue
Subscribe Today »
  • Renew
  • Give a Gift
  • Archives
  • Customer Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • Health & Medicine
  • Mind & Brain
  • Technology
  • Space
  • Human Origins
  • Living World
  • Environment
  • Physics & Math
  • Video
  • Photos
  • Podcast
  • RSS
Cosmic Variance
« KC and USC
Magnetism in Another Time »

Kansas feels the heat

by Sean Carroll

People who care about science are not sitting quietly as the Kansas board of education eviscerates the state science curriculum. First the American Association for the Advancement of Science and other organizations refused to participate in the sham hearings that had a foregone conclusion. This is a potentially risky strategy, aiming to deny an aura of respectability to the forces of superstition, but running the risk of giving them free rein to spout their nonsense unchecked. It seemed to work in this case, though, as many commentators were forced to take the initiative to point out how non-scientific the testimony was. (Here are more resources from AAAS.)

Now the National Academy of Sciences and the National Science Teachers Association are refusing to let Kansas use their materials in courses.

Two leading science organizations have denied the Kansas Board of Education permission to use their copyrighted materials as part of the state’s proposed new science standards because of the standards’ critical approach to evolution.

The rebuke from the two groups, the National Academy of Sciences and the National Science Teachers Association, comes less than two weeks before the board’s expected adoption of the controversial new standards, which will serve as a template for statewide tests and thus have great influence on what is taught.

Kansas is one of a number of states and school districts where the teaching of evolution has lately come under assault. If adopted, its change in standards will be among the most aggressive challenges in the nation to biology’s bedrock theory.

The copyright denial could delay adoption as the standards are rewritten but is unlikely to derail the board’s conservative majority in its mission to require that challenges to Darwin’s theories be taught in the state’s classrooms.

Again, a risky strategy, but potentially a very effective one. These materials are heavily used throughout the standards, so it will create a major headache for the board to remove them. It’s about time that pro-science groups stood up and started using the weapons at their disposal — the other guys don’t fight fair, we need to put everything we can into this battle.

Update: PZ Myers and Josh Rosenau are upset about the sloppy writing in the article. Fair enough.

Share

October 28th, 2005 10:19 AM
in Science and Politics | 4 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

4 Responses to “Kansas feels the heat”

  1. 1.   Gavin Polhemus Says:
    October 28th, 2005 at 2:55 pm

    There is a nice related article, “Is U.S. becoming hostile to science?” at CNN.com. Since this is a physics focused blog, I have to quote one passage:

    Other polls show that only around a third of American adults accept the Big Bang theory of the origin of the universe, even though the concept is virtually uncontested by scientists worldwide.

    We have a lot of work to do out there.

    Gavin

  2. 2.   SM Says:
    October 28th, 2005 at 11:59 pm

    How come the schools in Kansas can’t be stripped of their accredidation? I think if kids in Kansas stop being accepted to universities, parents will be up in arms in no time.

  3. 3.   bittergradstudent Says:
    October 29th, 2005 at 8:46 pm

    I think this strategy may be too risky to be tenable–it is basically daring some private industry to come up the Kansas school board with “replacement” materials–potentially vastly expanding the creationist infrastructure. If they fail in cowing Kansas into position on this one, it will make it all the easier for another state to follow in Kansas’s footsteps.

  4. 4.   Richard Says:
    December 6th, 2005 at 6:04 pm

    The religious studies professor in Kansas, Mirecki, who “recently wrote online that he planned to teach intelligent design as mythology in an upcoming course” was beaten up by some rednecks:

    http://media.ljworld.com/flattened/mirecki_2005_12_06.html





    • Cosmic Variance Cosmic Variance is a group blog by people who, coincidentally or not, all happen to be physicists and astrophysicists:
      • Daniel Holz
      • JoAnne Hewett
      • John Conway
      • Julianne Dalcanton
      • Mark Trodden
      • Risa Wechsler
      • Sean Carroll
      Our day (and night) jobs notwithstanding, the blog is about whatever we find interesting — science, to be sure, but also arts, politics, culture, technology, academia, and miscellaneous trivia. We have similar outlooks on many things, widely disparate opinions about others, and will do our best to keep the discourse reasonably elevated.
    • Recent Posts

      • How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • A 3.8-Sigma Anomaly
      • Boycott Elsevier
      • Mind = Blown
      • Unsolicited Advice XIII: How to Craft a Well-Argued Proposal
      • Your Favorite Deep, Elegant, or Beautiful Explanation
      • Good News/Bad News: Nobel Edition
      • Do I Not Live?
      • Noisy Systems and Wandering Canines
      • Happy Birthday, Stephen Hawking
      • Predictions for 2012
      • A Year Well Blogged
      • Happy Holidays!
      • Last-Minute Shopping List
      • The Girl With Various Interesting Qualities
    • Recent Comments

      • jammer on Mind = Blown
      • Kaleberg on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • David Brown on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • Andrew on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • steven johnson on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • Albert Z on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • Phillip Helbig on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • Marko on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • Marko on How To Think About Quantum Field Theory
      • JoeTurpin on Your Favorite Deep, Elegant, or Beautiful Explanation
      • Valdis Kletnieks on A 3.8-Sigma Anomaly
      • Bob Kirshner on A 3.8-Sigma Anomaly
    • Facebook

    • Archives By Date

    • Archives By Category

    • Useful Pages

      • Home
      • RSS Feed
      • Comments Feed
      • About
      • Links (Blogroll)
      • Guest Bloggers
      • Equations Using LaTeX
      • Facebook page and group
      • Twitter
      • Goodies Store
      • Google Blog Search
      • Technorati Profile
      • Bloglines citations
    • Site Meter



  • Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Copyright © 2012, Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Privacy - Terms - Reader Services - Subscribe Today - Advertise - About Us