We propose here a different alternative: Apply string theory to energies beyond the Planck scale, which are not observable even in principle. Then one avoids the objection of the untimeliness of string theory, since it never will be relevant, and thus one may as well work on it now as later.

Was there clues then by others to have understood such a thing inside the blackhole eh? That we now understand where these limitations are on Mother’s cooking with Paste? Always bring things to a slow boil?

So what else is out there other then “theoretics cooking” in the kitchen? What is Cooking Fast Theory contrived by the bakers, doing now?

1) It is not true that string theory is currently our best idea about how to quantize gravity. In fact string theory does NOT quantize gravity we observe in real experiments. M-theory (M for Magic, Metaphysics, Mad, ‘Mierda’, Money, etc.) does not better.

2) It would be interesting to know exactly where and when pure string theory ideas/techniques have benefited other fields such as mathematics, cosmology, and particle physics. For example in math, the contribution of string theory is of the order of 1/100 aprox. if one use number of Field Medals as ‘thermometer’…

Personally, i believe that none Field was awarded to string theory work and therefore the contribution to math on Field Medals is 0 but…

3) Regarding QCD, would be interesting to know exactly what benefited to what: QCD to string theory or string theory to QCD? Perhaps the history looks more as QCD –> ST –> QCD.

4) About branes. Really someone still think that a vibrating multidimensional membrane can modell particles? I am atonished! Has anyone obtained non supersimmetric 4D particle realistic modes from brane theory? Then what is the interest in testing ‘new physics’? First obtain the current Standard Model from brane theory and after, only after, predict any thing new to be observed…

5) About the arrogance of string theorists that has a simple explanation. It is an outcome of basic postulates of string theory. See Woit blog

http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=293

for some of those laws. Some examples of string theory postulates are

- God is a string theorist. If God is not one then he is not so smart.

- String theorists are smartest people of this universe. Landscape corolary: and of the rest of infinite others.

- String theory is not defined, therefore you can define string theory as you want

- Remember if you are a string theorist, you are smart. Corolary: this also apply if your contribution to science was zero

- Any rival theory, if good, is part of string theory if not, then it is another example of how smart you are

- Publish papers claiming contrary things. For example, in a paper string theory is unitary in other it is not and in other paper it is a mixture of two last ones. Then string theory always win. Corolary: you are more smart still

- If string theory is incompatible with experiments, the problem is with the experiment. It was incorrect, or done to a very low energy. Corollary: by each time that energy level to observe effects is sited to more higgher level, smart level is also.

6) String theory is a completely outdated and simplistic framework that, in the best of cases, can explain nothing. Even if some day string theory is substituted by any other NEW theory (probably will be called ’string theory’), that theory will be not a theory of everything, just a theory of some basic properties of simple matter.

More is different

[P.W. Anderson]

Juan R.

Center for CANONICAL |SCIENCE)

So, people have asked, is string theory worth studying? I would answer yes, for two reasons. One has already been given, namely, that string theory is currently our best idea about how to quantize gravity.

Quite a few people evidently think of string theory as one reasonable hope but possibly not the BEST hope for quantizing gravity. They apparently see other approaches as more promising, or currently making more rapid progress, or for some other reason more worth working on.

http://insti.physics.sunysb.edu/~siegel/plan.html

That made my day!!