DISCOVER Magazine. Science, Technology and The Future
Current Issue
Subscribe Today »
  • Renew
  • Give a Gift
  • Archives
  • Customer Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • Health & Medicine
  • Mind & Brain
  • Technology
  • Space
  • Human Origins
  • Living World
  • Environment
  • Physics & Math
  • Video
  • Photos
  • Podcast
  • RSS
Cosmic Variance
« Waiter, There’s a Derivative in my Cereal
Reprieve for Fermilab; Whither ITER? »

A Historical Science

by Mark Trodden

This morning has me packing and preparing for a trip to England, to take part in the annual editorial board meeting of the New Journal of Physics and then to spend a few days visiting my family. A additional bonus is that a good friend of mine, a historian, will be in London at the same time, and I’m looking forward to getting well and truly screwed by the exchange rate when we sample some of London’s culinary delights. I expect that, as usual, our conversation will turn to some of the comparisons and contrasts between our fields.

So it was fun to see that Sky & Telescope is reporting on work by Don Olson and collaborators at Texas State University, in which they claim to have laid to rest the historical question of precisely when Julius Caesar landed in Britain. The Roman invasion has had open questions associated with it because although Caesar approached the white cliffs of Dover, Celtic warriors armed with spears (no doubt chanting “Romanes Eunt Domus“) deterred him from landing. The choice of an alternate site was guided by the tides, and it is this that has apparently opened the door to astronomers.

Olson calculated that the complex tidal patterns in August 2007 would mimic extremely closely those in August of 55BC, and performed several experiments in the English Channel during that month. He was fortunate to have at his disposal modern astronomical technology, the use of which was pioneered by Newton, and which has been perfected more recently by G. Smith – the so-called apple. Dropping this “apple” into the ocean from the pier at Deal (where Caesar is thought to have landed), Olson and team were able to understand the dates on which it would have been reasonable for the tides to bring the Romans from Dover to Deal. The answer appears to be August 22-23. As the BBC reports

This is the beach preferred by most historians but rejected by tide experts in the past. A modified reading of Caesar’s reference to the “night of a full Moon” also leads to the August 22-23 date, Dr Olson claimed.

“The scientists were right about the tidal streams and so were the historians about the landing site,” he explained.

So there’s a bit of something here for both my historian friend and me.

Share

July 2nd, 2008 7:43 AM
in Science, Science and Society | 2 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

2 Responses to “A Historical Science”

  1. 1.   Michael Williams Says:
    July 2nd, 2008 at 8:34 am

    A neurosurgeon is having lunch with a historian. The neurosurgeon explains that he intends to build a good practice and make a name for himself before retiring and writing a history of the field. The historian responds that he plans to retire and take up neurosurgery.

    (via http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/001475)

  2. 2.   John R Ramsden Says:
    July 2nd, 2008 at 9:01 am

    Having claimed to have solved the problem of Julius Caesar’s landing site, perhaps Olson & co could turn their attention to the potentially more lucrative project of finding the treasure lost by King John in the Wash (a marine estuary in Eastern England):

    From http://new.edp24.co.uk/content/PlaceinHistory/content/41KingJohn.aspx

    If the treasure is really buried somewhere near modernday Sutton Bridge, then it would be covered by 20 feet or more of silt, so we can all put our metal detectors away. But that hasn’t stopped people looking. During the 1930s a group of American treasure hunters paid local farmers 2s 6d an acre for their help in looking for the jewels at Walpole Island. More recently a team from Nottingham University took soil samples in a bid to discover the causeway the wagon train used. The search goes on. We may never know the truth.

    I very much doubt there’s anything to find, or ever was, but who knows?





    • Cosmic Variance Cosmic Variance is a group blog by people who, coincidentally or not, all happen to be physicists and astrophysicists:
      • Daniel Holz
      • JoAnne Hewett
      • John Conway
      • Julianne Dalcanton
      • Mark Trodden
      • Risa Wechsler
      • Sean Carroll
      Our day (and night) jobs notwithstanding, the blog is about whatever we find interesting — science, to be sure, but also arts, politics, culture, technology, academia, and miscellaneous trivia. We have similar outlooks on many things, widely disparate opinions about others, and will do our best to keep the discourse reasonably elevated.
    • Recent Posts

      • Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Higgs Ripples in the Koi Pond
      • Dark Matter vs. Modified Gravity: A Trialogue
      • The Case for Naturalism
      • Avengers Assemble!
      • Astronomy at the Philadelphia Science Festival
      • Wrapping Up the Semester: Fests, Workshops and Exams
      • A Universe from Nothing?
      • PhD Comics Explains the Higgs Boson
      • What Particle Are You?
      • The Particle At the End of the Universe
      • Aiming at Different Audiences
      • Puzzles!
      • Jon Stewart Doesn’t Understand How Science Works Even a Little Bit
      • Is Physics Among the Dysfunctional Sciences?
    • Recent Comments

      • Marc Sher on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Len Ornstein on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • PJM on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • AnonymousSnowboarder on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Thomas on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Brett on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Steuard on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • max on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Ron Seadler on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Maia Miret on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Sean Carroll on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
      • Chris on Guest Post: Marc Sher on the Nonprofit Textbook Movement
    • Facebook

    • Archives By Date

    • Archives By Category

    • Useful Pages

      • Home
      • RSS Feed
      • Comments Feed
      • About
      • Links (Blogroll)
      • Guest Bloggers
      • Equations Using LaTeX
      • Facebook page and group
      • Twitter
      • Goodies Store
      • Google Blog Search
      • Technorati Profile
      • Bloglines citations
    • Site Meter



  • Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Copyright © 2012, Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Privacy - Terms - Reader Services - Subscribe Today - Advertise - About Us