The Mother of All Apples Is Disappearing

By John Wenz | June 8, 2017 9:49 am

You probably haven’t eaten this fruit before, but you may have one of its descendants in your house right now. (Credit: petrOlly/Flickr)

In the wilds of Kazakhstan, there’s an unassuming tree that bears an unassuming fruit. Like many plant species, development encroaches on its usual territory while climate change makes it harder for the tree to thrive and bear healthy yields of fruit.

You probably haven’t eaten this fruit before, but you may have one of its descendants in your house right now. After all, its children have more than 7,500 varieties in an assortment of colors and tastes and textures.

This plant is Malus sieversii. It’s one of the last truly wild apples. But development encroaches on its territory in Kazakhstan, while a hiatus on coal energy has led some Kazakhs to begin burning wood charcoal again — going after the wood of the tree, leaving old growth dead. Too many attempts at re-hybridizing it with other varieties are weakening its genetic heritage. Agricultural expansion is razing the untamed land the apple thrived on. Animals picking at the fruit are leaving the trees barren. And of course, there’s the ever-looming threat of becoming another climate casualty. 

The Garden of Eden

Liz Rattan spent a few years in Kazakhstan teaching English, and saw the way the apple is woven into the culture. After all, one of its biggest cities is named Almaty— “alma” is the Turkish word for apple.

It’s a virtual bounty of apples there. They’re all over grocery stores and road sides. Wilder cultivars sit alongside the granny smiths we all know and occasionally love. Ratan says where she lived, the apples were supplied by three Tajiki vendors who picked the fruit regionally.

These aren’t the massive Honeycrisps sitting in your grocery aisle, though. They’re smaller. More nuanced.

“The best way to tell the difference between commercially grown apples and the local varieties is essentially a size difference,” Ratan says. Local apples are not gargantuan; they are fresh and crisp; and they often have leaves intact on their stems. Lots of people also sell their garden variety backyard apples at the Zeloni (Green in Kazakh) bazaar in plastic bags, by the kilo.”

Others have referred to the territory containing M. sieversii as an “Eden of Apples.” This area covers several other former Soviet republics — Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Uzbekhistan — and a narrow area of China. But according to the IUCN, the wild apple has declined by 70 percent over the last 30 years.

That means that, like some agricultural animals, we may soon only have the more domestic apple as M. sieversii loses territory and is hybridized out of existence.

The Tree of Life

The apple has always held an importance in human affairs, but it’s never quite risen to staple crop status. Joanna Crosby, a faculty member in the history department at the University of Essex, wrote her dissertation on the historical heritage of apples as a cultural symbol. She says that it’s never been a staple crop, that a bad harvest year means “the villagers endure a winter without cider, the pigs will be a bit thinner (pigs love windfalls) but it’s not the same as the grain harvest failing.”

“That’s why I find all the apple symbolism so interesting, in that it seems out of proportion to the apple’s importance in the diet,” she says.  

Indeed, an apple a day may keep the doctor away (citation is awaiting peer review), but it’s chiefly a sort of healthy snack. But it’s also a symbol of virility, sin, of beauty and more. The Asgardian gods kept themselves alive thanks to the apple, so you can thank the apple for Thor. As Crosby points out, the Tudors had cultivators in their orchards specifically in service to the royalty, and the Greeks, Romans and Egyptians were early cultivators.

“[A]pples have been found in prehistoric graves and in the middens of bronze age settlements. It is a fruit that has been eaten ever since wild apples evolved in the ‘Fruit Forest’,” Crosby says. “This was a vast tract of forest, covering nearly all of what is now Eastern Europe and into Asia.”

The Secret History

So how did we get from the wilds of the Kazakh apple to the dreaded red delicious?

Amandine Cornille, a food genetics researcher at ETH Zurich, has extensively studied the genetic heritage of the apple. It seems that the apple as we know it came from the M. sieversii with input from a few cousin species. It’s sort of like modern humanity. We are Homo sapiens largely, but we have genetic input from Neanderthals and Denisovans that end up a fraction of our DNA.

In the end, Cornille and her coauthors came to the conclusion that the biggest genetic contribution came from Malus sylvestris. Unlike M. sierversii, M. sylvestris is far from palatable.

“You have two varieties, the Caucusus and the European one, and these two are very little apples,” Cornille says. “The European one is one to two centimeters, and I can tell you, if you try to eat them, the next day they’re not very crunchy. They’re not very tasty. Some people make a marmalade, where they add a lot of sugar, but you cannot eat them. Mainly it’s the deer that eat them in the wild.”

Somehow though, around 3,000 to 4,000 years ago, the European crab apple and the wild Kazakh apple began their agricultural courtship and created the cultivated apple you have in your lunchbox today. When looking at M. sierversii, it’s obvious that it’s the progenitor.

“That’s why we found out it was a different species, because in this area (of central Asia) you can find more of a diversity and morphology of apples,” Cornille says. “You can find apples that look like the European one, very little, and you can find very big ones that are very tasty and look like golden delicious.”

Of course, Michael Pollan wrote in a 1998 article that M. serversii wasn’t always that great itself. He wrote, “Many of the ones I tasted were unqualified spitters, and only a few of the oldies could hold a candle to, say, the Macoun or the Jonagold. Yet the old apples offer a striking catalogue of flavors (apples tinged with nutmeg and riesling, mango and nuts) and colors, intriguing qualities that have been trampled in the rush to breed apples brimming with sugar and red pigment.”

He was tasting the apple at a Cornell University plantation in upstate New York devoted to saving M. sierversii and cross breeding it to be a little more palatable. The program is also essential to keeping our modern apple alive by introducing pest resistant qualities only available in M. sierversii.

Cornille says efforts are already underway in Iran to preserve seeds of these apples, similar to the Cornell effort. You can even buy the plant (or its seeds at times) online. Some of those come directly from the New York State Agriculture Experiment Station.

There’s an uncertain future for the wild apple, but right now, it’s not yet truly endangered. With the right conservation efforts, it could rebound. But if its current trajectory continues, the plant may well dwindle away into nothing, the only evidence of its existence hiding in history books and more primitive varieties of cultivated apples like the golden russet.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Environment, Top Posts
MORE ABOUT: plants
  • Doltsbane

    I think you meant descendants, not ancestors.

  • Uncle Al

    the dreaded red delicious” amen. When last did you sniff an apple that was intensely perfumed “apple”?

    Eat a homegrown and vine-ripened heirloom seed Cherokee Purple tomato, then regret all of your prior life consuming commercial flavorless slimers.

    • Tyler Powell

      I do the job from comfort and ease of my apartment, via doing basic projects that just demands from you a Personal computer and even online connection and Now I am cheerful than ever… After six months with this work and also i acquired compensated for in sum 36,000 us dollars… Mainly I acquire just about eighty bucks/hr and work for three to four hours every single day.And brilliant point regarding this job is the fact you can control your time while you do the job and for just how long as you may prefer and you earn a paycheck every week.—–>>>> VZTURL.COM/bnk55

    • Taylor Vaughn

      I get the job done from relief of my residence, through simple gigs that merely demands from you a Laptop or computer and on-line connection and I am also more happy than ever… After 6 months with this career and therefore i got compensated overall 36,000 dollars… Normally I generate approximate to 80 bucks/hr and work for three to four hrs constantly.And excellent point about this job is the fact that you can also arrange time any time you do the job and for just how long as you may prefer and you get a paycheck per week.>>>> VZTURL.COM/bnk55

    • Julian Read

      Most of the US Heirloom tomatoes need composting. Believe me.

  • Busdriver Bill

    and then there’s the Spitzenberg, which is a 19th century (?) variety, and quite unusual in its pulp density – excellent flavor, though.

  • John3936

    I understand that the colonists discovered and documented over 700 varieties of apples in the Appalachian Mountains, where do North American Apples fit in with these European apples in the developmental tree? Parallel evolution?

    • outis

      The natives quickly assimilated fruit trees. When the native villages in upstate new york were destroyed after the war for independence they cut down orchards of peach trees.

      • jonathanpulliam

        By chance do you know what apple variety orchards along the Bozenkill in Knox, NY would have favored back in the day?

        • outis

          Macs, cortland and pippens in the 20th century. My great uncle ralph worked in a packing plant at the turn of the century wnd could name dozens of apple varieties.

  • The History Man

    Looks like Adam and Eve have finally got their just desserts. No more forbidden fruit from the ‘tree of knowledge’ as they have finally wiped out both it, and the Garden of Eden. I bet the serpent is having the last laugh!

    • Chase Bank Manhattan

      Do you ever get the feeling that you’re a huge weirdo who should shut up? You should listen to that feeling, it’s telling you something real and important.

    • Chubbee

      That story always struck me as odd, even as a child.
      You can have anything you want, except life or knowledge.
      Perfectly describes how religious control works.

      • James Armstrong

        It is not “religious control.” The Bible is true, but symbolically (not literally).

  • outis

    I used to work in the post harvest lab at cornell, and a fresh red delicious is delicious. Honeycrisps are too big because growers are habituated to thinning the fruit on trees to get bigger apples, but honeycrisps dont need it. They also get mealy and flat tasting when stored cold in high CO2 like other apples. I don’t know why they are so popular because the ones I find in stores have not been handled properly. One of the best I ever tasted had been literally rolling around the back of the farmer’s truck for a week.

  • Neil Crabtree

    Gravenstein when eaten just prior to ripening is a total experience in mouth
    filling juice.

  • Fady Asmar

    The Malus trilobata is a wild variety that grows in forests in Lebanon. The fruits are rather small and sower. They are pickled in some villages.

  • nik

    Cox’s Orange!
    Golden Delicious, YUK!

  • DodgeMiniVan

    Living in Southington, CT. We are surrounded by Roger’s Orchards. I ate an apple years ago that they developed, it was a Jo-Mac. A cross between a Johnathan and McIntosh. It was crisp, juicy and delicious taste.

  • HenryLoose

    Some apples weren’t in the Garden of Eden.
    Stark Bros., Louisiana, MO, gave us both the Red Delicious and the Golden Delicious.

    • Tootsie

      Why has the Golden Delicious (a favourite in our house) vanished from grocers, produce markets? any insight for us here in western Canada?

  • Natalia Русская

    Went through the article and to be honest didn’t understand, what it was about. Wild apples are endangered or were they not always great, or the apples disappearing in Central Asia, where they come from, or all apple trees you buy today come from New York State, or you have to put more sugar into a jam made of wild apples? The author put everything he had about apples in his head onto paper. However I do not see a purpose of this article at all.

  • The History Man

    When we eradicate the Tree of Life or the Tree of Knowledge, then we will really know that it is all up for humankind.

  • geet

    hello there! such a nice post. thank you so much for sharing such an insight.

  • Tootsie

    Where IS the Golden Delicious, btw? Vanished from any grocers and markets in these parts, for longer now than i can pin down reliably…


The Crux

A collection of bright and big ideas about timely and important science from a community of experts.

See More


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar