Our Solar System’s Formation Was A Lot Messier Than You Think

By Korey Haynes | January 16, 2019 11:30 am
planets superimposed on each other

The early solar system was a violent place: it wasn’t just asteroids, but whole planets that veered on strange courses. (Photo credit: NASA)

When most of us learn about the solar system, it seems like a pretty well-ordered place. Our sun formed first, about five billion years ago, and the planets appeared a little later. As a very general trend, these planets grew larger and less dense the farther from the sun they formed.  

But this story leaves out the chaotic dynamics and frenetic reshuffling that occurred when our solar system was young. Nature may like order eventually, but that order evolves out of pure chance. Our solar system may be settled down now, but in its youth, it was a wild place.

Creating Order Out of Chaos

cloud of gas with planets

The planets formed out of an initial disk of gas and dust. (Credit: NASA)

The basic story does sound ordered. Any star system begins as a vast disk of gas with a baby star forming in the center. The star absorbs the vast majority of the material in this disk, but there’s some left over. Those remnants coalesces into dust grains, which become pebbles, which become boulders and eventually planets. Meanwhile, the young star is turning on and starting to shine, creating a solar wind that starts to blow out the leftover gas. Only heavy materials are left near the star, leading to small, dense planets close by. Physics also tells us these closer planets have smaller orbits, limiting the amount of material they can encounter and nab with their growing gravitational bulk. Farther out, gas giants can form, sucking in large amounts of hydrogen and helium gas. And beyond that, you find the snow line, where ices can exist without being melted or baked away by the sun’s heat. These get incorporated into the ice giants.

That sounds very tidy and quaint, a cosmic “just-so story”, if you will. But the solar system is more messy and more complex than that. There’s the Kuiper Belt and Oort Cloud for example, swaths of detritus that aren’t collected into any one object. Mars is suspiciously tiny, and why is there an asteroid belt in the middle of the solar system anyway?

We also know that Earth was struck by some monstrous object in its early history, though where it came from is still a mystery. In any case, that planet-sized impactor gave us a moon — which turns out to be helpful in all kinds of ways. But it certainly wasn’t destined to be that way.

Planets Don’t Stay in One Place

solar system, with clouds of asteroids leading and trailing Jupiter

Jupiter still has a lot of sway in the solar system, with entire families of asteroids called Greeks and Trojans under its gravitational influence. (Credit: Roen Kelly)

Remember that Nature starts most chains of events pretty randomly. So sometimes planets will form on orbits that aren’t stable over the countless millennia of the planets’ lifetimes. Occasionally that instability means planets crash into each other. More often, it means they veer cosmically close — not colliding, but close enough for gravity and momentum to send them careening off on strange orbits. We use this “slingshot effect” all the time with spacecraft to great benefit, but random encounters result in random slingshotting. Sometimes planets may fling themselves out of the solar system entirely — like the Mars-sized object that collided with Earth to form our moon, and now is nowhere to be found. Scientists have found a few of these rogue planets, unattached to any identifiable star, drifting in the cosmos.

And our moon’s birth isn’t the only example of planets roving. Back when the solar system was young, our sun hadn’t yet blown away all the extra gas. Instead, it remained scattered throughout the planets, denser in some areas than others. Jupiter, cruising around the sun, interacted with these waves of gas and began to lose angular momentum and spiral in. As it migrated in toward the sun, it also nudged in closer to its inner neighbor, Mars, and sucked in material that by rights should have belonged to the Red Planet. This could explain why Mars somehow ended up with less material than Earth, despite having a bigger orbital path that therefore should have fed it richly enough to grow much larger. To get back where we see it in the modern era, Jupiter would then have had to reverse course, in a move researchers call a “grand tack” (as in a sailboat tacking to change direction). But why should a planet suddenly change directions?

Jupiter and Saturn still have a lot of sway in today’s solar system, thanks to their large bulks. Researchers think it’s possible that eons ago, as Jupiter spiraled in toward the sun, Saturn came chasing after. The two became locked in a resonance that spiraled them back out and cast an even stronger pull on the objects around them. Such a gravitational shove might have pushed Neptune farther out, which in turn scattered icy Kuiper Belt objects inwards. Jupiter then flung these objects all over, forming the Oort Cloud that still surrounds us.

Looking Farther From Home

planet trailing gas around a star

WASP-12b is another planet so hot it’s losing its atmosphere to its star. (Credit: ESA/Hubble)

It might help to look at these events from a more distant perspective. Since astronomers discovered the first planets outside our solar system a few decades ago, it’s been clear that other solar systems don’t look much like ours. Some of that is observational bias — it’s actually quite difficult to see planets as small as Earth orbiting as far from their star as we do from the sun.

But even the larger planets we do see look different. Astronomers have found numerous hot Jupiters, gas giants traveling on sizzling orbits close to their stars. They’ve discovered scores of super-Earths, sub-Neptune sized objects that appear to be the most common type of planet — and one that doesn’t exist in our home system. And with more systems to look at, they’ve noticed what there was evidence for in our own system the whole time: that planets often go roving.

Hot Jupiters have been confusing since astronomers first found them. It doesn’t make physical sense for a giant ball of gas to form next to a brilliantly hot star. The star will strip away that gas faster than the nascent planet’s gravity can pull it close. In fact, we can see this happening around some of the hottest exoplanets, like HD209458b. Astronomers can actually observe its atmosphere streaming away behind it, being boiled off.

Perhaps even more telling is WASP-17b, another hot Jupiter. This one orbits retrograde (backwards) to its host star, a sure sign that something wonky happened in its past, as planets can’t start out rotating the wrong way.

Astronomers also know that both of these planets are loners, like other hot Jupiters. This might have been our solar system’s fate, if Saturn hadn’t pulled Jupiter out of its downward spiral. Without that rescue mission, Jupiter might have herded the rest of the solar system into deep space. We don’t know if systems with hot Jupiters had more planets in their pasts, but we do know it would be unlikely for those hypothetical planets to survive a Jupiter-like planet’s sunward plunge.

Since we don’t have dashcam footage of the long-ago joyrides from our own solar system, it’s difficult for researchers to “prove” any of these scenarios. But the more we look at the universe around us, the more evidence we see for disrupted systems and roving planets, and the more we learn about how unique our own solar system’s history seems to be.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Space & Physics, Top Posts
MORE ABOUT: solar system
  • http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/EquivPrinFail.pdf Uncle Al

    110 astronomical Messier objects were catalogued by French astronomer Charles Messier in Catalogue des Nébuleuses et des Amas d’Étoiles. Our solar system is no messier than Pluto is a proper planet.

  • Torbjörn Larsson

    Planet systems are individuals, and our system is not an outlier in any distribution now that planets in similar wide orbits can be, and have been, detected. The debris belts inside and outside planet orbits are even fairly common. And as for superEarths, we still don’t know if we lack one or if Planet Nine exists.

    Re Theia at about Mars or 0.2 Earth mass that impacted proto-Earth Tellus, the main hypothesis as I know it is that it was contributing the last 0.1 of Earth mass instead of escaping.

  • Derek Hendricks

    The process of proto-planetary disk accretion and formation is fundamentally an ordered , and predictable one . Single central-body systems tend to develop Jovian , or SaturnIan mass distributions , depending upon infall parameters , such as timing . Once proto-planets have begun forming , tidal and gravitational interactions tend to interfere with further formation in tidal-resonance zones , and to induce planetary migrations and collisions as well . Different systems experience varying degrees of formation violence and scrambling . Chance dictates that most end up disordered . Small systems , however , are more likely to retain their initial mass distribution , than large systems . Both gas-giant planet , and dwarf-star systems , evidence this trend . The Sol system appears to fall solidly into this latter category . It has a Saturnian-type mass distribution , modified by tidal-gravitational forces involving , primarily , Jupiter and Saturn . These systems themselves , confirm the above paradigm .

  • http://Lanth.US/Mars.html Raymond Kenneth Petry

    …contemporary astrophysics indicates the ice line (snowline, frost line) was inward, of pre-Jupiter, and contributed fastest to the initial, buildup which became, giant gas-planets when those could-then-gravitationally collect the light gases hydrogen and helium… Jupiter could, grand tack, but only to a Venutian orbit where gases had already been depleted, so, more-likely-it-didn’t… And (I add) our solar planets formed in quads that gathered by ‘shepherding’ at opposition (180°), and at quadrature (90°), whereby the exceptionally-large Jupiter got 3 to Saturn’s 1… (there have been other cruder, models, Jupiter slung-off from the proto-sun, etc.)…

  • yvette

    The latest analysis demonstrates that over 75% individuals are occupied into web browsing activities. Online world-wide is now bigger and better and bringing lots of opportunities. Home-based on-line jobs are becoming poplar and changing individual’s day-to-day lives. Why it is actually extremely popular? Mainly because it enables you to do the job from anywhere and any time. You get more time to allocate with your family and friends and can plan out journeys for vacations. Men and women are generating nice revenue of $16000 in one week by utilizing the effective and intelligent techniques. Doing right work in a right path will definitely lead us towards becoming successful. You can begin to get paid from the 1st day once you see our web site. JOIN TODAY >>>>> CUMMINS.PT/eA

  • https://www.facebook.com/pages/My-Original-Music-written-arranged-produced-by-ME/195887277117017 JohnnyMorales

    I’m not normally a stickler for details, but two things really stick out as simply silly. The first is “like the Mars-sized object that collided with Earth to form our moon, and now is nowhere to be found.”

    That’s not true. It’s under your feet. All collision theories say the object merged with the Earth. The moon was formed from debris flung out from the impact of the 2 planet-sized objects.

    The second is “We also know that Earth was struck by some monstrous object in its early history, though where it came from is still a mystery. In any case, that planet-sized impactor gave us a moon.”

    The impactor was part of our own solar nebula. Where it came from is no mystery.

  • elsa

    Recent analysis shows that on average 75% individuals are occupied into internet activities. Online world-wide is now bigger and more beneficial and bringing a great number of work at home opportunities. Working from home on-line tasks are becoming poplar and developing people’s daily lives. Why it really is popular? Mainly because it grants you to work from anywhere and anytime. You get more time to allocate with people you care about and can plan out journeys for holidays. Individuals are generating great income of $42000 per week by utilizing the efficient and intelligent ways. Performing right work in a right path will definitely lead us in the direction of success. You will start to earn from the first day once you browse through our web-site. GET IT HERE >>>>> CUMMINS.PT/eA


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


See More

Collapse bottom bar