Aliens, Comets or Crap? What’s Going On With The Wow! Signal?

By John Wenz | June 8, 2017 9:00 am
Ohio State University's Big Ear Observatory caught one of the most promising SETI signals ever back in 1977. Astronomer are still debating if it came from aliens, or something closer to home. ( Credit: NRAO/AUI/NSF)

Ohio State University’s Big Ear Observatory caught one of the most promising SETI signals ever back in 1977. Astronomers are still debating if it came from aliens, or something closer to home. (Credit: NRAO/AUI/NSF)

In 1977, Ohio State University math professor Jerry Ehman walked into the Big Ear Observatory and looked over the past few nights’ observations. At the time, the radio telescope was the only observatory exclusively devoted to the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI).

It also was underfunded and had no full-time staff. That means no one was listening for aliens the night SETI had its closest call with the big one. On the night of Aug. 15, 1977, a 72-second signal arrived from deep space just at the right frequency astronomers believe aliens would use. Since no staff members were around, no one could alert other telescopes to listen in.

Without tying the radio signal to an object in the night sky, they couldn’t tell how far away it originated, Ehman told me last fall.

All Ehman could do was scribble “Wow!” on the data printout and hope the signal from Sagittarius would repeat.

It never did. But Antonio Paris, an astronomy professor at St. Petersburg College in Florida, thinks he has the solution. Two comets passed by that region of the sky in 1977, according to his hypothesis. And this year, those comets passed by again. That created a chance to test his theory. His research was accepted for publication in the Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences. (A preprint is available on Paris’ site.)

wow-signal-3

The comet 266/P Christensen is the one in question. Its orbit roughly aligns with Jupiter at its farthest distance and Mars at its closest to the Sun. According to Paris’ research, the comet “transmitted” at the 1420.25 MHz radio band. That’s near where the Wow! signal came from.

“We did everything we could to try to debunk our results but we kept getting a signal from the comet,” Paris told Discover. “That was when we said, ‘Eureka!’ ”

Paris, who along with his teaching duties runs the Center for Planetary Science and the UFO-hunting Aerial Phenomena Institute, proposed the hypothesis last year. Ehman scrutinized that original proposal, and didn’t believe it was likely to be comets.

“I received a copy of their article from the Journal of the Washington Academy of Sciences and I studied it carefully,” Ehman said in an interview at the time. “I have concluded that neither of the two comets could explain the Wow! signal, and colleagues of mine at the observatory have also concluded the same thing.”

Indeed, peer reviewers on Paris’ paper remarked on the need to coordinate with Ohio State and others on the research, seeing that as one of the flaws in the paper.

“The only response from the peer review that we were concerned about was that no one, including Ohio State University, had previous research on detecting a signal from a comet,” Paris says. “We had to explain to the peer reviewers that we were the first to do so … thus no previous data was available.”

Chris Lintott, a professor of astrophysics at Oxford University, isn’t buying any of the explanation.

“If real, this comet is detectable in the radio,” Lintott says. “But the signal isn’t bright enough or rapid enough to be a good fit to the Wow! signal.”

The methodology itself is flawed, according to Lintott. While staring at this region of the sky, he says there should have been about five minutes’ worth of signals if it were comets, but it only comes in intermittent bursts. And if it were comets, Lintott says we could expect to see Wow! signals all the time, rather than once in 1977 and once in 2017. Then there’s the choice of journal — in his words, “it’s not somewhere astronomers publish.”

Lintott has another problem with Paris’ research: He crowdfunded it.

“Bad papers get written and published all the time,” he says. “But this author asked people for money to fund his research, and if you do that you should hold yourself to the highest standards.”

Lintott isn’t sure what it is. But comets it ain’t.

“I don’t know what the Wow! signal was — it’s very hard to study something you’ve only seen once,” he says. Lintott suggests the study authors submit their research to one of the larger astronomy journals so they can get constructive feedback.

“This is just science by press release, and it’s depressing it’s picked up (by the press),” Lintott says.

Paris is aware of the criticism he’s receiving and believes his paper still stands up to scrutiny.

“I see one or two astronomers are skeptical. They emailed me, too,” he says. “But they can’t answer my question: Show me the evidence to refute my data. They might need to do some soul searching.”

For his part, Ehman remains (relatively) agnostic on the original signal, while wanting to believe the extraterrestrial cause. He acknowledges that limited equipment of the time led to a sort of dead end to the mystery.

“It’s an intriguing possibility that it’s a signal from extraterrestrial intelligence, but it’s also one that I’ve had to declare that I can’t prove that it is, or prove that it isn’t,” Ehman says.

So I guess that makes two things now that some people think are aliens and others think are comets. There’s now a possibly plausible explanation for the Wow! signal, but that won’t stop SETI researchers from continuing to look for something just like it, hoping for that needle in the haystack that proves we’re not alone.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Space & Physics, top posts
ADVERTISEMENT
  • wmmoisson

    Of course Ehman is reluctant to refute his own findings. Paris has a legitimate theory. I, for one, agree with Paris. It makes sense.

    • Barry Thomas

      I don’t, because alien ships disguises themselves like space and move extremely fast.

      • InsaniD

        Really? Alien Ships? Tell us more, please…

    • Chad Davis

      I’m with Lintott, if it were comets why was the signal so much shorter and why don’t we see them much more often rather than once every 40 years. Not saying it’s aliens but to me comets seem like an easy out and a guy trying to get a paper published

      • OWilson

        Illiterate aliens?

        Build a transmitter just to send that!?

  • José Carlos Bezerra

    Accept this ideia. The aliens are us. It´s that simple. Stop fatasizing.

    • http://secure49.com Tyler Powell

      I work from convenience of my home, through effortless gigs which needs only from you a Computer as well as connection to the web and I am more joyful than ever… After 6 months with this career and managed to get paid for overall 36 thousand dollars… Generally I make up around eighty bucks/h and also work for 3 to 4 hours time each day.And great factor regarding this task is the fact that you can manage your time at the time you get the job done and for how long as you wish for and you get a check week by week.>>>> VZTURL.COM/bnk55

  • theappalachian

    WE ARE NOT ALONE
    We are not alone
    Love is too great to be
    Confined to this one small world
    In this tiny galaxy
    Where we scan the skies
    Endlessly it seems
    Knowing beyond them lie
    Answers to hopes and dreams
    When amongst all men
    Perfect love is known
    Perhaps the stars will shout
    “YOU ARE NOT ALONE”!

    • Dorthy S. Warthen

      Mak­e more cash every week… This is a great part-time job opportunity for anybody… Best part about it ,work from your home and make $100-$2k at the end of every week … Apply for the job now and receive your first paycheck at the end of this week…> http://WWW.WZURL.ME/IkG1rw

  • stevlich

    It’s a nothing burger in the infinite void out there. The universe is nothing but rocks hitting each other. What else could produce the disaster on this planet that passes for life but nth degree randomness.

    • Chris TMC

      “What else could produce the disaster on this planet that passes for life”.

      You must be a whole lot of fun at parties.

      • Philip Sieve

        There’s a lot of smart-alecks writing articles for and commenting on the comments sections of this supposedly scientific blog that try to conceal they know little better about the subject than those they lampoon, but need to feel they are so smarter. Our species feel insecure when we can’t wrap our big egos around a phenomenon.
        Their bright idea to handle this insecurity is to write puerile criticism, with no scientific basis, whatsoever, to prove what they ridicule to be ridiculous.

        That being said, I’m not sure what was written in those letters that calls for a “Wow”.

  • http://theunpossiblefile.blogger.com Jerry H

    Intelligent life in intergalactic space? Probably not. Interdimensionally? Yes. In the movie Avatar an “alien” death shows the energy body recirculated into the planet’s atmosphere. Pretty nervy for director Cameron. Whatever you want to call it that’s the kind of meta-physical machinery that exists here or anywhere else with intelligent life. No guy with a beard on a cloud with pink cherubs flying around. Wha? Belief ain’t science?

    • Courtney Schumacher

      Movies: imagination. The only proof of interdimensionality I’ve seen is just that: visual. No, belief ain’t science. Science needs proof to be accepted.

      • http://theunpossiblefile.blogger.com Jerry H

        You should consider the context of the comment b4 you pontificate. Like my last sentence where I jokenly imply that I know about scientific method
        and wish to throw out what I consider to be informed speculation that also agrees with serious ppl who also did speculation for a living. Like James Cameron who went out on a limb and put the implications of intergalactic intel life to the test along with everything that involves. Also he implies the same process applies to this Earth existence. if you don’t know the reference is then you shouldnt reply.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

D-brief

Briefing you on the must-know news and trending topics in science and technology today.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar
+