“Just Say No” to… Free Wi-Fi?

By Lizzie Buchen | March 26, 2008 3:04 pm

When cafés place signs that boast “Free Wi-Fi” in their windows, they usually intend to lure patrons in—not drive them away. But in response to Sonic.net’s offer to provide free Wi-Fi to the small town of Sebastopol, California, its residents whipped out their tinfoil hats and rejected the offer due to “potential risks to the health of our community” (although they thanked Sonic for the “very nice gesture”).

tinfoil-hat.jpg

Sebastopol’s city council had signed a contract with Sonic in November, but rescinded its resolution due to pleas from self-proclaimed “electromagnetically hypersensitive” (EHS) citizens, who experienced headaches and rashes in response to electromagnetic frequencies (EMF), and an online petition with roughly 500 signatures. Can the little EMF coming from Wi-Fi be bad for our health? Could blogging from coffee shops become as taboo—and illegal—as smoking in bars?

Not likely. Sonic CEO Dane Jasper lists a number of independent studies on EHS on his blog, and there exist many, many, more. The latter study, specifically, showed that “the large majority of individuals who claims to be able to detect low level RF-EMF are not able to do so under double-blind conditions. If such individuals exist, they represent a small minority and have not been identified yet.” In other words, while the symptoms experienced by EHS individuals are real, they are most likely psychosomatic—caused by fear, rather than the airwaves.

Long before the advent of Wi-Fi, the residents of Sebastopol and all people of this planet were already bathing in EMF, emitted from radios, televisions, power lines, cell phone signals, microwaves, motion detectors, and computer monitors (which one would encounter when, say, signing an online petition)—all of which emit much more radiation than a mesh Wi-Fi network (which gives off about 0.1 watts).

Further, all of these sources, including Wi-Fi, are classified as “non-ionizing” radiation, which has such low energy that it only manages to cause molecules to vibrate, inducing a heating effect—which is why your ear feels warm after you end a long cell phone conversation. Ionizing radiation, like X-rays and gamma-rays, actually have enough energy to ionize atoms and molecules, producing carcinogenic free radicals. Higher frequency non-ionizing radiation, such as that emitted by that radiation-spewing behemoth in the sky—the sun—also have enough energy to damage your DNA.

Of course, no one has proven that Wi-Fi is harmless, but of all the dangers of modern society, it should be pretty low on your list of concerns. A bit more on target would be worries about the mercury and particulate pollution belched by coal plants (for your electricity), cephalopod-befuddling sonar, sweltering nights on urban heat islands, and soft drinks, to name a few.

Image: Paradigm/Flickr

  • Jeff W

    ah hippies…gotta love that irrational hysteria. in the meantime, I’ll take that free wifi, sonic.

  • pleasantly wi-fi’d

    all these accounts of EHF are anecdotal and completely unscientific (by the way, nice job referencing “negative proof”). that’s no way to run a city in 2008!

  • http://dicovermagazine.com george mcentire

    Seems odd that the City Council would sign such a contract without asking it’s citizens & business owners? Caving in so quickly to an undocumented vocal minority shows the Council knows it stepped in something.

  • Joe H

    Thank you Sonic for your offer. As a working mom, I would welcome the opportunity to go to the local cafe and get some work done, opposed to staying in my wireless home. Too bad Sebastopol’s Council is so short sighted and spineless.

  • D W

    Someone started another petition to fix this retarded mistake:

    http://www.petitiononline.com/freewifi/petition.html

    Sign it if you live near sebastopol

  • http://www.deviledegg.org/ Deviled Egg

    I live near Sebastopol, CA and I’m not surprised at all.

    Sebastopol has signs up declaring the town a “Nuclear Free Zone”. I guess they can add another sign now. Oh brother!

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Discoblog

Quirky, funny, and surprising science news from the edge of the known universe.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »