Comments on: Holy Crops! Pope Backs Genetically Modified Foods

By: Schiller Thurkettle

Schiller Thurkettle — Sun, 09 Aug 2009 20:48:21 +0000

This is a very confusing article.

I’ve never heard anything about the “papacy’s generally-hands-off approach to God’s creations”. Since we are God’s creations, and live among God’s creations, it seems like we (as humans) have no choice but to take a “hands-on” approach to creations. I mean, what else are we gonna do? Pretty obvious, but I’ve never heard the Church say anything one way or the other on this. Maybe because it’s too obvious.

The part about “the Pope’s scientists admit” is odd. Are they his employees? Looking at the list of who showed up for the Vatican meeting, it looks like they’re from all over, and employed totally elsewhere.

Then there’s the claim that “the environmental and health consequences of genetically modified foods remain largely unknown”. Anyone who can Google a topic can easily discover that these foods have been studied more intensely than any other in history.

Pretty sensational article, though. That’s probably the point. Heck, it got me to show up and comment!

But sensationalism really isn’t apropos of a publication titled “Discover”. There’s nothing new here, folks, move along…

By: Chris H

Chris H — Sat, 06 Jun 2009 15:05:54 +0000

I’m sorry to have to briong to your attention that your statement is way more absolute than the article you refer to actually says. A summary: a week was held at the academy of the vatican where many speakers were invited who happen to endorse GM. Most speeches focused on the problem of what they feel is too strict regulation.

The pope himself has not endorsed the conclusions of these people. In the working document for the 2nd synodal convention for Africa the invasion of Africa by multinationals is explicitly criticies, including the gm-seed campaign. (Source: St Columbus Mission Society website)

An African bisshop who was invited to the week had some inkling of being used for a campaign and noted the lack of balance in the arguments (see National Catholic Reporter “Two sides of Rome, two sides on GMOs” ).

Hope this helps…

By: MarkD

MarkD — Fri, 05 Jun 2009 08:29:02 +0000

Wow, not too bad! Slow but sure progress from the Vatican
First it’s Evolution is not incompatible with Christianity, now GM foods. Just have to work on that condom thing next.

I have big hopes for genetically modified crops and radiation treating food to sterilize it. But as soon and anyone mentions genetics or radiation people completely freak out. The food isn’t radioactive, you just aren’t going to get sick from it because it’s sterile. I bet the peanut and lettuce industry wished they had been using it. As far as genetically modified food, when you eat it, the DNA of the food breaks down in your stomach acid. If we absorbed DNA from food we would all have corn silk for hair and cow udders.

I just hope that new vitamin rich/drought resistant foods are made available soon freely to poor countries.