Mexican Religious Rite Has Created Super Poison-Tolerant Cave Fish

By Eliza Strickland | September 15, 2010 5:54 pm

cave-riteAny culture’s religious ceremonies can seem strange to outsiders: For example, take the indigenous Zoque people of southern Mexico. To ask their gods for bountiful rains during the growing season they head to a sulfur cave where molly fish swim in the subterranean lake. They then toss in leaf bundles that contain a paste made from the mashed-up root of the Barbasco plant, which has a powerful anesthetic effect.

When the stunned fish–which the Zoque people consider a gift from underworld gods–go belly-up, people scoop them from the water and bring them home for supper. This fishy protein helps them make it through until the harvest.

This ritual came to the attention of scientists studying the molly fish, who wondered how the toxic root might be affecting fish populations in the caves. So evolutionary ecologist Michael Tobler and his colleagues did a little field research.

From LiveScience:

“We learned about the ceremony, and actually attended it in 2007,” Tobler recalled. “The families each take a certain amount of the fish home. The way we had ours prepared was that they were just mixed with scrambled eggs, although I hear other families fry them. They had a funny salty taste to them, although I’m not sure if that’s because of their sulfuric environment, or something the cook messed up.”

The researchers got more than a taste of local culture, they also came up with evidence of evolution-in-action that they published in a study in Biology Letters. In lab experiments they compared molly fish from the ritual cave to others from an area upstream that had never swam in poisoned water, and found that the cave fish had a much higher tolerance for the Barbasco toxin.

Study coauthor Mark Tobler of Texas A&M University told New Scientist the results show that within the ritual cave, evolution has selected for fish that can survive the poison.

“The study indicates that the fish have adapted to the local Zoque traditions,” says Tobler, who describes the effect as “an intimate bond between nature and local culture.”

The relationship may be intimate, but the Mexican government is worried that it’s also detrimental–officials have banned the ceremony, saying it’s bad for the fish.

Related Content:
80beats: Unnatural Evolution: Fishing Eliminates Cod Adapted for Shallow Waters
80beats: Researchers Catch Lake Victoria Fish in the Act of Evolving
The Loom: When Love Shocks

Image: Biology Letters

MORE ABOUT: evolution, fish, mexico, religion
  • Gus

    Now how about a test of the Zoque people for Barbasco resistance?

  • john

    “I’m not sure …. [it was] something the cook messed up.” OR … perhaps the saltiness is part of the recipe, and not an error.

  • Monkey

    Not much of a religious tradiation, more like fishing with poison. I would expect that if I took a gun, shot at a moose, then saw the moose fall and cried “jeebus be loving! He granted me food!” I would be laughed at. Somebody might posit, rationally, “Um, you actually just killed it, dude”.

    I think the biology of this story and this event is amazing, and tells another part of the evolutionary tale. Its just that what passes as religious ceremonies is rather weak in some parts of the world (although, this is rather harmless overall compared to most!) and the irrationality associated with it is eye opening.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!


Quirky, funny, and surprising science news from the edge of the known universe.

See More

Collapse bottom bar