This is the eighth in a series of reports from the HI-SEAS simulated Mars mission. Read others in the series here.
On June 3, 1965, astronaut Ed White pushed out of the Gemini 4 capsule and floated into space. White, the first American to conduct an extra-vehicular activity, or EVA, was tasked with testing a hand-held maneuvering unit, taking pictures and generally making history. Twenty-three minutes after his exit, White reluctantly re-entered his spaceship, disappointed he couldn’t stay out longer, but exhilarated all the same.
As a crew on a simulated Mars mission, part of our job is to conduct EVAs here on Earth. The thinking is this: Astronauts on a Mars mission will need to go outside for routine maintenance, to study geology and to explore their surroundings. A simulated mission should provide that kind of workload. Also, it’s good to stretch the legs, get some natural light and take a break from day-to-day monotony.
This means that once or twice a week, a team of two or three HI-SEAS crew members leaves the confines of the dome to walk the lava fields of Mauna Loa. And yes, we do it in spacesuits. Or, more precisely, we wear spacesuit simulators. Our suits are nowhere near robust enough to protect a person in the vacuum of space.
A curious thing happened, though, on the way to the airlock: I learned there is no clear best spacesuit simulator for simulated missions like ours. In fact, the discussions about the most appropriate styles for spacesuit simulators are almost always contentious.
In one camp are people who are interested in suits that mimic real spacesuits’ function as closely as possible, while putting less emphasis on looks. For instance, suits should be almost completely closed off to the environment, and should be bulky and cumbersome. But they needn’t always align with the classic concept of a spacesuit: They don’t need to be white or silver; they don’t need to have a dome-shaped helmet; and they don’t necessarily even need a separate “life-support” backpack if it could be built into the suit itself. For the people in this camp, fidelity trumps photogenic.
In another camp are people who are interested in preserving the classic spacesuit look, often to the detriment of fidelity. They are based on flight suits and are likely to come with domed helmets and separate backpacks. They tend not to be airtight and sometimes provide quite a bit of access to the outside environment. Depending on who you are, these suits either make you feel more like an astronaut or make you feel like you’re wearing a costume.
When the HI-SEAS mission started, our main option for spacesuit simulators were those that fell into the former category: retrofitted, green hazmat suits that are closed off to the environment except for small fans for ventilation and cooling. But there have been problems. The suits aren’t just bulky and cumbersome; they actually don’t fit smaller crew members. And the built-in faceplate is oversized and uncomfortable, and sometimes obstructs visibility. Additionally, the fans don’t cool as expected; people overheat and faceplates fog.
Still, we wear them. And I actually enjoyed the challenge of maneuvering in such a clumsy, fogged-up suit on a recent geological expedition. (We explored the edges of a lava tube skylight, essentially a giant hole in the ground that leads to a cave created by a lava flow from long ago. More on that in a future post.) But I will readily admit that these suits don’t look good on camera. And in a simulated mission, it’s not necessarily the photos of the crew sitting down for dinner that people will remember. For better or for worse, the photos that count are of the habitat and the crew in spacesuits.
And so when we got word a few weeks into the mission that a team from the University of Maryland was interested in having us test its spacesuit simulator, we jumped at the chance. The suit comes with a separate helmet and backpack that holds a ventilation and cooling system. It’s white. It’s puffy like spacesuits are, but still fits most crewmembers well, and it has an excellent isolating effect, even if it isn’t completely airtight. In other words, it’s traditional and looks good.
This new suit isn’t perfect either. It uses a water-cooled vest to keep the torso from overheating, but arms and legs get hot fast. Also, the power supply for ventilation seems to lack a certain oomph. And the helmet doesn’t connect to the collar with a tight seal.
The crew is collaborating with the team at the University of Maryland to offer suggestions for improvements and to try out fixes where we can. In addition, we’ve suggested improvements for the hazmat suits that include separate helmets. We hope to try modified versions of both suits before the mission ends.
Clearly each spacesuit simulator has advantages and disadvantages. Personally, at the start of this mission, my opinion was that any spacesuit looks a little goofy if it’s on a person who isn’t actually in space. But after wearing the Maryland simulator, I’ve had to adjust my stance. With that helmet on my head and that pack on my back, I couldn’t help but feel a bit of EVA exhilaration—even with my feet planted firmly on the ground.