Evolution Made Ridiculous Flightless Birds Over and Over

By Elizabeth Preston | May 22, 2014 10:43 am

ostriches

Watching an ostrich sprint across the plain like a mean two-legged dust mop, you might think a mistake has been made. Surely this isn’t one of evolution’s prouder moments? But new genetic evidence says that the group of birds including ostriches, emus, and other ungainly birds all came from flying ancestors. They lost the ability to fly not once, but over and over again. Something must have been working.

The ratites are a group of birds that includes the ostrich and emu, as well as the kiwi, rhea (like a smaller, South American ostrich), and cassowary (with a bright blue face and what looks like a toenail on its head). There were also the moa of New Zealand and the elephant bird of Madagascar—gigantic Big Bird types that went extinct within the past several hundred years, likely due to humans.

The birds themselves are pretty obvious, but the story of ratite evolution “has always been a contentious issue,” says Oliver Haddrath, an ornithology research technician and PhD student at the Royal Ontario Museum. Scientists have never been certain how ratites arose, or how they’re related to each other and to more normal birds.

In the 1960s and 1970s, Haddrath says, molecular evidence showed that the flightless ratites were closely related to birds called tinamous. Unlike the ratites, these small ground dwellers in Central and South America can fly (though they don’t often choose to). At the same time, scientists realized that everyplace ratites live or used to live (Australia, South America, Africa) was a piece of land that once belonged to the supercontinent Gondwanaland. Perhaps the common ancestor of all ratites was a flightless bird on Gondwanaland that had already split off from its flying relative the tinamou. When the supercontinent broke up, the birds left standing on each bit of land could have evolved into different species.

Since then, some evidence has supported this theory, while other studies have contradicted it. Haddrath and his coauthors approached the question using DNA from the extinct moa, as well as updated DNA-sequencing technology that let them gather large amounts of data at once. “We used over 1 million base pairs” of DNA, Haddrath says, “to test whether the tinamou was closer to the moa than the moa was to the emu and ostrich.” At last, they would unearth the answers to the ratites’ family secrets.

They found that the tinamou isn’t a distant cousin after all, but a sibling smack in the middle of the ratite family tree. This suggests that the common ancestor of the ratites and the tinamou could fly, and while the tinamou held onto this skill, the branches leading to other ratites became flightless again and again.

ratite tree

Since tinamous kept their ability to fly, every other branch in this tree probably also started with a flying bird.

Technically, it’s possible that the opposite is true: all the ratites and the tinamou evolved from one flightless ancestor, and the tinamou re-learned how to fly. But Haddrath says it’s unlikely. “There are no known examples of a flightless bird species regaining flight,” he says. Many kinds of birds other than the ratites have lost the ability to fly—penguins, some ducks, and so on—but none have gotten it back. Generally, it’s “considered much easier to lose a trait than regain it,” Haddrath says.

The relationship between the tinamou and other ratites, for which Haddrath says there’s “overwhelming evidence” in the DNA, was hidden by the shapes of the birds’ bodies. “Most studies using skeletal features have concluded that the ratites are each other’s closest relatives, and the tinamous are a distant cousin,” Haddrath says. But it now seems that the demands of land-bound life made ratites’ skeletons evolve in similar ways. This convergent evolution masked the birds’ true relationships.

Since so many birds have given up flying, it must be an easy trait to lose when it’s beneficial, Haddrath says. For birds that are adapting to life on land, hanging onto the traits that let them fly may (ironically) weigh them down. As they lose flight they’re free to evolve into the weird, walking species we know today. It’s apparently a winning strategy—as long as humans don’t arrive on their island to wipe them out.


Images: ostriches by Josh*m (via Flickr); ratite tree adapted from Baker et al.

Baker AJ, Haddrath O, McPherson JD, & Cloutier A (2014). Genomic Support for a Moa-Tinamou Clade and Adaptive Morphological Convergence in Flightless Ratites. Molecular biology and evolution PMID: 24825849

Postscript (5/26/14): Another study, published this month in Science, compared ancient DNA from elephant birds to DNA from modern ratites and came to the same conclusion: flightless ratites evolved several times, independently, from a flying ancestor. You can read more at Not Exactly Rocket Science or in the New York Times.

ADVERTISEMENT
  • http://Orthoman.com/ DockyWocky

    Good thing some walking bird types died out, or were helped to die out by humans, who probably got tired of being eaten by the larger ones.

  • toongail

    God has a sense of humor..

    • Puddintaine

      And more than a trace of sadism.

    • Raymond Dalton

      She has.

  • Johny Loffler

    guys and girls and selfproclaimed otherwise… ostriches kill lions and other famous african predators. Nothing to be ashamed of… compared to our sad and disgraceful evolution.. humans are the bitches of animal kingdom hehe wonder if you agree…

  • Dank mem

    Im doin dis at school

    • that one dude guy

      same

    • Godly

      The FitnessGram Pacer Test is a multistage aerobic capacity test that progressively gets more difficult as it continues. The 20 meter pacer test will begin in 30 seconds. Line up at the start. The running speed starts slowly but gets faster each minute after you hear this signal bodeboop. A sing lap should be completed every time you hear this sound. ding Remember to run in a straight line and run as long as possible. The second time you fail to complete a lap before the sound, your test is over. The test will begin on the word start. On your mark. Get ready!… Start. ding

  • Dank mem

    this Essay is heard

    • Godly

      kool story bro dank mem/10

    • that one dude guy

      lol

      • Godly

        LMAO DED

      • that one dude guy

        youre white

        • Godly

          Im black? PROBLEM??!?!

          • that one dude guy

            america

          • Godly

            Oh yeah

          • Killer Snowman

            BOI

          • Godly

            GURL

          • Killer Snowman

            Yes?

          • Godly

            The FitnessGram Pacer Test is a multistage aerobic capacity test that progressively gets more difficult as it continues. The 20 meter pacer test will begin in 30 seconds. Line up at the start. The running speed starts slowly but gets faster each minute after you hear this signal bodeboop. A sing lap should be completed every time you hear this sound. ding Remember to run in a straight line and run as long as possible. The second time you fail to complete a lap before the sound, your test is over. The test will begin on the word start. On your mark. Get ready!… Start. ding

          • Killer Snowman

            english motherfucka do you speak it

          • Godly

            No habla englais

          • that one dude guy

            por favor

          • Godly

            no favor

          • that one dude guy

            :(

          • Killer Snowman

            Godly just wondering if we met would you date me?

          • Godly

            NO i would instantly reject

          • Killer Snowman

            Rude

          • Killer Snowman

            only wondering since we are in the same class

          • Godly

            Nah, you’re probably a guy

          • that one dude guy

            THEY KNOW

          • Killer Snowman

            shut up dude guy
            we have been friends for years

          • that one dude guy

            bull

          • Killer Snowman

            -_-

          • Godly

            Shut it kaileb

          • that one dude guy

            they know

          • Killer Snowman

            kaileb dont give off any reactions now so hushy

          • that one dude guy

            stfu brian

          • Killer Snowman

            whos brian? KAILEB ARE YOU CHEATING ON ME!

          • that one dude guy

            im batman

          • Killer Snowman

            no wonder i never met your parents

          • that one dude guy

            MY ONE WEAKNESS, NOOOOOO

          • Killer Snowman

            THE JOKES ON YOU!!!!!!!!!!

          • that one dude guy

            YOU, ILL FIND YOU

          • Killer Snowman

            and ill kill Jacob M.

          • that one dude guy

            DUN DUN DUNNNNN

          • Killer Snowman

            DUN DUN DUNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN

          • Godly

            Jesse go find james so you can finally have someone who loves you, maybe get a cat and name it meowth

          • that one dude guy

            HE KNOWS

          • Killer Snowman

            ITS A SHE YOU FUC WIT

          • Godly

            Your new name is James. Go marry Jesse

          • that one dude guy

            I DONT CONCENT

          • Godly

            I dont care.

          • that one dude guy

            who are you mystery person -_-

          • Killer Snowman

            godly who are you cause only two people have heard me say that as a joke

          • Godly

            I am nobody.

          • Killer Snowman

            just tell me

          • Killer Snowman

            kj

          • Godly

            yo no habla englais

          • Killer Snowman

            god i hate mexicans

          • that one dude guy

            omg dude

          • that one dude guy

            you have to be someone

          • that one dude guy

            get rigety rekt son

          • that one dude guy

            too much work

          • Killer Snowman

            ikr ;;))

          • that one dude guy

            what if girl

          • Killer Snowman

            i is gurl

          • that one dude guy

            ded

          • Godly

            LMAO

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Inkfish

Like the wily and many-armed cephalopod, Inkfish reaches into the far corners of science news and brings you back surprises (and the occasional sea creature). The ink is virtual but the research is real.

About Elizabeth Preston

Elizabeth Preston is a science writer whose articles have appeared in publications including Slate, Nautilus, and National Geographic. She's also the former editor of the children's science magazine Muse, where she still writes in the voice of a know-it-all bovine. She lives in Massachusetts. Read more and see her other writing here.

ADVERTISEMENT

See More

@Inkfish on Twitter

ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar
+