Wasps Choose the Sex of Their Young—but Climate Can Foil Them

By Elizabeth Preston | May 30, 2014 9:00 am


It’s a good thing human sex isn’t determined the same way a parasitoid wasp’s is, because “sugar and spice and everything nice” is much easier to rhyme than “sperm and moderate temperatures.” But that’s what little wasp girls are made of. A mother wasp can choose the sex of each egg she lays by deciding whether or not to fertilize it. Depending on the temperature of her environment, though, she may not get her way.

Whether you are biologically male or female isn’t really determined by spices, snips or snails, of course, but by the genes you receive from your parents. Outside of the mammal world, things get more interesting. In reptiles such as turtles or alligators, the sex of a developing egg may depend on the temperature of its nest. In certain insects, every fertilized egg becomes a female, while every unfertilized egg becomes a male (who has half the number of chromosomes as his sisters).*

This system of fertilized females and DNA-poor males shows up in bees, ants, and wasps, among other insects. But temperature could still matter—maybe one type of embryo is less likely to survive a cold snap, for example. Joffrey Moiroux, a biologist at the University of Montreal, wanted to tease apart these two different means of sex determination in a wasp species. It would require him scrutinizing every wiggle of a female wasp’s abdomen as she laid her eggs.

The species Moiroux and his coauthors chose to study was Trichogramma euproctidis, a tiny parasitoid wasp that lays its own eggs inside the eggs of butterflies and moths. (Things don’t end well for the butterfly or moth embryos already inhabiting those eggs.)

The researchers kept 90 recently mated female wasps at either 14, 24, or 34 degrees Celsius for an hour. (That’s 57, 75, or a toasty 93 degrees Fahrenheit.) Then they presented each female with 20 moth eggs, laid out in a neat grid like a jumbo egg carton.

By studying video recordings of each female wasp laying her eggs inside the unfortunate moth eggs, Moiroux could tell which offspring the mother intended to be female. Partway through laying these eggs, she’d pause for a few seconds—this is when she added sperm, which she’d stored inside her body after mating, to the egg. The eggs that she popped out with no pause, and no sperm, would become the unfertilized males.

For each batch of eggs, then, Moiroux knew the ratio of male to female offspring that the mother meant to create. Later on, when those eggs hatched, he counted the young to see whether their mother’s plan had worked.

At the highest temperature, mothers laid more (no-pause) male eggs than they did at medium or low temperatures. This is likely something a mother does to increase the fitness of her offspring, the researchers say. Higher temperatures make insects grow smaller; perhaps the mother lays more male eggs because they’ll be just as fertile at a smaller size, while her female young won’t.

When the eggs hatched, the sex ratios at medium and warm temperatures were similar to what the mothers intended. But the coldest temperature skewed the sex ratio toward males. This wasn’t because female embryos died more often, the scientists found. It might have been because cold temperatures damage or impair sperm—and when a mother thinks she’s fertilizing an egg, it may not work.

So extreme temperatures produce extra male wasps, whether it’s the mother’s choice (in hot temperatures) or outside of her control (in cold). This means climate change could lead to extra males in this species, says Moiroux. Extreme weather events can mean both heat waves and cold snaps, and both of these will result in more male wasp babies.

However, Moiroux adds, behavior can evolve very quickly. Since mother wasps already adjust their behavior at high temperatures, opting to lay more male eggs, it’s possible that they could adapt to a changing climate by tweaking the sex ratio again. At cold temperatures, though, things will still be outside of their control; that may be the time to try puppy dog tails.

Image: Trichogramma kaykai wasps (the same genus as the wasps in the story, but not the same species) laying eggs inside butterfly eggs. Duotone Wageningen, The Netherlands.

Moiroux, J., Brodeur, J., & Boivin, G. (2014). Sex ratio variations with temperature in an egg parasitoid: behavioural adjustment and physiological constraint Animal Behaviour, 91, 61-66 DOI: 10.1016/j.anbehav.2014.02.021

*This results in sisters who share about 75% of their genes, rather than the usual 50%, and may help explain why these insects don’t mind slaving away over a queen’s young—they’re more closely related than a standard family.

  • mememine

    If Human CO2 “could be” a “threat to the planet” why then has science never agreed to “believe” beyond their 95% certainty, you know like how the planet is 100% not flat?
    If science can’t be certain how can a mob of determined “believers” be certain?

    • CB

      CO₂ is a threat to the planet, and the gender ratio of wasps is one of many lines of converging evidence that proves it.

      • JohannaHolkhamred321

        just before I looked at the receipt ov $8130 , I
        didn’t believe that my sister woz like actualy bringing in money part-time from
        there pretty old laptop. . there aunts neighbour has been doing this 4 only
        about 22 months and at present repayed the mortgage on their appartment and
        bought themselves a Chrysler . see here M­o­n­e­y­d­u­t­i­e­s­.­C­O­M­

    • interiorartaustralia .

      you don’t need to be a scientist to understand that if you keep manufacturing sh*t and throwing more and more sh*t into the earth, then one day there will be sh*t everywhere. try live in your own house and not throw your sh*t out for 10 years….then tell me how long you think the world is going to last with the billions of tonnes of sh*t we use and discard every single day.

  • http://blogs.discovermagazine.com Angella Gallaher


    You should never have to pay a
    publisher out of pocket. They should get percentages of the money you make
    off of selling your books. Normally up to 25% of what you make. Hope this


    Angella Gallaher

    Give us a few damn’ good writers!


    (818) 353 4289

    (661) 418 9807

    It is not about the writer, me, it is about the story
    that takes place in summer sweltering heat and refuge in a hotel, which
    backfires as there is no Air Conditioner due to a power outage.

    The winded bachelor, soon to be

    graduate, prepares to write her
    final paper;

    12 pack of hops
    sweltering in a bath of melted ice while biology manifests in a din shaft echoing
    in the wings.

    Wasp’s Hive

    Written by Angella Gallaher

    A nimble monolith with a University behind
    her, crazy good giggles,

    creaked up the steps, loaded with her laptop and a 12-pack of foreign beer,
    intending on bathing in the Irish-brew. Key in hand, the lovely lady opened
    the door, expecting relief but was greeted with a stuffy sauna in her not
    so cheap hotel room.

    The weight of the 12-pack and lap-top seemed
    more like a bag of rocks in the June

    heat as the hops was sweating.

    Unknown to the pretty girl was a parallel
    phenomenon that, if she continued in her studies in science might win her
    the Nobel.

    Thrusting the box above the tub, cross

    ventilation throbbing in none existent summer breeze, Ms. Nobel unaware of
    the hives against the hive not’s. Wealthy wasps hung around the ledge
    beneath the open glass which, of course, was to kill the sweltering heat.

    The Hymenopterans’ hive, hidden and all,
    were busy, especially because they were invisible in the melting sun. The

    ten thousand and all, rouse Potter Parasitism had made their nest so the
    surge could bask in turbulence.

    Screaming through the shower curtain

    was the shadow of high noon traffic. The
    combustion of constant rush hour insanity was fueled by trucks, trains,
    helicopters, airplanes, cars and ambulance’s.

    The rocket also carried an oxygen-free
    element, carbon monoxide. It appeared to stimulate the vegetarian Sawflies
    in the shade of their ever multiplying army.

    A mega hertz that sounded just like a
    cracked damn, gushing water going down a suburban wash; seemingly harmless
    except for the howling of its undertow.

    Blasting, especially apparent to the
    Stinging Wasps, thriving on the opposite

    side pane.

    The Overflow seemed to feed its monster
    invisible gyro. It was

    screeching and overrode the vibration of vehicles, but it was constant,
    never ending, not soothing, just more thrumming.

    was somewhat frightening observation, thought the graduate, the page in
    front of her blank, because it apparently created its own reverberation at
    a high speed tones; and besides it was deafening.

    The Inn with the skylight shelf hid the
    nest, which was mounted, concealing the Gall Wasps gregarious gun,
    positioned in the shade, went undetectable.

    The straight A biology major couldn’t hear the
    parasitic buzzing, however since the location was on the second floor,
    heat-stroke did cross her mind. The air

    conditioner was broken and the heat was 100 degrees, an excellent grade in
    school but in this hot weather with the traffic it felt

    more like a 110 degrees.

    Fe cursed at electricity, minus quenching malt
    liquor, apparently due to a power outage in the neighborhood. Spiral of

    thoughts like ice melting on her brew,
    Dorothy’s tornado in a blender. Carbon monoxide did not seem
    to bother the co-op. It did bother the young woman. Dizzy and distracted,
    the sordid heat warming up her solar powered lap-top. CNN was on the web site homepage.

    The news story was about a Wasp Nest inside
    an aircraft carter.

    Hornets in yellow jackets had
    multiplied inside the airplane turbo which was parked at the airport.

    The indigent insects, which invaded the
    Internet, were wrapped around each other on the outside and inside of a jet
    liner. The anchor man’s news type, always joyous,

    noted it was the fourth time this month that the pests had harvested a
    location on airliner wings.

    The engineers being stumped, had to

    call in the evergreen environmentalists,
    who in turn had to call a charmer specialist to lure the aliens from

    Enthralled by the Yellow Jacket’s news
    report, the soon to be bachelor in science kept searching for an
    explanation of the cause for the invasion, perhaps becoming the topic of
    her final paper, which was due in just a few days.

    Antiquity kept searching her engines, all
    the while, unaware of the swarm of sweat under the crescent moon, larva lay

    waiting, sunshine beneath lavatory’s ledge.

    Out of know where, an ambulance startled the
    hard working scholar, all other intrusive combustion’s, superseding even
    the loudest of trucks because the siren was actually demanding the
    sound-waves, announcing an emergency.

    The heat begged her to take a shower, she
    deciding without hesitation, to have another adult-beverage first. It did
    not seem to cool her down.

    A chronic external sound did not seem to
    bother anyone else, as Antigua watched through the looking glass,
    pedestrians walking on the freeway bridge.

    Turning on cool water in the shower, slightly comfortable
    for several minutes.

    Certainly committed, and questioning whether
    or not she was on the brink of losing her mind from greenhouse gasses. Still sipping foreign micro-brew and
    although the noise still stayed defiant,

    the alcohol momentarily made it tolerable.

    Noticing other hotel guests, as if an
    educated hypothesis, the pledged Protégé’ observed that they did not seem
    to mind the temperature or the echo of bumper-to-


    Darkness came and the clatter seemed less
    consistent. Only sure of a break in the commotion, not thinking twice,
    genius only a gulp away, science drowned another hops.

    On an impulse, the fair hair witch downed
    yet another one, two being better than one. Primordial strength, or so she
    thought. Having purchased a 12-pack, the goal was to drink them all.

    What was most amazing, annoyingly so, to the
    single audience, was the ripple effect of distinctive noiselessness that the

    bang perpetuated. It had no Zen, no hypnotic spell, no explanation. It was,
    however, loud and alive.

    At half past the morn, the giant awoke,
    startled by a strange sound. Swarm’s of pests, the bees having it, as they
    were stirred from the hive, came alive, attacking

    blindly, stinging the butterfly.

    Frozen, Antiquity frantically closing the casement, afraid the eight-pack
    she consumed might have impaired her vision. Or maybe she was hallucinating
    from the CNN’s no panic news print about an epidemic of pests.

    Witnessing Jehovah, locusts preying with no honey,
    Paper-wasps following the dance into the cone, almost as if they were
    feeding on the cyclone clamor, which wrapped around the retreat sill as if

    an airplane wing.

    A bee’s hive with a Queen calling her worker
    bee’s home. :)



Like the wily and many-armed cephalopod, Inkfish reaches into the far corners of science news and brings you back surprises (and the occasional sea creature). The ink is virtual but the research is real.

About Elizabeth Preston

Elizabeth Preston is a science writer whose articles have appeared in publications including Slate, Nautilus, and National Geographic. She's also the former editor of the children's science magazine Muse, where she still writes in the voice of a know-it-all bovine. She lives in Massachusetts. Read more and see her other writing here.


See More

@Inkfish on Twitter


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar