Cuttlefish Can Count to Five

By Elizabeth Preston | September 1, 2016 9:22 am

624px-Sepiapharaonis

Don’t look now, but this spineless sea creature may be able to count better than your toddler.

Cuttlefish need to be savvy if they want to eat. They’re always on the lookout for shrimp, fish or crabs. When a cuttlefish spots a potential victim, it shoots out two specialized, sucker-bearing tentacles and nabs it. Since these hunters have to make constant judgments about which prey are worth targeting, it would make sense for them to have advanced cognitive skills—say, the ability to count.

To find out whether this was true, Tsang-I Yang and Chuan-Chin Chiao, of Taiwan’s National Tsing Hua University, brought some Sepia pharaonis cuttlefish into the lab for a math exam.

The researchers hatched cuttlefish eggs and waited until the animals were a month old. Then they started testing the young cephalopods. In each test, a cuttlefish waited on one end of a tank, and researchers lowered a two-chambered box with clear walls into the other end. A partition jutted out from the center of the box toward the cuttlefish. As it swam toward the apparatus, the cuttlefish would have to make a choice between one chamber and the other.

Screen Shot 2016-08-30 at 11.39.57 AM

This is what a math test for cuttlefish looks like from above.

As soon as the cuttlefish made its decision and veered toward one side of the box, the researchers yanked the apparatus back out of the water. (This was likely annoying to the cuttlefish, but they got fed at the end of the testing session.)

To see how well the animals can count, the researchers put different numbers of shrimp into each of the box’s chambers, ranging from 1 to 5. If there were 5 shrimp in one side of the box and just 1 in the other, the choice ought to be easy. But could cuttlefish reliably choose 2 shrimp over 1, or 3 shrimp over 2? What about 5 over 4?

The scientists tested 54 cuttlefish. As expected, the animals had no problem picking a bunch of shrimp over a single shrimp. But they also passed every other test they were given. Cuttlefish were significantly more likely to pick the side of the box with more shrimp, even when choosing between 4 and 5.

Cuttlefish took longer to make these decisions as the ratios between the numbers got smaller (for example, 5 to 4 versus 4 to 3). Chiao says this is evidence that the cephalopods were actually counting the shrimp on each side, rather than judging the quantities at a glance.

Further experiments ruled out other possible explanations: Rather than counting, do cuttlefish just look for a denser batch of shrimp? No, because when researchers crowded small numbers of shrimp into tighter spaces to increase their density, the cuttlefish still picked the bigger number. Do cuttlefish simply seek out the wiggliest pile of prey? No again, as the researchers showed using boxes of dead shrimp.

Math isn’t the only factor influencing a cuttlefish’s decisions, though. Cuttlefish prefer live victims, and when researchers offered their subjects 1 live shrimp or 2 dead ones, they chose the former. When offered one big, fat shrimp or two smaller shrimp, hungry cuttlefish took the big one—but cuttlefish that had already eaten chose the two small shrimp. This might be because the big shrimp is a more tempting prize, but riskier for a young hunter to grapple with. For a cuttlefish who isn’t especially hungry, it might not be worth the risk.

Chiao says he wasn’t surprised by how well the cephalopods performed.

“We know that [the] cuttlefish has a complex brain and a sophisticated neural system,” he says. “Cuttlefish have to search for food constantly, so having number sense is important for their life.” Although the experiments stopped at 5 shrimp, Chiao suspects cuttlefish might even be able to count a little bit higher.

Similar research in year-old humans showed that they could judge the difference between 1, 2 or 3 items, but failed when quantities got any bigger. Rhesus macaques could judge between numbers going up to 4, but no higher. So this study, the authors write, “implies that cuttlefish are at least equivalent to infants and primates in terms of number sense.”

 

Image: by Stickpen (via Wikimedia Commons)

Yang TI, & Chiao CC (2016). Number sense and state-dependent valuation in cuttlefish. Proceedings. Biological sciences / The Royal Society, 283 (1837) PMID: 27559063

ADVERTISEMENT
  • http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/qz4.htm Uncle Al

    Cuttlefish Can Count to Five” Award them fully paid diversity scholarships to Columbia University re Cephalopod Studies, then hire them as EPA administrators.

  • polistra24

    “Cuttlefish have to search for food constantly, so having number sense is important for their life.”

    Not good logic. Almost every creature searches for food constantly, but VERY FEW creatures have real counting abilities, other than judging more vs less. In this case I’d be inclined to look for communication as the real purpose. Do cuttlefish use countable dot patterns on their skin? Visual Morse?

    • JohnnyD

      You’re right. Most all creatures display the ability to count to one, as in they can differentiate between nothing (zero) and something (more than nothing), which is all that is required to feed themselves. Given that they’ve already identified the item(s) as food, that is, and since they can only eat them one at a time, anyway. No need for additional brainpower just to accomplish that, it’s like the most primordial instinct to evolve, even before sexual reproduction.

      I thought it was common knowledge that cuttlefish were intelligent because of the complex nuances of their chromatophore-based communication, as you said. Why anyone would tie their counting ability to searching for food is odd. Are they implying cuttlefish pass up the small groups of shrimp they come across in favor of finding larger groups, by counting them? I would wager they would pass up nothing at all within their catching range, regardless of quantity, and that this ability to count was born of something else, and only later used to distinguish “some” shrimp from “more” shrimp in the lab test.

  • Isaac42

    Of course cuttlefish can count. After all, their brains are bigger than their entire bodies.

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GDwOi7HpHtQ

    • Mark

      It’s it literally impossible for a brain to be larger than the body it belongs to? I mean, it’s inside of it…

      • Isaac42

        You may find this difficult to understand, but not the cuttlefish, on account of its enormous brain.

  • Gary Millam

    With 8 arms do they use base 8 to count???

    • JohnnyD

      Hard to judge that one until they’ve progressed as far as counting to nine.

      But I do think this bumps cuttlefish up a notch on the universal intelligence scale, to a point just above Uncle Al. Who seems to believe that cephalopods attend universities and head government agencies. Which of course explains his ranking. Even cuttlefish know that’s silly.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Inkfish

Like the wily and many-armed cephalopod, Inkfish reaches into the far corners of science news and brings you back surprises (and the occasional sea creature). The ink is virtual but the research is real.

About Elizabeth Preston

Elizabeth Preston is a science writer whose articles have appeared in publications including Slate, Nautilus, and National Geographic. She's also the former editor of the children's science magazine Muse, where she still writes in the voice of a know-it-all bovine. She lives in Massachusetts. Read more and see her other writing here.

ADVERTISEMENT

See More

@Inkfish on Twitter

ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar
+