The Shoulder Bone's Connected to the Ear Bone…

By Carl Zimmer | October 15, 2008 1:00 pm

ear [10/16/08 Correction appended: see end of post]

When our ancestors moved ashore some 360 million years ago, they underwent a lot of changes as they evolved from ocean-swimming fish to land-walking tetrapods. For one thing, they needed feet instead of fins. Paleontologists have discovered a series of fossils that document the early evolution of limb bones in our aquatic ancestors, showing how long bones first evolved, then parts of the wrist and digit-like bones, and finally full-blown feet. But lots of other changes happened at the same time, producing traits in tetrapods not found in other animals. Tetrapods, for example, are good at hearing airborne sounds, thanks to small bones that can vibrate in their ears. The earliest of those bones to have evolved was the stapes. But the stapes did not come from nowhere.

New clues to the origin of our ears  were published today in the journal Nature. They come from a fossil known as Tiktaalik, a 370-million-year old fish with a lot of tetrapod features, such as neck and a very leg-like fin. (See this Loom post on Tiktaalik for details.) Tiktaalik’s discoverers first published a description of the beast back in 2006, but there was only space for a tiny portion of the details they uncovered in its skeleton. Today they report on Tiktaalik’s skull.

In some respects, Tiktaalik’s skull was still fish-like. It had a hinge down the middle that allowed the front and back ends to bend. Later in the evolution of tetrapods, that hinge hardened, making the skull stiffer. But other parts of the skull had already evolved to be more like our own. For example, in our close aquatic relatives, there’s no neck to separate the head and shoulders. Instead, there are a series of bones. One, called the operculum, covers the gills. Between the operculum and the braincase is a boomerang-shaped bone called the hyomandibula. Some of the muscles attached to it helped fishes pump their gills, and it also buttressed the bones of the skull as they opened and closed when the fish fed. In Tiktaalik, the operculum is gone. The hyomandibula, as a result,  lost its connection to the shoulder region.

These changes suggest that Tiktaalik could move its head more, because it was freed from the shoulders. It had also lost the ability to pump a lot of water through its gills. By this point in evolution, the ancestors of tetrapods were relying less on gills for getting oxygen. Living in shallow coastal waters, Tiktaalik may have used its powerful front limbs to do push-ups in order to breathe air instead.

And once the hyomandibula was liberated from the shoulders, it could evolve to specialize for new roles. As other fossils reveal, the hyomandibula would evolve in a small bone that came into contact with the skull, able to transmit vibrations from the air. In other words, it became the stapes. A diagram below shows some stages in this transition.

What’s particularly cool about the evolution of our ear is that it was assembled over hundreds of millions of years from other parts. Tiktaalik helps reveal how the stapes evolved some 370 million years ago, but there are other bones in the ear–the incus and malleus–that transmit vibrations in our heads. They only evolved 150 million years later from some bones in the back of the jaw. They too were liberated from old jobs, and free to take on new ones. The ear was not an overnight invention, but the product of an inconceivably long evolutionary tinkering.

Hyomandibula

Source: Jason Downes et al, “The cranial endoskeleton of Tiktaalik roseae.” Nature  doi:10.1038/nature07189

Illustration: Kalliopi Monoyios

Ear image: Wikipedia

Correction: I’ve updated this post to correct some errors about the operculum (gill covering) and hyomandibula. Apologies to the anatomists!

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Evolution

Comments (6)

  1. twilightened

    Three bones, from different particular purposes, coming together to help hearing out of the water. That is pretty amazing. I knew about the jaw bones, but a bone from the shoulder transforming to an ear bone :) That is really well, weird so to speak. Weird nature :)

  2. kobeboy

    In higher fish the weberian apparatus connects the swim bladder to the inner ear. It’s also an assemblage of modified ribs and vertebrae. So it may not be so weird.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

The Loom

A blog about life, past and future. Written by DISCOVER contributing editor and columnist Carl Zimmer.

About Carl Zimmer

Carl Zimmer writes about science regularly for The New York Times and magazines such as DISCOVER, which also hosts his blog, The LoomHe is the author of 12 books, the most recent of which is Science Ink: Tattoos of the Science Obsessed.

ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »