The Flesh of Physics

By Carl Zimmer | January 26, 2009 4:24 pm

Muybridge horse infinite repeat

Our bodies are bunches of atoms, and like any rock or star or other bunch of atoms, we have to obey the laws of physics as we move. But each species obeys those same laws in its own way. My cat leaps onto my desk most mornings, his grace unblemished by the paper clips and computer cables he kicks onto the floor. A maple tree outside bends in the wind, a happy medium between flopping over and snapping in two. A hawk arrives at the tree and lands precisely on a branch. On their own, our eyes cannot tell us much about the different ways in which living things move. We can’t see the invisible vortices of air spiraling behind a hawk, the stresses experienced by different parts of the leaning maple, the thrust and torque generated by my cat as he rises into the air.

The first glimpse into this invisible world came in 1872. Leland Stanford, a railroad tycoon and the founder of Stanford University, spent a lot of time watching his race horses run. He was sure that when they trotted, there were moments when all four legs left the ground. Legend has it that he even bet $25,000 that they did.

Stanford paid a famed landscape photographer named Eadweard Muybridge to find out if he was right. Muybridge had horses trot down a path strung with threads connected to a row of cameras; when the horses snapped the threads, the cameras snapped the pictures. It took Muybridge years to perfect a shutter fast enough and film sensitive enough to capture the images (he also needed some time off to defend himself–successfully– against the charge that he had murdered his wife’s lover). But in 1877 he was finally able to give Stanford his answer. Horses do indeed bring all their legs off the ground during each cycle of a gallop. Later, Muybridge built contraptions that could display his pictures in quick succession. His moving pictures brought the horses back to life.

Eventually Muybridge made his way to the University of Pennsylvania, where he photographed many other four-legged animals. He found that whenever they ran, they lifted all their legs off the ground at once. Even two-legged humans did. That complete lack of contact with the ground, in fact, came to define the act of running. Muybridge’s photographs also revealed other rules. When four-legged animals walk rather than run, their feet usually hit the ground in the same pattern: hind left, front left, hind right, front right. Here’s a diagram of the cycle in a walking horse.

horse-walking600.jpg

Muybridge opened the way to the scientific study of life in motion. These days, biologists can film animals with high definition video cameras and use computers to calculate the speed and direction in which different body parts move. They can put sensors on animals or have them run over force-sensitive plates to measure the thrust they generate with their muscles. Instead of Muybridge’s flickering photographs of horses, we can enjoy their glacial grace in movies like this, from researchers at the Royal Veterinary College:

These superior tools have allowed scientists to discover some of reasons that animals move the way they do. The cycle of footfalls in a walking dog or a walking elephant, for example, is the best way to keep a four-legged animal stable. Walking is not just stable, but also efficient, because it turns animals, in effect, into pendulums. A pendulum can swing for such a long time because it continually recovers some of its energy. On its downward stroke, it’s powered by the force of gravity; when it reaches the lowest point of its arc it has so much energy that it can counteract gravity and swing upward. When you walk, your body behaves like an upside-down pendulum: the foot you plant in front of you is the pendulum’s axis, your center of mass the hanging weight. In the beginning of your stride you work against gravity, vaulting your center of mass upward with your leg until you reach your highest point. Gravity then takes over, and your body swings downward until your other leg hits the ground. The next stride is even easier. You can use the energy given to you by gravity to vault yourself into your second and all successive steps, just as a pendulum reclaims its energy in each swing.When you run, however, you stop behaving so much like a pendulum and begin behaving more like a pogo stick. Now when you first plant your leg, your body sinks down on it instead of rising up. Your leg actually acts as a brake for your body, and so your center of mass is at its lowest point when your acceleration is lowest. Meanwhile your tendons are acting as springs. As they stretch and snap back, they store and release energy, just like the spring in a pogo stick, and propel you upward and forward.There are many other ways to move around, of course. If you’re a cockroach or a centipede, you can use more than four legs. It turns out that many of the same rules that govern walking and running among us vertebrates also apply to invertebrates. Meanwhile, other researchers are discovering the rules behind other kinds of motion, like flying, jumping, and swimming.

For all the advances in biomechanics, however, it turns out that a lot of people still live in a pre-Muybridge universe. A team of biologists, biophysicists, and a veterinarian in Hungary recently did a survey of the depictions of animals in museum displays and other places. In each case, the researchers determined whether the poses of the animals followed the basic rules for how four-legged creatures move.The grades they handed out were pretty dismal. Museum displays were wrong 41% of the time. Taxidermy catalogs were wrong 43% of the time. Animal toys were wrong half the time. And, incredibly, coming in dead last were animal anatomy books–63.6% wrong.

Here, for example, is an illustration of a horse not being a horse. B is a diagram showing its limbs. C and D show two real poses it could have taken.

anatomy-horse600.jpg

And here’s a picture of an aardwolf in a museum display doing what no self-respecting aardwolf would do.

aardwoolf600.jpg

I was surprised that there are so many biomechanical mistakes out there, especially on such a simple matter of how to position an animal’s legs. To be fair, a lot of the biomechanical misktakes in museums are baggage they carry from the past. Today museums are following Hollywood’s lead and are working with biomechanics experts.

John Hutchinson of the Royal Veterinary College has done some pioneering work on how dinosaurs walked, and his research is the basis of an exhibit called Be The Dinosaur. Here’s a sample of the computer simulations the exhibit has to offer.

Tyrannosaurus Walk Cycle from Tom Spilman on Vimeo.

I first became fascinated with biomechanics in the mid-1990s, and I often dreamed of embedding movies on the pages of my articles. Words could only go so far, and photographs couldn’t go that much further. Most of my futuristic dreams have not come to pass, or have proven to be banal disappointments. But when it comes to writing about biomechanics, the future is here, and it is good. This will be the first of what I hope is a long line of blog posts about life in motion, illustrated with moving images that Muybridge could not imagine.

Reference: Horvath et al.: “Erroneous quadruped walking depictions in natural history museums.” Publishing in Current Biology, Vol. 19, No. 2, January 27, 2009

Muybridge Portrait: Smithsonian

Aardwolf and walking horse courtesy of Gabor Horvath and Adelinda Csapo

CATEGORIZED UNDER: Life In Motion

Comments (30)

  1. Martin

    The tyrannosaurus’s roar after silently walking for 30 seconds or so gave me quite a jolt.

    Looking forward to more from you.

  2. Truly mesmerizing. I’m happy that we now have the technological know-how to actually peer into the past, and observe such a spellbinding thing as an animals gait.

  3. Nice article, Carl, really interesting. You might like to find the spot in History of Animals by Aristotle where he says that all animals must keep at least three limbs in contact with the ground. He includes snakes…

    I mention it in my piece on the Mayfly.

  4. iratecat

    I’ve been told that cats and camels are the only animals who don’t follow the walking pattern you described – is it true, and if so, does anyone know why? I’m off to observe my own cat’s biomechanics.

  5. Galapagos

    Great idea! I seem to remember cheetahs doing something strange when running at high speeds… Can’t recall what it was though

  6. Joel Sammallahti

    I’ve always loved Muybridge’s work. There are several books available with his photo series of horses, people and other animals walking, jumping etc. I’ve got to say though, the tyrannosaurus looks weird. I have no expertise whatsoever, but it looks too light on its feet somehow. Granted, those are huge calf muscles, but wouldn’t one expect a horizontal biped’s hips to rotate or spine to bend during a stride? Especially with the feet so far apart? Maybe not, I wouldn’t know, but it looks a bit fake. Then again, lots of real things do.

  7. Noumenon

    Given that museums don’t have any way for you to actually learn why their exhibit looks the way it does (say, a link to this article), I’d say the money they put into making it look natural is wasted.

  8. Shawnie Fever
  9. Sal

    How about The Physics of Flesh.

  10. Muybridge plates can be purchased from Mondrian’s room:
    Mondrian’s Room

    Full Disclosure: I know the owners of the gallery.

  11. Ian

    Galapagos, the cheetah’s hind legs pass the front legs when it is at a full sprint. Good arfticle, especially since I’m studying pendulum’s in physics now.

  12. Alan Fox

    …survey of the <strong<depications of animals in museum displays…

    Depications? Depictions, surely. </nitpick ;)

  13. Terrific article! Just one quibble: you seem to use “trot”, “run”, and “gallop” as synonyms. “Run” and “gallop” are, but the “trot” is an entirely different gait.

    Some horses pace rather than trot – they move both legs on the same side forward. It’s faster than a trot but it’s also less stable, which is why pacing harness racers have their legs fastened together by the harness, to keep them from breaking gait around the curves (see this picture).

  14. I never though i’d gret to read with so much interest a biomechanics article.

    Great job!

  15. PS – “This will be the first of what I hope is a long line of blog posts about life in motion, illustrated with moving images that Muybridge could not imagine.”

    Yay! Can’t wait!

  16. Rawdge

    Is it just me, or is the horse in that YouTube video not following the rules as described? From what I can see, it looks like its pattern goes RH, LH, RF, LF. Am I missing something? Or is there any particular reasoning behind why there might be the discrepancy?

  17. Davi

    In defense of the anatomists, it seems possible that the best anatomical illustration (maximum density of detail, clearly portrayed) might sometimes not be the most biomechanically realistic.

  18. The horse in the video is galloping, not walking. That is a different gait.

  19. Michael D.

    Saw a special on the Animal Planet the other night about Whippets (small greyhound-like dogs). During their running cycle, all four feet are off the ground twice, once when the legs come together, like the horse, and once when the legs are outstretched, Superman-style. I suspect this may also be the case with cheetahs and perhaps greyhounds as well.

  20. Dani Long

    I wonder, do giraffes break the rules? Their movements seem similar to the example of the pace horses (but they do their same-side leg movements naturally, because of their leg/back length ratio).

    Also, the T. rex video was fascinating and surprising — I’d always imaged them to have longer strides. This fellow looked to me almost as though he was tiptoeing. Did they never fully extend their ‘knee’ joints?

    Great article!

  21. Dani Long

    Update to my own inquiry: after looking at giraffe videos on YouTube, I realized that they walk just like the diagram shows (the footfalls of hind and front feet on the same side happen a bit closer in time than those of the walking horse).

  22. http://digitalcuttlefish.blogspot.com/2009/01/walking-walk.html

    I thought I’d take an afternoon and visit the museum
    I’d heard they had some new things, and I thought I’d like to see ‘em
    One skeleton, a walking dog, was what I liked the best—
    But its front was moving eastward, while its back was moving west!
    The skeletons of dinosaurs were also really neat
    Though something seemed a little wrong in where they put their feet
    The tails looked right, the ribs were right, the spine, the head, the mouth—
    But their front feet pointed northward, while their back feet pointed south!
    I figured a museum ought to know which way is right,
    So I walked a little differently when I went home that night
    Now I’m flummoxed and I’m puzzled, and I feel like such a dork—
    See, I’ve one foot in Seattle, and the other in New York.

  23. BThirkield

    I have never considered the physics-side of biology! It is refreshing to know that such a difficult subject can be applied to practically any other area of knowledge in ways which we underestimate. After reading this, I can better understand the relationship between form and function, especially when it comes to animals and as it relates even to humans. It was a pleasure reading this!

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

The Loom

A blog about life, past and future. Written by DISCOVER contributing editor and columnist Carl Zimmer.

About Carl Zimmer

Carl Zimmer writes about science regularly for The New York Times and magazines such as DISCOVER, which also hosts his blog, The LoomHe is the author of 12 books, the most recent of which is Science Ink: Tattoos of the Science Obsessed.

ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »