DISCOVER Magazine. Science, Technology and The Future
Current Issue
Subscribe Today »
  • Renew
  • Give a Gift
  • Archives
  • Customer Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • Health & Medicine
  • Mind & Brain
  • Technology
  • Space
  • Human Origins
  • Living World
  • Environment
  • Physics & Math
  • Video
  • Photos
  • Podcast
  • RSS
The Loom
« Bonobo Outbreak: Update from Democratic Republic of Congo
DNA in the Mail and the Future of Life »

Evolution In Two Minutes: You Make The Movie

Check out the new contest from Discover…

Share

April 3rd, 2009 1:48 PM by Carl Zimmer in Evolution | 6 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

6 Responses to “Evolution In Two Minutes: You Make The Movie”

  1. 1.   Tuatara Says:
    April 3rd, 2009 at 5:19 pm

    I am an agnostic evolutionary biologist who feels that the way the contest is framed is way to confrontational. The following phrase just makes me feel sick:

    “Think you can convince even the most hard-headed creationist that Darwin was right? If so, show us—and that creationist—how it’s done.”

    Discover is better than this…at least I hope so.

  2. 2.   Ed Schwab Says:
    April 4th, 2009 at 12:04 am

    Does evolution really make sense to anyone? why would anything evolve? WHY? If every specie is happy, can move around and find food there is no reason to change. Why does any other specie exist today, shouldnt they be extinct considering we are here now? What will we evolve into? E.T.

  3. 3.   Anne Says:
    April 4th, 2009 at 5:56 am

    I have an issue with the same statement. How long are we going to equate evolution with Darwin’s theory? Evolution is made up of genetic drift and gene flow AND natural selection. Natural selection is just one of them. And people need to know this. The more we keep saying Darwin & Evolution in the same breath, we propagate this misconception.

  4. 4.   NewEnlandBob Says:
    April 4th, 2009 at 6:25 am

    I have an issue with the whole concept. This is another example of dumbing down in America. Trying to reduce this to a two minute video is ludicrous. There are a dozen beautifully written scholarly treatises on the subject. Next there will be a contest for a six second sound bite.

  5. 5.   Antaeus Feldspar Says:
    April 17th, 2009 at 11:55 pm

    “Does evolution really make sense to anyone? why would anything evolve? WHY? If every specie is happy, can move around and find food there is no reason to change. Why does any other specie exist today, shouldnt they be extinct considering we are here now? What will we evolve into? E.T.”

    Ed –

    Populations don’t change because there are “reasons” to change. Populations don’t “reason” at all. A species doesn’t reason and say “Hey, I’m happy, I can find lots of food, I guess I’ll stay the same” or “hey, I’m UNhappy, I’m underfed, I gotta evolve” any more than a sieve says “Hey, I’ve got a mixture of chunky rocks and fine sand in me, but I think I’ll keep the rocks and let the sand fall through my wire mesh.”

    Why would the existence of humans as a species mean that all other species would be extinct? Honestly, it’s hard to figure out why you think this would be so. It seems like you are trying to offer the following syllogism:

    1. If some descendants of a particular common ancestor evolve into a particularly “good” new species, that common ancestor should not have any other descendants that evolved in any other way;
    2. Humans are a particularly “good” and special species;
    3. Therefore no other species should exist that evolved from any common ancestor of humanity.

    Where does #1 come from?? I mean, maybe everyone agrees that Larry has the best job, out of all the graduating class of 2008 — the day after the graduation, he started work as a lawyer at a top-flight firm at a six-figure salary. Does that mean that no one else who graduated in that same class can have ANY job at all? Does that mean that Bob can’t be a plumber, because Larry’s a lawyer? (High-priced lawyer or not, Larry’s life is gonna be pretty dire, if there’s no plumbers he can call when his pipes burst.)

  6. 6.   News Round › British Centre for Science Education Says:
    May 3rd, 2009 at 5:03 am

    [...] Evolution In Two Minutes: You Make The Movie [...]

Leave a Reply





    • About The Loom

      "Celebrated curiosity monger"

      --Brain Pickings

      Carl Zimmer writes about science regularly for the New York Times and magazines such as Discover, where he is a contributing editor and columnist.

      He is the author of twelve books, the most recent of which is Science Ink: Tattoos of the Science Obsessed. His website is carlzimmer.com and his address is blog at carlzimmer dot com .




    • Google Profile


    • Facebook

    • RSS Recent Posts

      • Animal Friendships: My cover story for Time magazine
      • The Future of E-books–podcast of my interview on Wisconsin Public Radio
      • Thursday, February 16: Science and social media panel in New York
      • A Scientific Jonah: My profile of Joy Reidenberg in tomorrow’s New York Times
      • Ebooks on the radio: 6 pm ET tonight
    • Science Tattoo Emporium

      I once wondered aloud if scientists had tattoos of their science. The answer was yes, and this ever-growing collection is the evidence. I've turned them into a book about art and science called Science Ink: Tattoos of Science Obsessed.


    • Loom Junior

      My Tumblr home for scattershot
    • Books

      Carl Zimmer is the author of twelve books and counting.



      "Beautiful. Packed with fascinating stories"-Nature
      Order a copy




      "Whether discussing the common cold and flu, little-known viruses that attack bacteria or protect oceans, or the world’s viral future as seen through our encounters with HIV or SARS, Zimmer’s writing is lively, knowledgeable, and graced with poetic touches.”—Rebecca Skloot, author of The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks
      Available in hardback or Kindle




      “Carl Zimmer takes us behind the scenes in our own heads. He has ferreted out all the most wondrous, bizarre stories and studies and served them up in this delicious, sizzling, easy-to-digest platter of neuro-goodness.” —Mary Roach, author of Packing for Mars and Stiff
      An ebook exclusive: Amazon, Barnes and Noble, carlzimmer.com




      New! More Brain Cuttings:
      Further Explorations of the Mind
      Order from Amazon and Barnes & Noble and Apple



      The Tangled Bank: An Introduction to Evolution

      "The Tangled Bank is the best written and best illustrated introduction to evolution of the Darwin centennial decade, and also the most conversant with ongoing research."--Edward O. Wilson, Harvard University
      Order a copy



      Microcosm: E. coli and The New Science of Life

      "Superb...quietly revolutionary"--Boston Globe
      Order a copy



      Soul Made Flesh: The Discovery of the Brain and How It Changed the World

      "Fascinating...thrilling... Zimmer has produced a top-notch work of popular science."--Los Angeles Times
      Order a copy



      Evolution: The Triumph of An Idea

      "As thorough as it is graceful...This is as fine a book as one will find on the subject."--Scientific American
      Order a copy



      Parasite Rex

      "A book capable of changing how we see the world."--The Los Angeles Times
      Reissued with a new epilogue by the author.
      Order a copy



      At the Water's Edge: Fish With Fingers, Whales With Legs, and How Life Came Ashore But Then Went Back to The Sea

      "A fascinating story, which Zimmer unfolds as a tale of high-stakes scientific sleuthing."--Booklist
      Order a copy

    • Twitter Updates

        follow me on Twitter
      • Comment Policy

        Light but firm. Details here.
      • Recent comments

        • vhutchison on Animal Friendships: My cover story for Time magazine
        • gsgs on Flu Fighters
        • 4u1e on Flu Fighters
      • Categories

      • Blogroll

        • A Blog Around the Clock
        • Aetiology
        • Babel’s Dawn
        • Bad Science
        • Creature Cast
        • Culture Dish (Rebecca Skloot)
        • Dan Ariely
        • David Dobbs
        • dechronization
        • Developing Intelligence
        • Evolution & Medicine Review
        • Gene Expression
        • Genome Boy
        • Genomicron (Ryan Gregory)
        • io9
        • john hawks
        • John Rennie
        • Jonah Lehrer
        • Knight Science Journalism Tracker
        • Laelaps (Brian Switek)
        • Language Log
        • Mind Hacks
        • Mind Matters (David Berreby)
        • Mixing Memory
        • Mystery Rays From Outer Space
        • Nobel Intent
        • Not Exactly Rocket Science
        • Oscillator
        • Pharyngula
        • Prerogative of Harlots
        • RealClimate
        • Robert Krulwich
        • Sandwalk
        • Science Cheerleader
        • Science Made Cool
        • Skeptical Science
        • Small Things Considered
        • Speakeasy Science (Deborah Blum)
        • Steve Silberman
        • Steven Johnson’s blog
        • Superbug
        • synthesis
        • Tetrapod Zoology
        • The Intersection
        • The Inverse Square Blog
        • The Last Word On Nothing
        • The Panda's Thumb
        • The Tree of Life
        • This Week in Evolution
        • Why Evolution Is True
        • Word Routes (Ben Zimmer)
        • Zooillogix
      • My stuff

        • CarlZimmer.com
        • Facebook
        • microcosm: E. coli and the New Science of Life
        • My article archive
      • Archives

      • Nifty Fifty

      • Why “The Loom”?

        "...among the joyous, heartless, ever-juvenile eternities, Pip saw the multitudinous, God-omnipresent, coral insects, that out of the firmament of waters, heaved the colossal orbs. He saw God's foot upon the treadle of the loom, and spoke it; and therefore his shipmates called him mad." --Moby Dick


    • Kalmbach Publishing Co.

      Copyright © 2012, Kalmbach Publishing Co.

      Privacy - Terms - Reader Services - Subscribe Today - Advertise - About Us