Google Steps Away from Humanoid Robot PR Problem

By Jeremy Hsu | March 18, 2016 11:42 pm
The Atlas humanoid robot stands second from the left in a lineup of walking robots. Credit: Boston Dynamics

The Atlas humanoid robot stands second from the left in a lineup of walking robots. Credit: Boston Dynamics

Google has not been shy about placing big bets on the future of robotics and artificial intelligence. But even the Silicon Valley giant may not feel ready to fully embrace humanoid robots and the uncomfortable questions they pose about the relationship between machines and humanity.

Several robots shaped like humanoids or four-legged creatures were being developed by Boston Dynamics, a robotics company bought by Google for $500 million at the end of 2013. For years, Boston Dynamics has been famous for posting online videos showing its walking robots maintaining their balance despite being kicked and shoved by the company’s human employees. One of the latest videos of the Atlas humanoid robot, published in February 2016, triggered a slew of YouTube comments that described the robot as “terrifying” or referenced Hollywood’s “Terminator” films about an artificial intelligence called Skynet destroying humanity. Such reactions apparently made Google’s public-relations team wary of wading into the online debate, according to Bloomberg News.

“There’s excitement from the tech press, but we’re also starting to see some negative threads about it being terrifying, ready to take humans’ jobs,” wrote Courtney Hohne, a director of communications at Google and the spokeswoman for the Google X lab, in emails posted to an internal Google forum.

Hohne also suggested that colleagues should “distance X from this video” to avoid triggering additional media speculation. “We’re not going to comment on this video because there’s really not a lot we can add, and we don’t want to answer most of the Qs it triggers,” she wrote.

The same Bloomberg News story revealed that the Google parent company, Alphabet Inc., has decided to put Boston Dynamics up for sale. The decision had more to do with the fact that Boston Dynamics’ walking robots seemed unlikely to lead to a commercial product within the next few years, according to sources interviewed by Bloomberg News. (A Boston Dynamics “robotic mule” called LS3 was recently turned down by the U.S. military after field tests with U.S. Marine foot patrols.)

Still, it’s intriguing to get a glimpse of how Google is attempting to deal with the public perceptions and attitudes toward the rise of robots and artificial intelligence (AI). Some of the negativity comes from experts having long predicted that robots and AI could become disruptive economic forces that may eliminate the need for certain human jobs. Lifelike robots may cause uneasiness in part because their growing capabilities evoke countless science fiction stories of machines surpassing humanity.

Robots with increasingly lifelike forms and movements may also make people uncomfortable because of the so-called “uncanny valley” phenomenon. In 1970, Japanese roboticist Masahiro Mori first discussed the idea of the uncanny valley to describe the psychological discomfort of seeing figures that appear almost human but not quite.

But human reactions to robots go well beyond just fear or discomfort. The closer future robots get to the human form, the greater the chance for humans to empathize with the machines or even fall in love with robots. Nobody appears to have fallen in love with Boston Dynamics’ Atlas humanoid robot. Yet many YouTube comments expressed sympathy for the robot as they perceived the machine being pushed around and “bullied” by the humans.

YouTube Comments on Atlas Robot

That outpouring of sympathy for the Atlas robot even spawned a few parody videos that dubbed new voices over the Boston Dynamics video. The “Auralnauts” YouTube channel made a video that depicts Atlas as a box-loving robot bullied by its human creators.

A second parody YouTube video turns Atlas into a foul-mouthed humanoid robot swearing at its human overseers.

Google may no longer have to worry about public relations for humanoid robots if it succeeds in selling Boston Dynamics to another company. But the tech giant still faces similar challenges in making the public feel comfortable with its self-driving robot cars. Such driverless vehicles hold the promise of potentially reducing traffic gridlock and making the roads safer in the future. But first, Google and other companies must win the hearts and minds of both drivers and pedestrians alike. It’s probably no accident that one of Google’s prototype robot cars has a “face” resembling that of a cuddly koala.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: mind & brain, technology, top posts
  • Uncle Al

    Google’s “Don’t be evil,” Alphabet’s “Do the Right Thing,” hence withdrawal. What could be nicer than a North Korean human wave attack meeting a DARPA/Boston Dynamics cheetah and Atlas counteroffensive (with hard-faced Hello Kitty! Chobham armor glacis plates)?

    the psychological discomfort of seeing figures that appear almost human but not quite” Congress, activists, priests, rock stars, athletes (e.g., Caitlyn Jenner), 1968 Czechcago riots’ police counterforce…clowns.

  • George Kapotto

    To begin, I am totally comfortable with the concept that these are just machines completely without feelings or any higher level awareness.

    Nevertheless, my empathy subroutine still kicks in when I see Atlas persevering after being pushed around or stumbling in the snow. And I KNOW that nobody is home…

    Perhaps this bridge across the uncanny valley correlates to our empathy for ‘highly evolved’ animals. We see human characteristics in that which is not human and attribute to an executive function which may not be anything more than a complex tropism.

    How long before we see People for the Ethical Treatment of Androids?

  • Shalryn

    As much as these Boston Dynamics robots push all my anthropomorphic buttons, what scares me are the robot cars. I’ve noticed that in movies these days, people get trapped in their robotic cars on train tracks and the like. I take that to mean I’m not the only one who sees a potential flaw in a vehicle that runs only on software. Whether the flaw is exploited maliciously or occurs as a security or functional glitch, it is there, and it will very likely kill some people.

    • Andrew Kiener

      Bad “software” kills thousands of people every day in human-driven cars. To be a net improvement in safety, robot cars don’t have to be perfect, they just have to be better than us. And it wouldn’t make much sense to sell a robot car that doesn’t have some basic safety overrides for its occupants.

  • Francis Jacob

    Have you ever imagined an Artificial Human Size Humanoid Robot. Do you think it is possible?

    Yes it is possible. Our company iBrain Robotics is going to introduce India’s 1st Artificial Human Size Humanoid Robot ‘SANDY’. This robot will replace many technologies at the same time that is many technologies in one robot.

    If you don’t believe then you may just login to our official website and also see the youtube video in the links shared below :-


Lovesick Cyborg

Lovesick Cyborg examines how technology shapes our human experience of the world on both an emotional and physical level. I’ll focus on stories such as why audiences loved or hated Hollywood’s digital resurrection of fallen actors, how soldiers interact with battlefield robots and the capability of music fans to idolize virtual pop stars. Other stories might include the experience of using an advanced prosthetic limb, whether or not people trust driverless cars with their lives, and how virtual reality headsets or 3-D film technology can make some people physically ill.

About Jeremy Hsu

Jeremy Hsu is journalist who writes about science and technology for Scientific American, Popular Science, IEEE Spectrum and other publications. He received a master’s degree in journalism through the Science, Health and Environmental Reporting Program at NYU and currently lives in Brooklyn. His side interests include an ongoing fascination with the history of science and technology and military history.


See More

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar