No ‘Westworld’ Can Contain the Real Rise of AI

By Jeremy Hsu | January 21, 2017 5:00 pm
A train carries human visitors to the futuristic amusement park of "Westworld" populated by robot hosts. Credit: HBO

A train carries human visitors to the futuristic amusement park of “Westworld” populated by robot hosts. Credit: HBO

Nobody would accuse the HBO show “Westworld” of being a sunny science fiction tale about artificial intelligence. The show features humanlike robot “hosts” who live, die, and live again to serve the fantasies of human guests visiting a Western-themed amusement park. But the dark premise of “Westworld” is still escapist fiction compared with real concerns surrounding the rise of artificial intelligence.

The lurking threat of a “Westworld” robot uprising begins with the premise of artificial intelligence (AI) confined within the boundaries of the amusement park. Human visitors wishing to play cowboy or cowgirl arrive in the Westworld amusement park on a train, indulge in their immersive vacation experience, and then leave on the train. The managed pleasures and dangers of the Wild West fantasy—supported by the robot hosts—remain cordoned off within the park and safely separated from the rest of the world.

But don’t mistake the enjoyable science fiction premise of “Westworld” for real life. Like the railroads that helped transform the Wild West, AI technologies have already begun sweeping across the land and and transforming the human communities they touch. They are poised to reshape the fundamental underpinnings of both individual human livelihoods and entire national economies.

For now, real AI technologies do not consist of the sentient or possibly rebellious robot variety. A new report titled “Amplifying Human Potential: Towards Purposeful Artificial Intelligence” loosely defines AI as “any activity that used to only be done via human intelligence that now can be executed by a computer.” Such AI technologies handle a dizzying array of tasks such as visual perception, speech recognition, decision-making and natural language processing in support of products and services used by millions of people every day.

An ‘Inevitable’ Rise of AI

The new report reflects a popular view that the AI revolution is unstoppable. The Indian multinational company Infosys commissioned a survey of 1,600 senior leaders in major organizations around the world to gauge their views of AI technologies. Among those surveyed, 71 percent see the rise of AI as “inevitable” and believe it will be disruptive.

The companies that participated in the report invested $6.7 million on average in AI last year, and had been using AI for about two years on average. But most don’t expect to reach “mature” adoption of AI technologies for another three years. “Meanwhile, only 25 percent state that they have AI technologies fully deployed and working as expected,” the report says. “Of those that use it, only 10 percent believe they are fully maximizing the current available benefits of AI.”

To gauge organizational readiness for the AI revolution, the report ranked countries and certain sectors of the economy based on an “maturity index.” The index assigned scores to certain answers that added up to a total score, with the highest possible score being 100 percent.

For example, a small number of organizations that scored within the highest maturity level of 80 to 100 percent were described as having “already successfully deployed AI throughout their businesses and are reaping the benefits.” On the least prepared side of the spectrum, a “small but significant” group of organizations that scored between zero and 20 percent were described as having “no current deployment of such technologies and no plans to do so in the near future. ”

But most countries and industries had scores that fell somewhere in the middle group (40 to 59 percent) known as “explorers.” This group was described as having “partial deployments of AI” that were “proving their value,” and the desire to expand further with more AI initiatives coming in the next year.

AI Leaders and Laggards

The leading countries and industries stand poised to make the most of the rise of AI. China and India led the pack in terms of the report’s average maturity scoring by country. That may partially reflect greater confidence among Chinese and Indian leaders about their organizations’ investments in AI. But the report also suggests that both countries have “fewer legacy systems and business processes” holding back adoption of AI technologies.

Among the participating countries, China (56 percent) and India (55 percent) were followed by Germany (53 percent), the United States (46 percent), UK and France (both 44 percent). Australia bought up the rear with a respectable average score of 40 percent.

Most industries ranked fairly respectably in the middle “explorers” group, but a few stood out. The pharmaceutical and life sciences industry ranked the highest at 58 percent, followed by automotive and aerospace (54 percent), telecoms (52 percent), energy, oil/gas and utilities (51 percent), manufacturing (50 percent), fast moving consumer goods (50 percent), healthcare (50 percent), financial services (47 percent) and retail (44 percent).

The only sector that scored relatively low by comparison was the public sector at 32 percent. That suggests government organizations probably have the longest way to go in terms of adapting AI technologies.

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

The benefits could be huge for those countries and industries racing to adopt AI technologies. Business leaders expect to see a 39 percent boost to revenues on average and a 37 percent reduction in costs by the year 2020. In addition, 70 percent of leaders expect AI to deliver positive societal benefits beyond corporate bottom lines. And 76 percent expect AI to bring about positive economic change.

But as the dark premise of “Westworld” suggests, the rise of AI does not come without some fear of humans becoming displaced. An overwhelming majority of the leaders believe that their employees have concerns about AI (90 percent). Of those employee concerns, the leaders pointed to data safety (43 percent) and privacy (34 percent) as being the chief areas of worry. Another 28 percent say that AI will have some impact on the “human dignity” of their employees.

Robert Ford (Anthony Hopkins) and Bernard Lowe (Jeffrey Wright) watch the creation of new robot hosts in the HBO TV show "Westworld." Credit: HBO

Robert Ford (Anthony Hopkins) and Bernard Lowe (Jeffrey Wright) watch the creation of new robot hosts in the HBO TV show “Westworld.” Credit: HBO

Similarly, 88 percent believe that customers also have concerns about AI. Of those concerns, respondents pointed to a lack of understanding about AI’s use as being the biggest source of concern (41 percent). Another 38 percent of respondents saw mistrust of technology as the biggest source of concern for customers.

Working Together with AI

Human mistrust or fear of AI is not without some basis. Like other technologies, the rise of AI technologies will almost certainly put some human workers out of their jobs. Some economists argue that AI technologies will still have more positive benefits for both human workers and society than negative impacts, but that’s no consolation for those workers who lose their jobs during the transition process.

A previous survey of business leaders showed that a significant number believed that AI and robotics would make people “largely irrelevant” to the future of work. But this latest survey by Infosys implies a more positive future for human workers. The vast majority of respondents in the Infosys report (80 percent) said they would retrain or redeploy human employees whose jobs are impacted by AI technologies.

In addition, 53 percent of the leaders said they are specifically investing in skills development for their human workers. Among the different countries, 95 percent of Chinese organizations said that AI would cause greater investment in their workforces. China was followed closely by France at 90 percent and Germany at 89 percent. The UK and U.S. organizations lagged somewhat behind with 82 percent and 76 percent, respectively, saying that AI would lead them to invest more in their workforces.

“This is an optimistic sign that fears may be misplaced and that AI deployment and worker redundancy do not necessarily go hand in hand,” according to the Infosys report.

The science fiction of “Westworld” focused on the implications of sentient AI becoming rebellious and discontent with human control. To earn a more optimistic future in the real world, leaders will need to take appropriate steps to ensure that the rise of AI does not sow the seeds of discontent for humans.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: technology, top posts
  • m242424

    I could give you real strong AI today, But I am not going to.
    For 1 billion, I would revolutionise the whole industry overnight with each company and country scrambling.

    tsk, 1 billion. Give me 500 billion so at least I could fund a colony on mars with it

  • Uncle Al

    WHAT DO WE WANT? Evidenced-based science!
    WHEN DO WE WANT IT? After peer review!

    • Edwin Medina

      This is the way you possibly can make quite decent income monthly… You can Try it yourself! After been without work for 6 months, I started off freelancing over this website and at this time i couldn’t be more satisfied. After 6 months on my latest job opportunity my per month income is around 12k per 30 days…>>FACEBOOK.COM/Tina-E-King-610592265811198/app/208195102528120/

    • Brett Gibson

      I’ve earned $104000 in 2016 by doing an on-line job from home a­­n­­d I was able to do it by wo­rking part-time for few h each day. I followed a business opportunity I stumbled upon online and I am so amazed that I was able to earn so much money. It’s very beginner friendly and I’m just so grateful that i discovered it. Here is what i did…FACEBOOK.COM/Jobs-from-home-for-US-UK-Cananda-Australia-and-New-Zealand-251232438633700/app/208195102528120/

    • Brenda Boyd

      I was paid 104 thousand bucks last year by working online from my house and I did it by w­o­r­k­i­n­g part time f­o­r several hours every day. I was following an earning opportunity I was introduced by this website i found on-line and I am so amazed that i earned so much money. It’s beginner friendly and I’m so thankful that i discovered this. Here’s what I do… TIMELY84.COM

  • Anton Nolan

    Curtis. if you think Shirley `s comment is good… on tuesday I got myself themselves a Jaguar XJ from earning money $4331 this-past/month or even more than ten-k this past-month. with-out a doubt this is the easiest-job I have actually had. I started this 8-months back and almost instantly started off to bring home not less than $81.. per hour. Find the facts…>> FACEBOOK.COM/Tina-E-King-610592265811198/app/208195102528120/

  • John C

    Please sign my new White House Petition and then help spread the word through your Facebook, Twitter and email lists. When we reach 150 signatures it will be publicly posted on the White House web site. At 100,000 signatures we will get an official response from the Trump Administration. Thank you

    The New Manhattan Project for Fusion Energy

    WE THE PEOPLE ask President Trump to announce and spear head an international effort to develop a practical means of utilizing nuclear fusion by the end of his term. The New Manhattan Project will provide an inexhaustible, clean source of energy for humanity.

    As a political benefit It will inspire and bring together Liberals and Conservatives for the goals of finally eliminating our dependence on carbon fuels and vastly stimulating the economy.

    It will provide a great boost to scientific research, education and progress.

    It will result in countless new spin off technologies and business opportunities from fusion tech itself as well as from the vast source of energy it will supply to power new ventures.

    It will offer an area of cooperation not only with friendly nations but also with Russia and China.

    • Uncle Al

      Successfully controlled hot nuclear fusion is merely a matter of scale. No reduction to practice – little fusor, Z-pinch, tokamak, optical implosion, H-bomb…stars – is the right scale. They are all unrectifiable messes of recursive turbulence.

      Gigawatt civilian nuclear reactors are run by a handful of Navy veterans. Hot fusion research is armies of PhDs. Thank you for your interest.

      • stephen connell

        Human kind can’t control the tools it has now so god forbid what it would do with Nuclear fusion.

  • Byron Spencer

    I’ve seen the first few episodes of this series and found it entertaining at most. Yes, the dark themes underlying it were undeniable, but I guess that’s one of the main selling points of the show (it’s based on a book by the way). Surely, a community of conscious and rebellious robots sounds inevitable, but we’re really a long way off. For the mean time, AI will of course, thrive and evolve, posing increasing risks like unemployment; putting human workers at a serious expense. I only hope that as an entire race, we are prepared to pay the price when the time comes.

  • stephen connell

    Question; How do you prevent AI from being discontented with it’s human creators? Anybody care to answer the question?


Lovesick Cyborg

Lovesick Cyborg examines how technology shapes our human experience of the world on both an emotional and physical level. I’ll focus on stories such as why audiences loved or hated Hollywood’s digital resurrection of fallen actors, how soldiers interact with battlefield robots and the capability of music fans to idolize virtual pop stars. Other stories might include the experience of using an advanced prosthetic limb, whether or not people trust driverless cars with their lives, and how virtual reality headsets or 3-D film technology can make some people physically ill.

About Jeremy Hsu

Jeremy Hsu is journalist who writes about science and technology for Scientific American, Popular Science, IEEE Spectrum and other publications. He received a master’s degree in journalism through the Science, Health and Environmental Reporting Program at NYU and currently lives in Brooklyn. His side interests include an ongoing fascination with the history of science and technology and military history.


See More

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar