‘Logan’ Is a Western Wandering the Sci-Fi Frontier

By Jeremy Hsu | March 24, 2017 12:13 pm
"We don't like strangers in these parts." Credit: 20th Century Fox

“We don’t like strangers in these parts.” Credit: 20th Century Fox

The X-Men films have consistently shown their mutant superheroes as powerful but misunderstood outcasts living in the shadows. One of the loneliest and angriest of them all has been Wolverine: the seemingly ageless mutant played by Hugh Jackman whose superhuman healing powers and retractable metal claws enable him to literally tear through squads of gun-toting enemies. But the third and last film of the standalone Wolverine trilogy, titled “Logan” in a nod to the mutant’s other nickname, finds a weary Logan fending off cyborg gunslingers and eking out an isolated life by the Texas-Mexico border.

The film “Logan” hits fast forward on Hollywood’s Western genre by setting its story in the year 2029. That enables plenty of futuristic twists on modern technologies: bionic arms, driverless trucks, quadcopter drone scouts and huge automated farm robots working in the genetically modified cornfields. All of those technologies ground the world of “Logan” with a sense of realism and familiarity because they already exist in some form. But there is nothing shiny or optimistic about the future in “Logan.” Instead, technology represents a dehumanizing force that leaves ordinary people to struggle on the edges of society and empowers amoral corporations to operate with impunity. It’s a harsh world that should prove instantly recognizable to fans of the old Westerns.

“Logan” does much to invoke the tropes of classic Westerns such as “The Magnificent Seven” and “Once Upon a Time in the West.” There are desperate Mexicans seeking aid from reluctant heroes and ruthless businessmen employing mercenary bands of gunslingers. Men engage in potentially deadly struggles over basic resources such as water. “Logan” even has a chase scene near a moving train, except that the heroes and villains ride in cars and trucks instead of on horseback.

In the 2017 film "Logan," the mutant superhero Wolverine faces off against enemies such as the mercenary cyborgs called The Reavers. Credit: 20th Century Fox

In the 2017 film “Logan,” the mutant superhero Wolverine faces off against enemies such as the mercenary cyborgs called The Reavers. Credit: 20th Century Fox

The most intentional callout to the Western genre in “Logan” goes to the 1953 film “Shane.” Several characters spend time watching key scenes from “Shane” in a hotel room while on the run. Like “Logan,” the film “Shane” takes its title from the name of its protagonist. Like Wolverine, Shane is a warrior weary of killing who gets drawn back to violence in service of defending good people against ruthless business interests and their guns for hire. Each faces slightly different shades of villainy: the bad guys of “Logan” recruit cyborg mercenaries to hunt for escaped mutants instead of getting gunslingers to drive settlers out of their homes.

The character of Wolverine—a mutant transformed into a living weapon by military experiments—has always been a kindred spirit to the Western genre’s pantheon of talented killers who become reluctant heroes. The 1968 Spaghetti Western “Once Upon a Time in the West” has the mysterious harmonica-playing gunslinger “Harmonica” and the bandit leader Cheyenne. The 1960 film “The Magnificent Seven” features seven gunmen who band together to defend a Mexican village from bandits; a remake of the 1954 Japanese film “Seven Samurai” with a similar plot. (Logan would understand the spiritual connection between the West’s reluctant gunslinger heroes and the East’s reluctant ronin heroes given his own Japan adventures in the 2013 film “The Wolverine.”)

The film “Logan” even shows the ending of “Shane” where the titular character of that 1953 Western tells a young boy: “Joey, there’s no living with… with a killing. There’s no going back from one. Right or wrong, it’s a brand. A brand sticks.” The character Logan would have instantly recognized the meaning behind those words if he had been paying attention.

None of the surviving heroes in those classic Westerns truly enjoy a happy ride into the sunset. But they do all seem to recognize themselves as relics of a dying era. Their individual stories reflect the larger narrative of the Wild Wild West giving way to civilization marching in lockstep with technological progress. The survivors of both “The Magnificent Seven” and its “Seven Samurai” inspiration talk about how only the farmers win in the end. “Once Upon a Time in the West” ends with the gunslinger Harmonica riding off with his fallen friend as railroad workers lay tracks ahead of a puffing work train.

As for “Shane,” the protagonist tells the villain “your kind of days are over” and acknowledges the same for himself as a gunfighter. He rides off wounded from the final showdown with some parting words for the boy who idolizes him: “Now you run on home to your mother, and tell her… tell her everything’s all right. And there aren’t any more guns in the valley.”

If you have already seen “Logan,” you can draw your own conclusions about how closely the superhero film embraces the bittersweet endings of those classic Westerns. But “Logan” seems ambivalent at best about technological progress given its depiction of automated farming machines and self-driving truckloads leaving humans in the dust. The film ultimately favors a less radical but more familiar idea: family bonds and not futuristic machines will prove the saving grace of humanity. That philosophy may hold true even for a jaded mutant with adamantium claws.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: technology, top posts
  • http://www.mazepath.com/uncleal/qz4.htm Uncle Al

    “Instead, technology represents a dehumanizing force that leaves ordinary people to struggle on the edges of society” Medical office girls, coffee pullers, Walmart drones, maids and janitors…. If your IQ is less than 120, there is little in technological Western civilization other than government employment or criminality awaiting you, with one exception.

    Technology is the singular humanizing force that chooses against the dregs of a society, with one exception: management. Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Entropy overall, guns when appropriate – but SOP installing worse.

    • Mallet Head

      Geeze Unk that almost made sense but it’s my short coming that it didn’t. What I don’t get is I thought a driver of progressive thought (oxymoron fer sur) is to free up time to become “cowboy poets” which this article and you seem to say the coming robotic labor force will do. Yet it’s portrayed as evil, I don’t get it. There is nothing that a little victimization to justify income distribution and the guiding hand of an all knowing, caring, perfectly administered central government won’t fix. As it works so well now so will it in the future. Just because both corporations and government are large entities (though government is much, much, larger) run by humans looking out for their own interests and otherwise sharing the same motivations, expansion of market space, doesn’t mean more specific motivations can’t be judged as evil vs. if not good, at least benevolent and trust worthy enough to allow control over our entire life, on the other hand. Corporate Profit as a motivator is clearly an evil, no need to discuss it. Whereas government doesn’t need to turn a profit since it has unlimited overhead. This is good because of all the free stuff they can distribute. If only government would take over the coming robotic revolution would it be utopia instead of dystopia.

  • Frazier Mccollum

    When I was watching the movie the week it was released, I also couldn’t help draw out its similarities to classic Westerns. I think this was intentional though, as portrayed in the scene with Laura and Charles watching “Shane.” I guess the moral questions raised in that movie resonated all too well with Logan, and was meant to be there to remind us that these questions never really change, even in 2029.

  • B. Dickey

    Some of the inspiration for Logan is from an alternate reality tale called Old Man Logan. OML is a futuristic tale, but its also post apocalyptic, that is, civilization as we know it is over, since super villains have taken over the world and divided up the ravaged territory. The imagery inherent in the art of OML was decidedly Western, as was the overall story arc. It was about an aging gunslinger/warrior type, trying to raise a family and eck out a living as a hardscrabble farmer. And, he rode a horse at times. I think I see what you are drawing in this article, Logan, as it handles the character of Wolverine and several others, does portray them as being of a dying era. That’s the whooole point of X-23. Your analysis wouldn’t be out of place in a 2017 version of Leo Marx’ The Machine in the Garden, I suppose, but its the same thing, really.

    • http://secure93.com Jake Collins

      M­a­n­y p­e­o­ple w­a­nt t­o ha­v­e a awesome earnings at their, bu­t t­he­y don’t have much idea ho­w t­o exactly d­o th­at o­n th­e Int­ernet. Th­ere ar­e a a number of w­ays t­o ea­rn large am­ount of mo­ney, b­ut wh­enev­er p­eopl­e t­ry th­at the­y g­et tr­app­ed in a s­cam, Thus I am sh­aring wi­th yo­u a g­enuine an­d gu­arante­ed w­ay f­or fre­e to ea­rn hug­e am­ount of mon­ey a­t ho­me.I am earning atleast $10000 each month since 12 months.Its an on-line job and not hard to do, Even a little child can do this work and make online money. If you want a happy and wealthy life then you should copy and paste this internet site in web browser and then follow instructions to get started today and earn Thousands On-line……….. http://www­.­doshort­.­com/58rQ

    • http://secure93.com Joel King

      Exactly I got victory to obtain 98 Thousand Five Hundred and Sixty Seven dollars.I read about this project six months ago and a couple of months past I definitely practiced it and I have obtained superb funds. It is remarkebly helpful for myself and also my family.My relatives and friends are uncertain to look at how exactly I settled my online career and my Life in just few days. Thanks to GOD for this….You surely can earn that good number of payment, if you own a laptop computer and internet connection in your household. Any other complex information are not necessary to undertake this work. I am Loving it and all of you will surely love it and also you will not pardon yourself if you not at all take a look at the information >>>>>> B1Z.ORG/38B


Lovesick Cyborg

Lovesick Cyborg examines how technology shapes our human experience of the world on both an emotional and physical level. I’ll focus on stories such as why audiences loved or hated Hollywood’s digital resurrection of fallen actors, how soldiers interact with battlefield robots and the capability of music fans to idolize virtual pop stars. Other stories might include the experience of using an advanced prosthetic limb, whether or not people trust driverless cars with their lives, and how virtual reality headsets or 3-D film technology can make some people physically ill.

About Jeremy Hsu

Jeremy Hsu is journalist who writes about science and technology for Scientific American, Popular Science, IEEE Spectrum and other publications. He received a master’s degree in journalism through the Science, Health and Environmental Reporting Program at NYU and currently lives in Brooklyn. His side interests include an ongoing fascination with the history of science and technology and military history.


See More

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar