“Right Wing Brain Surgeons” And The NFL

By Neuroskeptic | July 28, 2015 5:07 am

This week (via Retraction Watch) we learned about the case of Joseph Maroon. Earlier this year Maroon and colleagues published a paper arguing that the much-discussed issue of chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE) may not be a widespread problem in contact sports such as American football.

doctormask

However, it turns out that Maroon did not fully declare his conflicts of interest, which include links to the NFL and also World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE).

Maroon, who amongst other things is lead neurosurgeon for the Pittsburgh Steelers football team, issued a Correction acknowledging his interests in this area. The question of which athletes are at risk of CTE has potential legal and financial implications for sports organisations such as NFL and WWE.

Now this story got my attention because Maroon is also linked to Surgical Neurology International (SNI), an academic journal that I blogged about earlier this year: Right-Wing Brain Surgeons.

In that post I discussed how some of SNI’s editorials are overtly political in nature, with nothing to do with brain surgery. I also discussed the complicated history of the journal.

Maroon is an associate editor-in-chief of SNI and has published a number of papers there. Most notably, he has co-authored papers, including one on CTE, with Russell Blaylock, another SNI editor. Blaylock is a controversial figure some of whose beliefs can only be described as fringe.

For example, in the pages of SNI, Blaylock has written that:

The foundation upon which Western civilization was built was religion… collectivists not only seek to destroy Judeo-Christian beliefs but also are aggressively altering the church from inside so that it too becomes a voice of egalitarian collectivism, that is, the new world order.

This would be good material for a conspiracist blog, although I’m less clear on how it was deemed suitable for an academic journal. In other places, Blaylock has argued that vaccines cause brain damage, and that chemtrails are real (and cause brain damage.)

The papers Maroon helped write seem relatively sensible, although the CTE article does mention “vaccinations” as one potential contributing factor to brain “immunoexcitotoxicity”. Hmm.

Incidentally, SNI was once linked to another figure who’s in the headlines lately: Ben Carson, a neurosurgeon and author who’s currently running to become the next Republican President. His campaign has been endorsed by Kid Rock.

Surgical Neurology (the predecessor to SNI) in 1996 published “The physician’s role in curing social ills” by Benjamin Carson MD. This article was originally a speech that Carson gave in 1993.

It’s an autobiographical piece, describing how Carson grew up in “dire poverty” yet worked his way up to become, at 33, the youngest ever Head of the Department of Pediatric Neurosurgery at Johns Hopkins.

The piece is not overtly political, although Carson does comment on the limitations of the US educational system, and closes by decrying “silly people running around saying you cannot mention God in public and that it is a violation of separation of church and state.” Carson does not seem to have associated with SNI since then.

ADVERTISEMENT
  • John C

    There are quite a few political activists in science: Noam Chomsky, GMO deniers, even pseudo-scientists “proving” liberals’ brains are intellectually superior to conservatives’, sheesh. Not to mention the early 20th century eugenecists.

    • http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/neuroskeptic/ Neuroskeptic

      Chomsky doesn’t use specialist scientific (linguistics) journals to push his political views though (not as far as I know). He keeps his political activism and his academic life distinct.

      • OWilson

        Ah, apparently it’s only “right wing” professionals that don’t.

        Ever hear of Pachauri? Hansen?

      • https://www.teepublic.com/user/ECM Ergo

        Well, that was certainly an inartful dodge of John C’s comment…

        • http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/neuroskeptic/ Neuroskeptic

          Well I didn’t want to just say “two wrongs don’t make a right” but sure, I’ll say it.

          Just because some other academics have politicized their science too doesn’t make it okay in this case.

  • lump1

    Recent metastudies have shown a significant correlation between SNI and brain damage.

  • OWilson

    I usually get my science from science journals, but any article in a “science” magazine that mentions Republicans, Right Wingers, in its headline is of interest to me because I’m a self confessed conservative. :)

    I looked for the alleged “once linked”, “connection” between “right wing brain surgeons” and poor Dr. Carson.

    As, usual, there’s no “there”, there.

    If I was a leftist, I’d cry racism!

    • http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/neuroskeptic/ Neuroskeptic

      Well apart from anything else Carson is himself both right-wing and a brain surgeon.

      • OWilson

        How terrible!

        And he was once linked to …….?

        Does he share those folks views on chronic traumatic encephalopathy? Someone dug deep into his past.

        Anybody ask him?

        • http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/neuroskeptic/ Neuroskeptic

          I never said he did share those views. I said “Incidentally, SNI was once linked to” Carson, I didn’t say Carson was directly linked to Maroon or Blaylock.

  • practiCalfMRI

    Definitely not one of your better posts, NS. Starts out well enough but then goes into hearsay and free association mode. If you write anything on Donald Trump (pronounced “chump”) I’m off, mate.

  • ejhaskins

    He MIGHT be right though! Maybe the brain damage preceded the involvement in football!

  • Tannahill Glen

    As much as I abhor lack of disclosure of potential conflict of interest (in politics as much as in science), let’s not be naive and think zealous CTE researchers have less financial skin in the game than the NFL or WWF; there are A LOT of zeroes in those grant funds.

  • CentralBlueArmy

    I’ve known this for years,this is why one side can’t convince the other to change,by the way I’m a conservative.

  • Pingback: Ben Carson and the Power of the Hippocampus - Neuroskeptic()

  • Pingback: Ben Carson and the Power of the Hippocampus ⋆ Epeak . Independent news and blogs()

  • Pingback: Ben Carson and the Power of the Hippocampus – Credence Nation()

  • Pingback: Ben Carson and the Power of the Hippocampus - World Fast News()

  • Pingback: Sergio Canavero: Will His Head Transplants Roll? - World Fast News()

  • Pingback: Sergio Canavero: Will His Head Transplants Roll? ⋆ Epeak . Independent news and blogs()

  • Pingback: Sergio Canavero: Will His Head Transplants Roll? - Press News Reporter()

  • Pingback: Sergio Canavero: Will His Head Transplants Roll? – Read News Daily()

  • Pingback: Sergio Canavero: Will His Head Transplants Roll? | Facts Behind News()

  • Pingback: Sergio Canavero: Will His Head Transplants Roll? – Press News Reporter()

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Neuroskeptic

No brain. No gain.

About Neuroskeptic

Neuroskeptic is a British neuroscientist who takes a skeptical look at his own field, and beyond. His blog offers a look at the latest developments in neuroscience, psychiatry and psychology through a critical lens.

ADVERTISEMENT

See More

@Neuro_Skeptic on Twitter

ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar
+