Vagus Nerve Stimulation Restores Consciousness?

By Neuroskeptic | September 28, 2017 2:58 pm

A report that nerve stimulation was able to partially restore consciousness in a patient in a vegetative state has attracted a great deal of attention this week.

vagus_vegetative

The paper, published in Current Biology from French researchers Martina Corazzol and colleagues, is certainly promising, but I didn’t find it entirely convincing.

Corazzol et al.’s patient was a 35-year old man who had been in a vegetative state for 15 years following a car accident. After receiving consent from his family members, surgeons implanted a device to electrically stimulate the patient’s vagus nerve. Vagus nerve stimulation is a quite widely used technique for the treatment of epilepsy (and, experimentally, for depression), although its mechanism of action remains unclear.

So what happened? After the stimulator was switched on, the intensity of the current was ramped up over a period of five weeks. The patient’s level of consciousness, as rated by a clinician using the Coma Recovery Scale-Revised (CRS-R), increased around week four. The CRS-R scores are shown below as the red line, with stimulus intensity in blue.

corazzolIt can be seen that the increase in CRS-R scores was not entirely sustained. While the patient scored 10 on two consecutive days, he later dropped down to 6-8 points, even though the stimulation continued at the maximum 1.5 mA. A score of 10 still represents severe impairment: the maximum (best) score on the CRS-R scale is 23.

Another reason to be a little wary of the CRS-R changes is that the┬áthere was no ‘placebo’ control condition. While a patient in a vegetative state is hardly likely to experience the placebo effect, the clinicians making the CRS-R ratings might. Corazzol et al. don’t state that the raters were blind to the timing of the treatment.

Corazzol et al. also used EEG and PET to measure the patient’s brain activity and how it changed during the vagus nerve stimulation. These results showed:

Vagus nerve stimulation enhances information sharing within a centro-posterior network… extensive increases of activity in occipito-parieto-frontal and basal ganglia regions

The neuroimaging work is interesting from a research point of view, but what ultimately matters in a study like this are the clinical results. These were promising, but I think the headlines are over-optimistic. This is very much a preliminary study and the results seem mixed to me.

CATEGORIZED UNDER: EEG, papers, placebo, select, Top Posts
ADVERTISEMENT
  • TLongmire

    Anyone studying conscience should approach it empathically and not purely ” scientifically” because there is a real chance that the mind is not the brain and just because we satisfy our selves doesn’t mean we aren’t affecting others.

  • glio

    Thanks for your nice analysis ! – M. Corazzol and G. Lio

  • Not_that_anyone_cares, but…

    Please, I have been conscious enough already!

  • smut clyde

    Viva las vagus!
    My big question is whether the “increases of activity in occipito-parieto-frontal and basal ganglia regions” persist if the vagus stimulation is turned off again. If the activity is just entrainment of those bits of cortex to the stimulation, naturally it would be synchronised, but I don’t know about counting it as “consciousness”.

  • Astor

    Thanks a lot for this accurate analysis ! At least I can see that I am not alone to think that we aren’t sure at all that there is here one results, because the protocol is not scientific enough … the stimulation should have been turned off at least once, then turned on again (etc), and the clinical assessment should be done more frequently during the baseline , to ensure that it is not the repetition of the examinations that allows to detect more the little behavioral signs. And, very important, the examinator should be blind to the intervention.

  • daniele marinazzo

    so the subject eventually died

    http://www.lemonde.fr/sciences/article/2017/10/03/le-patient-sorti-de-l-etat-vegetatif-est-mort_5195330_1650684.html

    but they did not say it before

    is it the ultimate file-drawer or what?

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Neuroskeptic

No brain. No gain.

About Neuroskeptic

Neuroskeptic is a British neuroscientist who takes a skeptical look at his own field, and beyond. His blog offers a look at the latest developments in neuroscience, psychiatry and psychology through a critical lens.

ADVERTISEMENT

See More

@Neuro_Skeptic on Twitter

ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Collapse bottom bar
+