DISCOVER Magazine. Science, Technology and The Future
Current Issue
Subscribe Today »
  • Renew
  • Give a Gift
  • Archives
  • Customer Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • Health & Medicine
  • Mind & Brain
  • Technology
  • Space
  • Human Origins
  • Living World
  • Environment
  • Physics & Math
  • Video
  • Photos
  • Podcast
  • RSS
Not Exactly Rocket Science
« ScienceOnline 2010 redux – in which I’m interviewed by Bora
Crayfish females lure males with urine, but then play hard to get »

Tree rings reveal two droughts that sealed the fate of Angkor

AngkorToday, the city of Angkor in Cambodia lies in ruins. But a thousand years ago, life there was very different. Then, Angkor was the heart of the Khmer empire and the largest preindustrial city of its day. It had a population of a million and an area that rivalled modern Los Angeles. And the key to this vast urban sprawl was water.

Radar images of the city by the Greater Angkor Project (GAP) revealed that Angkor was carefully designed to collect, store and distribute water. The “Hydraulic City” included miles of canals and dikes, irrigation channels for supplying crops, overflow channels to cope with a monsoon, massive storage areas (the largest of which was 16km2 in area), and even a river diverted into a reservoir. Water was the city’s most precious resource, allowing it to thrive in the most unlikely of locations – the middle of a tropical forest.

But water, or rather a lack of it, may have been part of Angkor’s downfall. Brendan Buckley from Columbia University has reconstructed the climate of Angkor over the last 750 years, encompassing the final centuries of the Khmer Empire. The records show that Angkor was hit by two ferocious droughts in the mid-14th and early-15th century, each lasting for a few decades. Without a reliable source of water, the Hydraulic City’s aquatic network dried up. It may have been the coup de grace for a civilisation that was already in severe decline.

Many theories have been put forward for the downfall of Angkor, from war with the Siamese to erosion of the state religion. All of these ideas have proved difficult to back up, despite a century of research. Partly, that’s because the area hasn’t yielded much in the way of historical texts after the 13th century. But texts aren’t the only way of studying Angkor’s history. Buckley’s reconstruction relies on a very different but more telling source of information – Fujian cypress trees.

Fujian_cypressThe trees in question grow in Bidoup Nui Ba National Park in neighbouring Vietnam. They’re a while away from Angkor in Cambodia but their location is far less important than their age. These trees have been growing for around a thousand years and they were around when Angkor was in its prime.

Throughout this time, the climate affected their speed of growth. During years of plenty, they expanded in width far more quickly than during unfavourable drought years. These trends are reflected in the size of their rings and Buckley sampled those by cutting cylindrical cores from the trees. These samples could be very accurately carbon-dated and they provide an invaluable record of the climate in Southeast Asia over at least the past 759 years.

In Buckley’s record, two droughts stood out in terms of their severity and length. The first one in the mid-1300s was the most sustained period of drought in the region over the last eight centuries. The second, while shorter, was often more severe, and included the driest year on record – 1403. The timings of these droughts coincided with periods when the surface temperature of the Pacific Ocean was unusually high. Buckley suggests that El Nino, a periodic warming of the Pacific, may have driven the two dry spells.

These disasters have been corroborated by other evidence. Records from Chao Phraya in Thailand also referenced severe droughts in the 14th century, and the dry spells may even have extended into Sri Lanka, India and China.

During this time, the climate also reversed dramatically, with intense monsoons following the two droughts. These oscillating extremes of too little water following by far too much of it pounded the infrastructure of the Hydraulic City. Today’s ruins show signs of the failing structures that marked the city’s end days. Assaulted by sediment carried in floods, some canals suffered metres of erosion in a short space of time. One, which linked the capital with a nearby lake, is now filled with coarse sand and gravel, which suggests that it was rapidly filled by a single flood. That would have suddenly cut the city off from a major water source.

There are signs that the people of Angkor tried to cope with their fluctuating environment by modifying their network. However, that’s easier said than done with a criss-crossing infrastructure that spans a thousand square kilometres. The complicated lattice of waterways would have struggled to adapt.

Of course, a changing environment was far from the only reason behind the fall of Angkor. By the time the droughts kicked in, the city was already weakened by social, economic and political strife. Buckley simply thinks that the climate simply sealed the city’s demise. In fact, others have suggested that some force may have pushed the local people to move from inland agriculture to maritime trade. Buckley says that this transition coincides neatly with the aftermath of the first drought.

Reference: Buckley, B., Anchukaitis, K., Penny, D., Fletcher, R., Cook, E., Sano, M., Nam, L., Wichienkeeo, A., Minh, T., & Hong, T. (2010). Climate as a contributing factor in the demise of Angkor, Cambodia Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0910827107

Images: Angkor Wat by Bjørn Christian Tørrissen; tree by Juan Pablo Moreiras

  • An 60,000-year old artistic movement recorded in ostrich egg shells
  • Tuberculosis, not cancer, killed Dr Granville’s mummy
  • The fall and rise of lefties in Victorian England
  • 35,000-year-old German flutes display excellent kraftwerk
  • Prehistoric carving is oldest known figurative art
  • How inbreeding killed off a line of kings

http://images.google.co.uk/imgres?imgurl=http://www.unep-wcmc.org/information_services/publications/gtc/images/JM_Hoang_lien_Som_2-5-1.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.unep-wcmc.org/information_services/publications/gtc/images.htm&usg=__KgIjMfmVU0Iwrb_7oSbXY0045R0=&h=1600&w=1038&sz=468&hl=en&start=4&sig2=PvnnG0T6kzXS9KYjeSBCRQ&um=1&itbs=1&tbnid=bH13BsynQ1-VgM:&tbnh=150&tbnw=97&prev=/images%3Fq%3DFokienia%26um%3D1%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dfirefox-a%26sa%3DX%26rls%3Dorg.mozilla:en-GB:official%26tbs%3Disch:1&ei=1GqvS42POMzf-QbW3LCsDQ
Share

March 29th, 2010 Tags: angkor, cypress, drought, monsoon, tree rings
by Ed Yong in Anthropology and social science, Climate change, Environment, History, Uncategorized | 10 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

10 Responses to “Tree rings reveal two droughts that sealed the fate of Angkor”

  1. 1.   dearieme Says:
    March 29th, 2010 at 5:04 pm

    “a while away”: can’t you use a standard measurement? How many Nelson’s columns is that? Or London Buses?

  2. 2.   dearieme Says:
    March 29th, 2010 at 5:06 pm

    P.S. Can you explain why tree rings are rain gauges if you’re studying Angkor Wat, but thermometers if you’re studying Global Warming?

  3. 3.   Joel Says:
    March 29th, 2010 at 9:38 pm

    Tree ring density is basically a measure of how good the conditions are for growing trees. So if tree growth is limited by temperature, then the tree rings are a proxy for temperature. If tree growth is limited by rainfall, then tree rings are a proxy for rainfall, and so forth.

    The tree rings used for temperature are from trees at quite high latitudes, where temperature has historically been the limiting factor. Angkor, obviously, is somewhat more tropical and so has different limiting factors.

  4. 4.   Wsa Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 4:49 am

    A good example of the importance of environmental factors in human history, too often neglected by traditional historians. It should be included in the next edition of Jared Diamond’s “Collapse”

  5. 5.   Ed Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 4:57 am

    The paper, incidentally, lists several similar examples of environmental factors affecting past civilisations. Should really have added that to the piece – will try to dig them out later on tonight.

  6. 6.   dearieme Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 7:36 am

    Thanks, Joel. But unless one has rain gauges and thermometers where the trees grow, how can one know?

  7. 7.   Mike from Tibeca Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 1:33 pm

    Fascinating stuff, Mr. Yong. Keep up the great work.

  8. 8.   Brian Schmidt Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 2:38 pm

    #6 “unless one has rain gauges and thermometers where the trees grow, how can one know?”

    We do have such things and they have validated the hypotheses, except for some weirdness in recent decades that might be attributable to high CO2 levels.

  9. 9.   dearieme Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 4:34 pm

    Thanks, Brian. But to know that the SE Asian trees were measuring rainfall several centuries ago, you’d presumably have to know what the local temperatures were at the time?

    Also: “We do have such things and they have validated the hypotheses, except for some weirdness in recent decades” – but we have had widespread rain gauges and thermometers for only, what, ca 10 decades, so “recent decades” must form a decent part of the record. It seems to boil down to “it works sometimes and not other times”, which seems pretty unsatisfactory.

  10. 10.   Brian Schmidt Says:
    March 30th, 2010 at 7:47 pm

    “But to know that the SE Asian trees were measuring rainfall several centuries ago, you’d presumably have to know what the local temperatures were at the time?”

    If you want 100% certainty, maybe, although even then someone would argue about confounding factors. In reality, you’ll never find 100% certainty in science. Anyway, try RealClimate for more info and links:

    http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2009/11/a-treeline-story/

    And temp records are good for about 160 years.

Leave a Reply





    • About Not Exactly Rocket Science



      Ed Yong is an award-winning British science writer. His work has appeared in New Scientist, the Times, WIRED, the Guardian, Nature and more. Not Exactly Rocket Science is his attempt to talk about the awe-inspiring, beautiful and quirky world of science to as many people as possible.

      My personal website with biography, other writing, speaking engagements, and more

      Some interviews with me
      Some awards that I’ve won
      Who my readers are: 2008, 2009 and 2010 editions
      A complete list of posts from this blog

      Follow me on Twitter or Google+

      Contact me on edyong209[at]googlemail[dot]com

    • Support science writers


      Every month, I choose ten excellent blog posts and donate £3 to their authors. If you want to join me in supporting great science writing, use the first button. Any donations in June will be split evenly between these ten writers.

      If you would like to support this blog in particular, use the second button. For anything you donate, I will match a third and donate it to the month's chosen writers.

    • What others say

      "One of the best sites for in-depth analysis of interesting scientific papers" - The Times

      "One of the smartest science bloggers I read... a prime practitioner among the new generation of scientifically authoritative bloggers" - David Rowan, editor of Wired UK

      "Engaging and jargon-free multimedia storytelling about science and the digital age" - National Academy of Sciences

      "A consistently illuminating home for long, thoughtful, and thorough explorations of science news" - National Association of Science Writers

      "Head and shoulders above many broadsheet hacks" - Ben Goldacre

      "Ed Yong... is made of pure unobtanium and rides TWO Toruks." - Frank Swain

      "Ed Yong is better than chocolate, fairy lights, and kittens chasing yarn. That is all." - Christine Ottery

    • Do you want to be a science writer?

      Read origin stories and advice from over 130 science writers from around the world.
    • Not Exactly Rocket Science content

      RSS Recent Posts

      Recent Posts

      • The two-genome waltz: how the threat of mismatched partners shapes complex life [Repost]
      • Hacking the genome with a MAGE and a CAGE [Repost]
      • The Peking Man, and other lost treasures that science wants back
      • Defeating dengue by releasing mosquitoes with virus-blocking bacteria [Repost]
      • Tiny water insect makes record-breaking song with his penis [Repost]
      • Forget butterflies – wasps and flies have hidden rainbows in their wings [Repost]
      • I’ve got your missing links right here (04 February 2012)
      • Random gene sets can predict breast cancer survival better than supposedly cancer-related ones
      Categories

      Categories

      Archives

      Archives

      • February 2012
      • January 2012
      • December 2011
      • November 2011
      • October 2011
      • September 2011
      • August 2011
      • July 2011
      • June 2011
      • May 2011
      • April 2011
      • March 2011
      • February 2011
      • January 2011
      • December 2010
      • November 2010
      • October 2010
      • September 2010
      • August 2010
      • July 2010
      • June 2010
      • May 2010
      • April 2010
      • March 2010
      • February 2010
      • January 2010
      • December 2009
      • November 2009
      • October 2009
      • September 2009
      • August 2009
      • July 2009
      • June 2009
      • May 2009
      • April 2009
      • March 2009
      • February 2009
      • January 2009
      • December 2008
      • November 2008
      • October 2008
      • September 2008
      • August 2008
      • July 2008
      • June 2008
      • May 2008
      • April 2008
      • March 2008
      • February 2008
    • RSS Twitter

    • My wife, who makes it all possible

      Alice.jpg
    • Blogroll

      Science blogs

      Science blogs

      • 80 Beats
      • A Blog Around the Clock
      • Adventures in Ethics and Science
      • Aetiology
      • Alice Bell
      • Ars Technica
      • Arthropoda
      • Atlantic Science
      • Babel's Dawn
      • Bad Astronomy
      • Bad Science
      • BPS Research Digest Blog
      • Cancer Research UK Science Update Blog
      • Child's Play
      • Cocktail Party Physics
      • Collision Detection
      • Culture Dish
      • Culturing Science
      • Deep Sea News
      • Discoblog + NCBI ROFL
      • Dot Earth
      • Dr Petra Boynton
      • Drugmonkey
      • EarthLab
      • Embargo Watch
      • Epiphenom
      • Evolving Thoughts
      • Finite Attention Span
      • Fistful of Science
      • Gary Schwitzer's HealthNewsReview
      • Gene Expression
      • Genetic Future
      • Genomeboy
      • Genomicron
      • Gimpy's Blog
      • Highly Allochthonous
      • Ionian Enchantment
      • JL Vernon Presents American Psico
      • Joanne Loves Science
      • John Pavlus
      • Just a Theory
      • Lab Rat
      • Laelaps
      • Last Word on Nothing
      • Lay Scientist
      • Loom
      • Mark Changizi
      • Mind Hacks
      • Myrmecos
      • Neuroanthropology
      • Neurologica
      • Neuron Culture
      • Neurophilosophy
      • Neurotic Physiology (SciCurious)
      • Neurotribes
      • Obesity Panacea
      • Observations of a Nerd
      • On Becoming a Domestic and Laboratory Goddess
      • Open Minds and Parachutes
      • Political Science (Evan Harris)
      • Predictably Irrational
      • Retraction Watch
      • Save Your Breath for Running Ponies
      • Schooner of Science
      • Science Punk
      • ScienceLine
      • ScienceLush
      • Sentence First
      • Sex, Drugs and Rockin' Venom – Confessions of an Extreme Scientist
      • Skepchick
      • Speakeasy Science
      • Superbug
      • Take as Directed
      • Terra Sigillata
      • Tetrapod Zoology
      • The Artful Amoeba
      • The Chicken or the Egg
      • The Examining Room of Dr Charles
      • The Flying Trilobite
      • The Frontal Cortex
      • The Gleaming Retort
      • The Great Beyond
      • The Intersection
      • The Inverse Square Blog
      • The Millikan Daily
      • The Primate Diaries
      • The Science Project
      • Thoughtomics
      • Thus Spake Zuska
      • TYWKIWDBI
      • Vagina Dentata
      • Voyages Around my Camera
      • Weird Bug Lady
      • White Coat Underground
      • Why Evolution is True
      • Wild Muse
      • Wired Science
      • Words of Science
      • XKCD
      • Zooillogix
      Other blogs

      Other blogs

      • Cafe Philos
      • Miss Cellania
    • NetworkedBlogs
      Blog:
      Not Exactly Rocket Science
      Topics:
      science, biology, news
       
      Follow my blog


  • Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Copyright © 2012, Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Privacy - Terms - Reader Services - Subscribe Today - Advertise - About Us