Butch tail made Carnotaurus a champion dinosaur sprinter

By Ed Yong | October 18, 2011 9:00 am

If you look at the skeleton of the flesh-eating dinosaur called Carnotaurus, two features instantly stand out: the skull and the arms. The fearsome skull is short, deep and topped by two devilish horns. Hence, its name: “meat-eating bull”. The arms are much less fearsome – they’re so short that they make Tyrannosaurus’s stunted fore-limbs looks like those of a wrestler. These body parts are distinctive, but Scott Persons and Phillip Currie from the University of Alberta think that the most interesting parts of Carnotaurus are its hips and tail.

By reconstructing the meat-eating bull’s hindquarters, Persons and Currie have found evidence that this dinosaur was much faster than anyone had thought. Powered by an enormous tail muscle, Carnotaurus was the Usain Bolt of the Cretaceous, well-adapted for short-burst sprinting.

Carnotaurus is the most famous member of the abelisaurids, a group of large predatory dinosaurs that hunted in the southern hemisphere, while the tyrannosaurs dominated the north. When Argentinean palaeontologist Jose Bonaparte discovered the animal in 1990, he suggested that it would have been a good runner. Others called this view into question when they discovered other closely related abelisaurids whose hind limbs hinted at a slower pace.

But leg bones don’t tell the whole story about a dinosaur’s running speed. You also have to look at its tail. The flesh-eating theropods, like Carnotaurus and Tyrannosaurus, had a pair of large muscles that ran along the sides of their tails. These muscles, known as the caudofemoralis, attached to the animals’ thigh bone. When they contracted, they pulled the leg backwards, powering a forceful running stroke.

Last year, Persons and Currie analysed the caudofemoralis of Tyrannosaurus to show that it probably ran faster than people had previously thought. But Carnotaurus was probably faster still. It could have been one of the fastest of all the large theropods, although Persons and Currie haven’t calculated a top speed yet.

The duo found that the dinosaur had a particularly butch caudofemoralis. Its tail bones each have a pair of unusual crescent-shaped flanges that protrude off to either side. Persons and Currie think that these flanges – also known as “caudal ribs” – served as anchor points for an unusually large caudofemoralis muscle. It was larger for the animal’s size than that of any other theropod, and would have accounted for 15 percent of its total body weight. When Carnotaurus contracted this mighty muscle, it would have pulled its hind leg backwards with extreme force, allowing for “sudden, straightforward sprints and charges”.

But Carnotaurus paid a price for its speed. Its caudal ribs may have anchored a powerful running muscle, but they also made its tail very rigid. When theropods ran, they turned in an almost snake-like way, leading with their heads and following with necks, torsos, hips and tails. But Carnotaurus’s tail was so rigid that its entire back half would have had to rotate as one. It could dash hell for leather in a straight line, but tight turns were out of the question. Its prey could probably have dodged and weaved around it.

Carnotaurus was one of the latest abelisaurids on the scene, and many of its contemporaries, like Skorpiovenator and Aucasaurus, also had caudal ribs. These species could probably have mustered the same bursts of speed. However, earlier members of the group had less distinctive tails, which suggests that these hunters gradually evolved to become sprinters.

When Carnotaurus was still alive, it shared South America with a far larger group of theropods – the carcharodontosaurids, or shark-toothed lizards. These included some of the largest theropods that ever lived, including Giganotosaurus and Tyrannotitan, large enough to hunt truly gargantuan prey like titanosaurs.

Persons and Currie think that Carnotaurus  and its ilk went the other way – evolving to chase smaller, nimbler prey with rapid bursts of speed. Perhaps they were the Cretaceous equivalents of cheetahs, sprinting after smaller prey while they left the bigger quarry to the more powerfully built lions. If an asteroid hadn’t finished off the dinosaurs, perhaps Carnotaurus would have eventually evolved go-faster stripes and a rear spoiler…

Reference: Persons, W., & Currie, P. (2011). Dinosaur Speed Demon: The Caudal Musculature of Carnotaurus sastrei and Implications for the Evolution of South American Abelisaurids PLoS ONE, 6 (10) DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0025763

Image: by Lida Xing and Yi Lu

More on theropods:


Comments (2)

  1. To illustrate diversity in abelisaurid leg proportions, see this skeletal reconstruction of Majungasaurus (here), and one of Aucasaurus (here).

    I need to highlight that contrary to what you wrote, Carnotaurus, which as you said was one of the last of the abelisaurids, probably didn’t share its environment with carcharodontosaurids. Earlier abelisaurids (E.g. African Kryptops and Rugops, South American Ekrixinatosaurus and Skorpiovenator) and carcharodontosaurids (African Eocarcharia and Carcharodontosaurus, South American Mapusaurus and Giganotosaurus) did live alongside one another, but the latter appear to have died out by the Cenomanian stage. Also, Carnotaurus lived close to the end of the Cretaceous, during the Maastrichtian stage; both Aucasaurus (Campanian stage) and Skorpiovenator (Turonian stage) were found in older deposits, and so weren’t its contemporaries.

    If abelisaurids evolved to be sprinters to take down smaller ornithopod prey and avoid competing with the carcharodontosaurids that evolved to hunt the giant titanosaurs, why is it that the one abelisaurid most adapted for speed is one of the last, living at a time when the giant carcharodontosaurids were already extinct? Shouldn’t the disappearance of the carcharodontosaurids have lessened the need for abelisaurids to specialise in this area?

    Instead, smaller carnosaurs known as neovenatorids might have replaced their giant relatives. And it was these (such as Aerosteon and Orkoraptor) that would have lived alongside the later abelisaurids like Carnotaurus and Aucasaurus. Since neovenatorids appear to have been closer in size to contemporary abelisaurids, perhaps there was greater likelihood of competition for prey, and selective pressure during this time may have been greater, leading to Carnotaurus becoming more specialised for speed than its earlier counterparts.

    It’s interesting to note that some abelisaurids in other parts of the world, like the Madagascan Majungasaurus and Indian Rajasaurus had short legs in comparison to their South American relatives. So far, fossils of carcharodontosaurids and neovenatorids have yet to be found in these regions. So maybe the absence of carnosaurs meant that the abelisaurids in these parts did not need to evolve into sprinters, since there wasn’t any competition in the form of other large predatory theropods.

    Also, the early abelisaurid Ekrixinatosaurus was a contemporary of the carcharodontosaurid Giganotosaurus, and according to Juárez Valieri, Porfiri & Calvo (2011), it was one of the largest abelisaurids, possibly measuring ~10 metres long (compare with the ~13-metre long Giganotosaurus). Even though it lived alongside a giant carcharodontosaurid, this abelisaurid appears to have had short and stocky legs like Majungasaurus. So Ekrixinatosaurus presents an interesting exception.

    (P.S. I’m sick of Rugops being depicted as a scavenger)

  2. Well, first, looks like my favorite dinosaur just got even cooler!

    Second, I was going to echo when Hai-Ren said about Carnotaurus living with carcharodontosaurs. I actually don’t think the beds where Carnotaurus is found are that well sampled (could be wrong) so it’s faunal contemporaries aren’t really well known.


Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Not Exactly Rocket Science

Dive into the awe-inspiring, beautiful and quirky world of science news with award-winning writer Ed Yong. No previous experience required.

See More

Collapse bottom bar