DISCOVER Magazine. Science, Technology and The Future
Current Issue
Subscribe Today »
  • Renew
  • Give a Gift
  • Archives
  • Customer Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Newsletter
  • Health & Medicine
  • Mind & Brain
  • Technology
  • Space
  • Human Origins
  • Living World
  • Environment
  • Physics & Math
  • Video
  • Photos
  • Podcast
  • RSS
Not Exactly Rocket Science
« How leaping lizards, dinosaurs and robots use their tails
Return of the supersoldier ants »

Fish mimics octopus that mimics fish

Many animals defend themselves by mimicking something distasteful, like a wasp or a venomous snake. But the mimic octopus can don a multitude of disguises. It becomes a sea-snake by pushing six arms down a hole and waving the other two around in a sinuous wriggle. It turns into a flatfish by folding its arms back into a leaf shape and undulating them up and down. Its repertoire of venomous animals potentially includes lionfish, sea anemones, jellyfish, and more. It is one of the most dynamic mimics in the animal kingdom.

And now, the mimic has been mimicked.

Last July, while diving in Indonesian waters, Godehard Kopp saw a black-marble jawfish hanging around a mimic octopus. The little fish perfectly matched the octopus in both colour and pattern, blending in among the brown and white stripes of its arms.

Kopp send his video to Rich Ross and Luiz Rocha of the California Academy of Sciences, who identified the fish. Jawfish spend most of their time in burrows. Out in the open, their poor swimming abilities leave them vulnerable to predators. The mimic octopus has no such problems. Its acts are so convincing that it is relatively safe from attack. By blending in with the octopus, the jawfish seems to have found a good way of moving about openly. Octopuses are predators in their own right, but this one certainly didn’t seem to mind its fishy companion.

This relationship is probably a rare occurrence. The black-marble jawfish is found throughout the Pacific from Japan to Australia, while the mimic octopus only hangs around Indonesia and Malaysia. For most of its range, the jawfish has no octopuses to hide against. Instead, Ross and Rocha think that this particular fish is engaging in “opportunistic mimicry”, taking advantage of a rare chance to share in an octopus’s protection.

Reference: Rocha, Ross & Kopp. 2011. Opportunistic mimicry by a Jawfish. Coral Reefs. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00338-011-0855-y

Images from the authors.

Hat-tip to Cameron Turner for alerting me to the story

More on mimicry:

  • The mimic octopus (my first ever post)
  • Cross-dressing raptors avoid violence
  • Orchid flowers fool flat-footed flies by faking fungus-infected foliage
  • The strumming assassin that hunts spiders on their own webs
  • Fake cleaner fish dons multiple disguises
  • Spider mimics ant to eat spiders and avoid being eaten by spiders
Share

January 5th, 2012 by Ed Yong in Animal behaviour, Animals, Cephalopods, Fish, Invertebrates, Mimicry | 4 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

4 Responses to “Fish mimics octopus that mimics fish”

  1. 1.   Neil Losin Says:
    January 5th, 2012 at 11:45 am

    Cool video and a fascinating bit of natural history. But unlike the authors, I don’t think my first inclination would be to call this relationship “mimicry.” The fish is difficult to detect against the brown-and-white mottled pattern of the octopus; it’s not fooling any predators into thinking it *is* an octopus. More like an excellent example of crypsis. But it’s certainly an interesting form of crypsis, wherein the visual background is another living, motile organism. (Are there any other examples like this? I don’t know.)

  2. 2.   Danny Byrd Says:
    January 5th, 2012 at 11:47 am

    It is clear that in December 2012 they will hit the mimic singularity.

  3. 3.   Ed Yong Says:
    January 5th, 2012 at 7:39 pm

    @Neil – That’s true! It’s one of those odd behaviours where our terminology suddenly seems a bit lacking.

    @Danny – I give you this: http://xkcd.com/928/

  4. 4.   Daniel J. Andrews Says:
    January 5th, 2012 at 7:42 pm

    Springerlink seems to be not working at the moment so can’t read the paper. My initial thoughts were the same as Neil’s. This seems to be more an example of crypsis rather than mimicry….but perhaps the authors have addressed this issue. I’ll try from work tomorrow.

    Certainly though, this is a fascinating example in its own right.

Leave a Reply





    • About Not Exactly Rocket Science



      Ed Yong is an award-winning British science writer. His work has appeared in New Scientist, the Times, WIRED, the Guardian, Nature and more. Not Exactly Rocket Science is his attempt to talk about the awe-inspiring, beautiful and quirky world of science to as many people as possible.

      My personal website with biography, other writing, speaking engagements, and more

      Some interviews with me
      Some awards that I’ve won
      Who my readers are: 2008, 2009 and 2010 editions
      A complete list of posts from this blog

      Follow me on Twitter or Google+

      Contact me on edyong209[at]googlemail[dot]com

    • Support

    • What others say

      "One of the best sites for in-depth analysis of interesting scientific papers" - The Times

      "One of the smartest science bloggers I read... a prime practitioner among the new generation of scientifically authoritative bloggers" - David Rowan, editor of Wired UK

      "Engaging and jargon-free multimedia storytelling about science and the digital age" - National Academy of Sciences

      "A consistently illuminating home for long, thoughtful, and thorough explorations of science news" - National Association of Science Writers

      "Head and shoulders above many broadsheet hacks" - Ben Goldacre

      "Ed Yong... is made of pure unobtanium and rides TWO Toruks." - Frank Swain

      "Ed Yong is better than chocolate, fairy lights, and kittens chasing yarn. That is all." - Christine Ottery

    • Do you want to be a science writer?

      Read origin stories and advice from over 130 science writers from around the world.
    • Not Exactly Rocket Science content

      RSS Recent Posts

      Recent Posts

      • Neurons transplanted into mouse spines reverse chronic pain
      • Virtual resurrection shows that early four-legged animal couldn’t walk very well
      • New sense organ helps giant whales to coordinate the world’s biggest mouthfuls
      • Here’s where all the magic happens
      • Blind mice regain sight after scientists persuade their optic nerves to grow
      • I’ve got your missing links right here (19 May 2012)
      • Meet the paralysed woman who commandeered a robotic arm
      • Deep-sea bacteria redefine life in the slow lane
      Categories

      Categories

      Archives

      Archives

      • May 2012
      • April 2012
      • March 2012
      • February 2012
      • January 2012
      • December 2011
      • November 2011
      • October 2011
      • September 2011
      • August 2011
      • July 2011
      • June 2011
      • May 2011
      • April 2011
      • March 2011
      • February 2011
      • January 2011
      • December 2010
      • November 2010
      • October 2010
      • September 2010
      • August 2010
      • July 2010
      • June 2010
      • May 2010
      • April 2010
      • March 2010
      • February 2010
      • January 2010
      • December 2009
      • November 2009
      • October 2009
      • September 2009
      • August 2009
      • July 2009
      • June 2009
      • May 2009
      • April 2009
      • March 2009
      • February 2009
      • January 2009
      • December 2008
      • November 2008
      • October 2008
      • September 2008
      • August 2008
      • July 2008
      • June 2008
      • May 2008
      • April 2008
      • March 2008
      • February 2008
    • RSS Twitter

    • My wife, who makes it all possible

      Alice.jpg
    • Blogroll

      Science blogs

      Science blogs

      • 80 Beats
      • A Blog Around the Clock
      • Adventures in Ethics and Science
      • Aetiology
      • Alice Bell
      • Ars Technica
      • Arthropoda
      • Atlantic Science
      • Babel's Dawn
      • Bad Astronomy
      • Bad Science
      • BPS Research Digest Blog
      • Cancer Research UK Science Update Blog
      • Child's Play
      • Cocktail Party Physics
      • Collision Detection
      • Culture Dish
      • Culturing Science
      • Deep Sea News
      • Discoblog + NCBI ROFL
      • Dot Earth
      • Dr Petra Boynton
      • Drugmonkey
      • EarthLab
      • Embargo Watch
      • Epiphenom
      • Evolving Thoughts
      • Finite Attention Span
      • Fistful of Science
      • Gary Schwitzer's HealthNewsReview
      • Gene Expression
      • Genetic Future
      • Genomeboy
      • Genomicron
      • Gimpy's Blog
      • Highly Allochthonous
      • Ionian Enchantment
      • JL Vernon Presents American Psico
      • Joanne Loves Science
      • John Pavlus
      • Just a Theory
      • Lab Rat
      • Laelaps
      • Last Word on Nothing
      • Lay Scientist
      • Loom
      • Mark Changizi
      • Mind Hacks
      • Myrmecos
      • Neuroanthropology
      • Neurologica
      • Neuron Culture
      • Neurophilosophy
      • Neurotic Physiology (SciCurious)
      • Neurotribes
      • Obesity Panacea
      • Observations of a Nerd
      • On Becoming a Domestic and Laboratory Goddess
      • Open Minds and Parachutes
      • Political Science (Evan Harris)
      • Predictably Irrational
      • Retraction Watch
      • Save Your Breath for Running Ponies
      • Schooner of Science
      • Science Punk
      • ScienceLine
      • ScienceLush
      • Sentence First
      • Sex, Drugs and Rockin' Venom – Confessions of an Extreme Scientist
      • Skepchick
      • Speakeasy Science
      • Superbug
      • Take as Directed
      • Terra Sigillata
      • Tetrapod Zoology
      • The Artful Amoeba
      • The Chicken or the Egg
      • The Examining Room of Dr Charles
      • The Flying Trilobite
      • The Frontal Cortex
      • The Gleaming Retort
      • The Great Beyond
      • The Intersection
      • The Inverse Square Blog
      • The Millikan Daily
      • The Primate Diaries
      • The Science Project
      • Thoughtomics
      • Thus Spake Zuska
      • TYWKIWDBI
      • Vagina Dentata
      • Voyages Around my Camera
      • Weird Bug Lady
      • White Coat Underground
      • Why Evolution is True
      • Wild Muse
      • Wired Science
      • Words of Science
      • XKCD
      • Zooillogix
      Other blogs

      Other blogs

      • Cafe Philos
      • Miss Cellania
    • NetworkedBlogs
      Blog:
      Not Exactly Rocket Science
      Topics:
      science, biology, news
       
      Follow my blog


  • Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Copyright © 2012, Kalmbach Publishing Co.

    Privacy - Terms - Reader Services - Subscribe Today - Advertise - About Us