Bacteria cities cannot form on a super-slippery surface, inspired by meat-eating plants

By Ed Yong | July 31, 2012 9:30 am


When bacteria start building cities, we’re in trouble. The normally free-floating cells can gather in large numbers and secrete a slimy matrix that they live within. These communities are called biofilms, and they grow wherever there is a surface to support them. Hospital catheters are prime real estate, but they’ll settle on everything from plumbing to oil refineries to ship hulls.

Within a biofilm, bacteria are extraordinarily durable. Antibacterial chemicals have a tough time reaching them within their slimy fortress. Even if they do, there’s always a batch of dormant cells that can persist through a chemical onslaught and restart the community. They’re involved in the majority of persistent hospital infections, and it’s easy to see why. You could bleach a biofilm for an hour and still fail to kill it. They’ve survived in pipes that are flushed with toxic chemicals for a week.

Since killing biofilms is a Sisyphean task, some scientists are trying to prevent them from forming at all. They’ve tried textured surfaces, chemical coats, and antibiotic-releasing layers. But Joanna Aizenberg has developed a new solution that goes well beyond what the competitors can do. Inspired by the flesh-eating pitcher plant, she created a material so slippery that biofilms simply cannot form upon it.

The material is called Slippery Liquid-Infused Porous Surfaces or, more aptly, SLIPS. It’s more slippery than any other man-made substance, and I wrote about it last year when Aizenberg first announced it:

It makes a duck’s back look like a sponge. It is “omniphobic” – it repels everything. All manner of liquids, from water to blood to crude oil, roll straight off it. Ice cannot form on it. It even heals itself when damaged.

The SLIPS consists of thousands of stacks, each a thousand times thinner than a human hair. These hold a liquid lubricant in place, and the liquid forms a smooth flat layer at the top of the stacks. That’s what makes the structure so slippery. The same set-up is found in the pitcher plant, on the rim of its pitcher-like leaves. When insects walk upon it, they lose their footing and fall into the pool of digestive fluids below. Inspired by this structure, forged over millions of years of evolution, Aizenberg created a synthetic version. Here’s how it performed:

Drops of water, blood and crude oil sit on the SLIPS as spheres. If the SLIPS are gently angled, the drops roll off, leaving nothing behind. Ice won’t form on the slips either – the second the crystals come together, they slide off. Nor can insects get a grip – an ant, climbing after a dollop of jam, slips off just as it would on the rim of a pitcher plant (with the jam quickly following).

SLIPS are around ten times as slippery as the next best synthetic [materials]. They are smoother, they work under high pressures, and they can be made transparent. They can also heal themselves. When Wong damaged the solid structure, the liquid part simply refills the affected area within less than a second. Best of all, they’re easy to make.

At the time, Aizenberg suggested a wide range of applications, from graffiti-proof walls to frictionless pipelines to ice-resistant windshields. She also suggested that medical devices would be hard to contaminate if they were covered in SLIPS, and her team have now proven that point.

Her student Alexander Epstein and postdoc Tak-Sing Wong showed that Pseudomonas aeruginosa, an opportunistic bacterium that causes many hospital-based infections, finds it hard to grow on SLIPS. Its cells just can’t get any purchase. Faced with a smooth liquid surface, they cannot anchor themselves with their usual toolbox of threads and proteins. They can’t swim through the liquid either. The bacteria have no problem forming biofilms on other slippery surfaces, such as Teflon. On SLIPS, they stay as free-floating, isolated cells. Just tilt the surfaces, and the bacteria slide away, leaving nothing behind.

Epstein and Wong also tested SLIPS in a flow chamber, which mimicked the constant pulse of liquid you’d get in a catheter or a plumbing pipe. Biofilms are known to grow under such conditions, and they happily did so upon a layer of PTFE – the same substance that the SLIPS stacks are made from. But once the PTFE was structured in microscopic stacks and covered in the lubricant, it reduced the growth of three bacteria species (P.aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, and Staphylococcus aureus) by 96 to 99.6 percent after a week.

That’s 35 times more than the next best option: a surface treated with polyethylene glycol (PEG). In one study, a titanium surface coated with PEG could reduce the growth of biofilms by 86 percent after 5 hours. Beyond that, the bacterial cities started rising. By contrast, the SLIPS kept bacteria almost totally at bay for a week. Aizenberg describes this result as “a step change beyond state-of-the-art technology”. No other synthetic surface can do the same, at least not without being incredibly toxic.

Best of all, the team once again demonstrated how stable the SLIPS can be. The solid and liquid parts are chosen so that the liquid doesn’t wash away or evaporate from the stacks over time. It tolerates aggressive flows of liquid. It can withstand a week of submersion in water that’s 10 times saltier than sea water, or in extreme acids or alkalis. It shrugs off as much ultraviolet radiation as you’d get after a full year under in the southwestern US sun.

Aizenberg describes her study as a “proof of concept”. She now wants to understand how exactly the SLIPS are preventing the biofilms from forming.  And, as I mentioned last year, the team are trying to tweak the materials so that they are even more durable than they currently are. Still, it’s hard not to get excited about the results as they stand. The SLIPS could provide an easy and effective way of preventing everything from medical devices to ship hulls from becoming urban centres for bacteria.

Reference: Epstein, Wong, Belisle, Boggs & Aizenberg. 2012. Liquid-infused structured surfaces with exceptional anti-biofouling performance. PNAS http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1201973109

Comments (13)

  1. Odin

    I wonder if geckos can gain a footing.

  2. Probably not. Gecko feet are sticky because they have microscopic hairs that fit into the nooks and crannies of a surface and basically form molecular bonds with them. If that surface is completely flat and smooth, the hairs have nowhere to go.

  3. I hope you’ll write something about the Panasonic photosynthesis announcement. All I can find are press releases, and I’m having a hard time understanding them.

  4. Old Geezer

    While making ship hulls less hospitable for bacteria is laudable, would it also make them move through the water more efficiently, perhaps conserving fuel?

  5. Stu

    I *so* want a Slip-’n'-Slide coated with this.

  6. DennyMo

    If it prevented barnacles and similar critters from clinging to the hull, yes it would help ship’s fuel efficiency. The trick will be figuring out how to install a SLIPS material that will stand up to the buffeting of tug boats and pier bumpers.

  7. @Old Geezer – Yes! Apparently so! From the paper:

    “Marine fouling, which initiates the accumulation of bacterial biofilm on ship hulls followed by the attachment of larger marine organisms, increases the fuel burn of seafaring vessels by up to 40%”

    Referenced to: Dalley AACaR (1987) Barnacle fouling and its prevention. Barnacle Biology, ed
    AJ Southward (A.A. Balkema, Rotterdam, NL), pp 419–433.

  8. Peter Beattie

    They’ve survived in pipes that are flushed with toxic chemicals for a week.

    Would they have survived the same exposure to boiling water? I mean, there is a limit to what proteins can take before denaturing, right? Or is that reversible for the main chunk of proteins that are important in that respect?

  9. Shanahanahan

    How exciting!
    Could urinary catheters be made of this?
    Would there be issues with maintaining position with general use?
    The possibilities are incredible!

  10. someone_else

    @Peter Beattie: Various kinds of bacteria do form spores, and in spore form they can withstand boiling water for indefinite amounts of time. This is the reason why stuff is sterilized by autoclave or UV.

    Of course you cannot autoclave everything, and UV fail to penetrate enough biofilm to kill them all.

  11. Corey

    Imagine how this could potentially be applied in the aerospace industry. Jetliners coated with a highly durable, long-lasting version of SLIPS would never have to be “de-iced”. Airplanes falling out of the skies due to icing might be relegated to history. One would think the massive reduction in friction might also enhance the speed of airplanes while simultaneously decreasing fuel consumption. And what about space probes and space vehicles that travel to places like the moon and Mars? Presumably, if those machines had SLIPS incorporated, they would not become coated or clogged with dust (think of the Spirit and Opportunity rovers currently on Mars) and their solar collectors (and other mechanical, moving parts like wheels, robotic arms, etc.) would always be in prime working condition. It will be very interesting to see how this concept of SLIPS evolves and is applied over time.

  12. Peter Williams

    Also for leading edges of aircraft wings. No need for energy-wasting de-icing strategies.

  13. Keith

    Is there anything known about the heat stability of SLIPS? The possibilities are so intriguing with this kind of material.

NEW ON DISCOVER
OPEN
CITIZEN SCIENCE
ADVERTISEMENT

Discover's Newsletter

Sign up to get the latest science news delivered weekly right to your inbox!

Not Exactly Rocket Science

Dive into the awe-inspiring, beautiful and quirky world of science news with award-winning writer Ed Yong. No previous experience required.
ADVERTISEMENT

See More

ADVERTISEMENT
Collapse bottom bar
+

Login to your Account

X
E-mail address:
Password:
Remember me
Forgot your password?
No problem. Click here to have it e-mailed to you.

Not Registered Yet?

Register now for FREE. Registration only takes a few minutes to complete. Register now »