Title IX Hits the Science World, But Will It Do Any Good?

submit to reddit

female scientistThe New York Times is reporting that the National Science Foundation, NASA, and the Department of Energy are invoking Title IX, the anti-discrimination law usually reserved for college athletics, to examine science programs at schools receiving federal money.

Specifically, the feds are sending investigators to take inventories of lab space and interview faculty and students in physics and engineering departments in order to determine whether there are signs of discrimination (an issue we’ve addressed before). The only problem with this tactic: Overt discrimination, the kind that leaves a clear and visible trail, is rarely what’s operating in science departments. Rather, subconscious biases (the power of which we’ve also discussed before) and subtle forces such as a lack of childcare options and flexible maternity leave are more likely to be contributing to the gap.

Not to mention that more often than not, what’s being interpreted as discrimination is occurring as self-selection. The Times cites research finding that, despite the fact that women make up only 10 percent of physics faculties, women with physics degrees have the same likelihood to go on to doctorates, teaching jobs, and tenure that men do. The separation happens earlier: Women are less likely to choose physics in high school or college.

Whether this choice is a result of nature or nurture remains the stuff of intense controversy. But for now at least, it’s not going to be solved by government investigations under Title IX.

Image: Flickr/DrKar

July 17th, 2008 Tags: , ,
by Melissa Lafsky in Science & Gender, Science Goes to Washington | 148 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

148 Responses to “Title IX Hits the Science World, But Will It Do Any Good?”

  1. 1.   Liz Says:

    I think it is important to note that the NY Times article is actually a column. It is basically an opinions piece and gives a mostly one-sided account from the author’s, John Tierney, viewpoint. This is should by no means be considered an unbias piece reportage considering its one-sidedness.

    Also, Title IX has always applied to ANY educational program or activity receiving federal funds, as the law states. This means science to. It is in no way reserved for athletics; it just seems this is where it have been most applied. It is also the law for these organizations receiving federal funds to conduct compliance reviews, which is exactly what the feds are doing. They are finally following the law, which they should have been doing the whole time.

  2. 2.   Zuska Says:

    This crap about self-selection drives me bananas. As if women are just making these choices about which careers to enter in a vacuum, and there are no constraints – no gender role expectations, no stereotyping, no biased treatment in classrooms, nothing in the media that saturates young kids’ lives, that might push young girls AWAY from careers in the sciences. In chemistry, there is definitely a problem in the step between PhD and assistant professor – women are not being recruited into the assistant professor level at the rate at which they are earning PhDs. Same in biology. Crappy reporting here, Discover. You’ve taken an opinion piece in the NYT, called it reporting, not bothered to look into the validity of what was said, and presented it like it’s truth.

    Not to mention what Liz above says about Title IX: It’s the law, it’s always been the law, and it’s always applied to educational settings as well as sports. Just because it’s been enforced in sports more than in educational settings doesn’t mean it doesn’t apply in the latter.

  3. 3.   Azakia Says:

    I agree with Zuska. The moment they place quotas into any academica programme the moment sexual discrimination will be reintroduced this time BECAUSE of title IX; not its absence. This is because Title IX doesn’t take into the equation the levels of interest of different groups. They should be reviewing the levels of interest at the start then checking the outcome of numbers on the otherside. Imagine restricting the amount of Asians in medicine because they don’t meet the quota of asians in the country – Now that’s discrimination.

  4. 4.   Anthony Says:

    Title IX is a joke! Our society assumes the underrepresentation of women in science is the result of sexism. Is it possible men and women make different career choices? If title IX is necessary to close the science gap, than why isn’t also used for men to gain parity in female dominated fields? Keep in mind, approximately 60% of all college students are female. Why isn’t the rapid decline of male teachers taken seriously? Title IX is another example of government female entitlement that claims equality at the expense of men.

  5. 5.   How to Get Six Pack Fast Says:

    The style of writing is very familiar . Did you write guest posts for other bloggers?

  6. 6.   Janardhanaya Says:

    VRy interesting to read it :P :D

  7. 7.   Gynecomastia products Says:

    GR8 Info, what are other good sites to confirm this info?

  8. 8.   Abapo Says:

    homeowners insurance [url="http://www.eliseogallery.com/Home-Insurance.html"]cheap home insurance[/url] http://www.eliseogallery.com/Home-Insurance.html %)))

  9. 9.   Viktoria Says:

    life quotes [url="http://www.eliseogallery.com/Life-Insurance.html"]life quotes[/url] http://www.eliseogallery.com/Life-Insurance.html 8-PPP

  10. 10.   Treker Says:

    life quotes [url="http://www.eliseogallery.com/Life-Insurance.html"]life quotes[/url] http://www.eliseogallery.com/Life-Insurance.html 625

  11. 11.   Abarca Says:

    homeowners insurance [url="http://www.eliseogallery.com/Home-Insurance.html"]cheap home insurance[/url] http://www.eliseogallery.com/Home-Insurance.html :) ))

  12. 12.   Parejo Says:

    [url="http://www.arkhamgames.com/viagra.html"]generic viagra[/url] generic viagra http://www.arkhamgames.com/viagra.html 8-P

  13. 13.   aderegroono Says:

    Other variant is possible also

  14. 14.   ctjbfwfcj Says:

    3gCeKR bxejbupsqqws, [url=http://wftvfpcapqee.com/]wftvfpcapqee[/url], [link=http://ppmvhxsfvidb.com/]ppmvhxsfvidb[/link], http://rikbiqeijwyx.com/

  15. 15.   howea Says:
  16. 16.   aviv Says:
  17. 17.   practice craps online online Says:
  18. 18.   cool cat online casino secrets Says:
  19. 19.   high roller online casino online Says:
  20. 20.   lindsay lohan sex tape Says:
  21. 21.   megan fox fhm Says:

    online bachelors degree education, megan fox gallery, clqob, miley cyrus nude, =-D, jessica biel sex scene, =-]]], megan fox wallpaper, >:OO, adrienne bailon nude pics, bhxxoi,

  22. 22.   ashley tisdale naked Says:
  23. 23.   jessica biel pictures Says:
  24. 24.   holly madison photos Says:
  25. 25.   lindsay lohan breasts Says:

    career technical education, jessica biel pictures, 1332, megan fox gallery, =-PP, ashley tisdale sex, 38366, emma watson sex, 709079, jessica biel pictures, qvqvzo, ashley tisdale sex, bdpcqt,

  26. 26.   online casino bonus guide online Says:
  27. 27.   lindsay lohan breasts Says:
  28. 28.   online casino cheat software secrets Says:
  29. 29.   online casino free bonus deposit Says:
  30. 30.   pictures of miley cyrus Says:

    definition of physical education, megan fox gallery, pevbg, jessica biel sex scene, :O, megan fox wallpaper, pfqhb, megan fox nude, ivgh, pictures of miley cyrus, >:-]], jessica alba butt, 671605, jessica alba butt, rkcmdi, jessica alba exposed, pevwkv, lindsay lohan sex, 09985,

  31. 31.   angelina jolie in bikini Says:
  32. 32.   online casino mastercard tips Says:
  33. 33.   online casino roulette bonus bonus Says:
  34. 34.   pictures of miley cyrus Says:
  35. 35.   carmen electra gallery Says:

    secondary education, miley cyrus naked, =-O, lindsay lohan breasts, =-)), emma watson sex, 11381, miley cyrus naked, %[[, ashley tisdale sex, 38330, megan fox wallpaper, xktrpz,

  36. 36.   megan fox fhm Says:

    regional offices of education, ashley tisdale sex, myqo, megan fox wallpaper, =-OO, paris hilton video, 088856, miley cyrus nude pics, 20591, kelis sextape, 8653,

  37. 37.   carmen electra gallery Says:
  38. 38.   kelis sextape Says:
  39. 39.   megan fox gallery Says:
  40. 40.   jessica biel pictures Says:
  41. 41.   paris hilton video Says:
  42. 42.   adrienne bailon nude pics Says:
  43. 43.   megan fox nude Says:

    beliefs about the purpose of education, megan fox nude pics, :], miley cyrus naked, =-), miley cyrus nude, ulzot, jessica biel sex scene, ltxh, lindsay lohan sex tape, 2198, adrienne bailon nude pics, 2925, lindsay lohan hot, =)), lucy pinder boobs, =)), lucy pinder, >:-))), emma watson sex, >:O, megan fox wallpaper, blukz, megan fox fhm, 5869, carmen electra gallery, jhbtjh, emma watson sex, gbab, paris hilton sex, isgcbm, jessica biel sex scene, rum, anne hathaway sex scene, 687693, jessica alba butt, nwjiwd, jessica biel sex scene, :]]], megan fox fhm, :O, lindsay lohan breasts, :OOO, miley cyrus pics, 54723, jessica alba exposed, dyoi, megan fox wallpaper, :O, megan fox fhm, %-DD, lindsay lohan sex tape, gjzh, megan fox nude, 96398, holly madison pictorial, hgoer, kim kardashian playboy, vvlg,

  44. 44.   recommended online casino secrets Says:
  45. 45.   vegas country online casino deposit Says:
  46. 46.   holly madison pictorial Says:

    history of early childhood education, emma watson sex, 5642, miley cyrus nude, 8-O, holly madison pictorial, oahbvg, holly madison pictorial, psz, paris hilton video, adn,

  47. 47.   miley cyrus nude pics Says:
  48. 48.   ashley tisdale sex Says:
  49. 49.   emma watson sex Says:
  50. 50.   holly madison photos Says:
  51. 51.   jessica biel pictures Says:
  52. 52.   megan fox wallpaper Says:
  53. 53.   miley cyrus nude pics Says:
  54. 54.   wyoming Says:
  55. 55.   megan fox nude pics Says:
  56. 56.   free kim kardashian sex tape Says:
  57. 57.   chesmu Says:
  58. 58.   noapeh Says:
  59. 59.   jenna jameson anal Says:
  60. 60.   kim kardashian naked Says:
  61. 61.   britney spears ass Says:

    beliefs about the purpose of education, megan fox pics, veeyc, lucy pinder, %O, paris hilton in bed, uns, miley cyrus pics, %-))), paris hilton video, sxgek, lindsay lohan breasts, 420284,

  62. 62.   megan fox wallpaper Says:
  63. 63.   holly madison photos Says:
  64. 64.   ashley tisdale sex Says:
  65. 65.   megan fox wallpaper Says:

    ‘native education centre’, kim kardashian naked, >:PP, tila tequila nude, gmfcpr, megan fox pics, soeo, lucy pinder video, 636, kelis sextape, eniw, miley cyrus nude, 895, lindsay lohan sex tape, =DD, megan fox nude pics, lzsy, megan fox pics, %-D,

  66. 66.   lindsay lohan breasts Says:
  67. 67.   alyssa milano vampire Says:
  68. 68.   jessica alba bikini Says:
  69. 69.   megan fox nude pics Says:
  70. 70.   wakanda Says:
  71. 71.   aiattaua Says:
  72. 72.   aim Says:
  73. 73.   ashley tisdale sex Says:

    higher education statistics, kim kardashian naked, vlfdjr, tila tequila nude, :-) ), megan fox wallpaper, 867573, anne hathaway, >:P, ashley tisdale sex, 1967,

  74. 74.   lucy pinder Says:

    importance of higher education, free kim kardashian sex tape, 974, holly madison pictorial, gmkr, anne hathaway, 0257, brooke burke wallpaper, 02882, jessica biel pictures, bfsvk,

  75. 75.   ankti Says:
  76. 76.   chayton Says:
  77. 77.   tenskwatawa Says:
  78. 78.   anders Says:
  79. 79.   anatole Says:
  80. 80.   jessica biel pictures Says:
  81. 81.   free kim kardashian sex tape Says:

    pharmacy technician free continuing education, carmen electra gallery, 142600, jessica biel sex scene, >:-OO, holly madison pictorial, >:-[[[, miley cyrus nude pics, 028583, jessica biel pictures, gwlo, holly madison photos, 38344,

  82. 82.   alyssa milano barefoot Says:

    what is physical education, nude megan fox, 916, nude megan fox, rhgdo, megan fox pictures, 604538, megan fox fhm, :-OO, megan fox pictures, qkocqj, jenna jameson lesbian, :[[, is jessica biel a lesbian, zhju,

  83. 83.   lindsay lohan breasts Says:
  84. 84.   lucy pinder Says:

    history of early childhood education, kim kardashian ray j, 585, megan fox wallpaper, tfwf, holly madison photos, >:[[[, megan fox gallery, nao, jessica alba butt, =-], holly madison photos, =-((,

  85. 85.   jessica biel pictures Says:

    jimi hendrix childhood and education, jennifer love hewitt in her bra, 6800, megan fox fhm, 8DDD, free kim kardashian sex tape, dhyylf, miley cyrus naked, :], holly madison pictorial, wfdes, miley cyrus pics, 8-(, lucy pinder, kopp,

  86. 86.   katy perry sexy Says:

    wood education training, megan fox fhm, wtrb, megan fox gallery, lwo, paris hilton sex, btayr, megan fox wallpaper, %], kim kardashian nude pics, 501,

  87. 87.   megan fox gallery Says:

    south carolina education lottery, jessica biel pictures, %-D, kim kardashian nude pics, =[[[, megan fox gallery, >:OOO, carmen electra gallery, 69759, holly madison photos, 166016, katy perry sexy, fty,

  88. 88.   megan fox gallery Says:
  89. 89.   kim kardashian naked Says:
  90. 90.   miley cyrus nude pics Says:
  91. 91.   emma watson sex Says:
  92. 92.   carmen electra gallery Says:
  93. 93.   shay buckeye johnson Says:
  94. 94.   holly madison photos Says:
  95. 95.   kim kardashian nude pics Says:
  96. 96.   jenna jameson anal Says:

    meaning of physical education, megan fox fhm, 226249, jessica biel sex scene, 61617, kim kardashian naked, dtmvk, jenna jameson sex, 774662, brooke burke wallpaper, hsycz, jennifer love hewitt gallery, 8-[,

  97. 97.   jessica biel sex scene Says:

    louisiana department of education, kim kardashian nude pics, mctrjf, jessica biel sex scene, :[[, lindsay lohan sex tape, =]], emma watson sex, hculej, lindsay lohan breasts, 8-[[[, megan fox fhm, gplyl, britney spears vagina, qjhavs,

  98. 98.   megan fox nude Says:
  99. 99.   kim kardashian nude pics Says:
  100. 100.   megan fox wallpaper Says:

    insurance continuing education, kim kardashian nude pics, 264, kim kardashian ray j, >:P, pictures of miley cyrus, %-[[, megan fox fhm, cymq, kelis sextape, 376657, halle berry nude, xfmsg, megan fox fhm, dufae, jessica alba exposed, 136352,

  101. 101.   megan fox nude Says:
  102. 102.   paris hilton video Says:
  103. 103.   online casino poker games Says:
  104. 104.   we are rock slot machine Says:
  105. 105.   casino game video slot Says:
  106. 106.   internet casino slots Says:
  107. 107.   online casino rigged Says:
  108. 108.   online casino australian dollars Says:
  109. 109.   online casino cheats Says:
  110. 110.   video slot machine online deposit Says:
  111. 111.   rental casino games Says:
  112. 112.   video slot machines free deposit Says:
  113. 113.   cool cat online casino Says:
  114. 114.   online casino apple Says:
  115. 115.   atlantic city casino games Says:
  116. 116.   online casino western union Says:
  117. 117.   inet casino Says:
  118. 118.   instant online casino bonus Says:
  119. 119.   online casino three card poker Says:
  120. 120.   ewalletxpress online casino Says:
  121. 121.   online casino jackpots Says:
  122. 122.   most trusted online casino bonus Says:
  123. 123.   online casino reviews Says:
  124. 124.   online casino secrets free Says:
  125. 125.   online casino roulette Says:
  126. 126.   starting a online casino Says:
  127. 127.   online casino payment methods Says:
  128. 128.   yachting casino games Says:
  129. 129.   online casino linux Says:
  130. 130.   silver oak online casino Says:
  131. 131.   progressive casino games Says:
  132. 132.   aladdin's palace online casino Says:
  133. 133.   millionaire online casino Says:
  134. 134.   online casino free Says:
  135. 135.   yahoo casino games Says:
  136. 136.   slot machine logic Says:

    comment1, online casino groups, purchase Nuance PaperPort Professional 11.1 , slot machine error code, roulette online for real money deposit, casino machine machine online online slot slot yourbestonlinecasino.com, online casino software providers, slot machine tips and tricks, slot machine seller, club player online casino deposit, video slot machines online, Colin Farrell sex tape online, play craps online for money best, cool cat online casino online, Leighton Meester sex tape, order Autodesk NavisWorks Manage 2009 , purchase Autodesk NavisWorks Manage 2009 , make money playing roulette online bonus, video slot machine online usa , buy Fireworks CS4 , python slot machine, video slot machine free online, buy Acronis True Image 11 Home , parts of a slot machine, slot machine shareware, loosest slot machine in las vegas, video slot machine simulator online, roulette online real money online, video slot machine emulator online, live casino games, online casino deutschland, casino game video slot, slot machine training, slot machine vote, uk online casino,

  137. 137.   online casino legal in usa Says:

    comment3, video slot machines free, russian roulette online usa , buy Corel Video Studio Pro X2 , online casino news, milk money slot machine, silver sands online casino, cheap Fireworks CS4 , order Nero 9 , online casino help, casino machine online slot, purchase Roxio Creator 2009 Ultimate , pelican slot machine, play craps online flash deposit, cleopatra casino game, golden casino games, house advantage on casino games, practice craps online deposit, buy Money 2007 Deluxe , slot machine advice, online casino blacklist, Corel Painter X MAC , purchase Office Visio Professional 2007 , online casino bodog, enchanted forest slot machine, bonus free game online slot, Namrata Shrestha sex tape, card counting online casino bonus, most reliable online casino, casino free machine online slot, download Office Enterprise 2007 , video slot machine simulator best, slot machine mills,

  138. 138.   casino casino machine online online slot yourbestonlinecasino.com Says:

    comment5, order E-gadgets Delete Duplicate Files , slot machine games, slot machine coin bank, online casino roulette scam, roulette online no download usa , online casino 1 hour free play, order Windows Vista Ultimate SP2 64, play real roulette online, site freeslots.com free slot machine games, star trek slot machine las vegas, casino casino machine online online slot yourbestonlinecasino.com, rapid roulette online deposit, purchase FrontPage 2003 , slot machine websites, pinball slot machine, Propellerhead Reason 4 , vegas strip online casino, casino casino machine machine online online slot slot yourbestonlinecasino.com, personalized slot machine, internet casino gambling, lucky club online casino, las vegas slot machine odds, bingo free game online slot, rushmore online casino reviews, reel millions slot machine, online casino australian dollars, super mario slot machine,

  139. 139.   online casino 10 minimum deposit Says:
  140. 140.   dude vu. dudevu down Says:
  141. 141.   shay biggest loser. daniel biggest loser Says:

    comment6, sammy sosa s wife. sammy sosa, citiz nespresso. harris bank online, carrie prejean video. carrie prejean playboy, veteran s day for kids. veteran s day, curtis vance trial. car wrap advertising, whatever you like anya marina. anya marina whatever you like mediafire, john allen muhammad execution. john allen muhammad, carrie prejean nipple. carrie prejean, brothers trailer. tobey maguire, dc sniper execution. dc sniper execution, toni braxton trey songz. toni braxton kiss, fort hood victims. fort hood memorial, stissing mountain high school. pine plains high school, brothers movie 2009. brothers, dudevu down. sites like dudevu, jimmy the greek wiki. jimmy the greek wiki, orkanen ida. hurricane ida projected path, modern warfare 2 at sainsburys. modern warfare 2 walmart, blackout in brazil. ebay, new mexico soccer. temryss lane,

  142. 142.   nickel silver cutlery Says:
  143. 143.   purchase online Nero 8 Ultra Edition Says:
  144. 144.   porn women arabis watch Says:
  145. 145.   menomonee bingo and casino keshena wi Says:
  146. 146.   bingo erie fort golden nugget Says:
  147. 147.   charity bingo in jasper alabama Says:
  148. 148.   new casinos in imichigan Says:

Leave a Reply