Historians Foretell Our Demise as a Scientific Superpower

submit to reddit

Given the grim economic climate and even grimmer forecasts for the future, it’s not hard to predict that the U.S. will lose its status as the world’s preeminent superpower. But will we fall behind in science as well? J. Rogers Hollingsworth, a history professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, thinks so. He and a group of historians and sociologists think that the country’s diminishing lead over other nations in science investment and research output mirrors the downfall of preceding science juggernauts like France, Germany and Britain. History, they say, is primed to repeat itself.

In an essay in this week’s issue of Nature, (subscription required) Hollingsworth and his co-authors argue that recent huge investments by the EU, China, Japan, Russia and India have leveled the international playing field in the sciences, leaving the U.S. teetering on the brink of losing the status it’s held since the second World War. China in particular has moved from 15th in the world rankings in science and engineering production to second place, just in the last twelve years.

Hollingsworth isn’t wrong; other countries are handing out more doctorates, publishing more papers, and funding more research than ever before, while we’re floundering under budget constraints (and political agendas). So should we pack up the labs at M.I.T. and CalTech and send everyone to Beijing? Not so fast, he argues, citing the fact that the U.S. is still major player, with American researchers accounting for more than half of the top 1 percent of the world’s most-cited papers.

Interestingly, he points out that the “publish or perish” attitude of major research universities may actually be squashing innovation—U.S. scientists are pumping out papers, but without a corresponding increase in “major breakthroughs.” The solution, he says, is for U.S. scientists and universities to “become more flexible and more adaptive”—advice that might do us all some good.

July 24th, 2008 by Melissa Lafsky in Science Goes to Washington | 74 comments | RSS feed | Trackback >

74 Responses to “Historians Foretell Our Demise as a Scientific Superpower”

  1. 1.   squashing Says:

    [...] attitude of major research universities may actually be squashing innovation??US scientists are …http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/realitybase/2008/07/24/historians-foretell-our-demise-as-a-scienti…Car smashes through restaurant squashing man against counterVideo from a camera mounted inside a [...]

  2. 2.   Judy Says:

    Well its time America woke up to the fact that America is & always has been ROMES (via the british Royal family, who is America’s owner) laboratory where they send people from all over the world to create what they have required to build toward their NEW WORLD ORDER. They expect this to be up & running & pretty much settled by 2012.
    The public wasnt included or allowed to know their plans because they know we wont be happy with the end product. Now they are covering their tracks by eliminating where they’ve been. (Even in the Universities.)
    Fortunately there are some big shocks coming up for them.
    They have been permitted to climb very high on there pedestal so their fall will be harsh enough to ensure they wake up. No more blaming others or hiding behind their power & money.

  3. 3.   Amy Says:

    Well, I seriously doubt we can keep being a science superpower if our children are taught that some person in the sky made everything. While the generation that got out of school before the religious people ruined it will be enough to keep Americans going for awhile, the kids that grew up thinking that a designer put everything here in six days (a population that, unfortunately, is growing constantly) are not going to be much of an asset to American science.

  4. 4.   Forrest Says:

    Amazing stuff, nice post Manchester United Blog – http://theredevilspot.blogspot.com

  5. 5.   Spain Says:

    Fantastic post, very much useful information. I found your blog a few days ago on Google and have been reading it over the past few days. I am goint to subscribe your blog. Btw, here is where you can download nhac mp3 for free

  6. 6.   Moulton Says:

    cool pics

  7. 7.   Stepanian Says:

    cool pics

  8. 8.   Lovorn Says:

    Thanks for the information an excellent post.

  9. 9.   Behme Says:
  10. 10.   Guitar_lesson Says:

    Great Post.

  11. 11.   Paff Says:

    Great post! I’m searching for this information for long time and i have found it here. I’m a lucky man and honestly It’ really important to me. Thanks for kindly sharing it with us.

    Very well done indeed.

  12. 12.   Apel Says:

    Great post! I’m searching for this information for long time and i have found it here. I’m a lucky man and honestly It’ really important to me. Thanks for kindly sharing it with us.

    Very well done indeed.

  13. 13.   Brede Says:
  14. 14.   Pridmore Says:

    cool pics

  15. 15.   Castanada Says:

    cool pics

  16. 16.   Moulds Says:

    Showing some love to this topic “new to this wordpress”. I defiantly agree with it also. If you really think about it than it all makes alot of sense

  17. 17.   Archibold Says:

    Showing some love to this topic “new to this wordpress”. I defiantly agree with it also. If you really think about it than it all makes alot of sense

  18. 18.   Laber Says:

    Nice post and I really like your blog. Would you like me to post a guest post? You can see how I write on my blog. My Blog

  19. 19.   Rigdon Says:

    Thanks for this great information. Most of all i agree with you. Keep the good posts and I’m waiting for another useful posts.
    Also i’m very glad to subscribe to this blog. :) TWR Power System

  20. 20.   Kochis Says:

    Showing some love to this topic “new to this wordpress”. I defiantly agree with it also. If you really think about it than it all makes alot of sense

  21. 21.   Wolski Says:

    Showing some love to this topic “new to this wordpress”. I defiantly agree with it also. If you really think about it than it all makes alot of sense

  22. 22.   Litchfield Says:

    cool pics

  23. 23.   Boyton Says:

    Need Medical advice? Have an Medical question?
    Check out the new medical advice forum http://www.justaskmedical.com/fg Over 500 active users and over 10,000 medical advice threads started. Join the community now 100% Free. Medical Question?

  24. 24.   Mcferrin Says:

    Need Medical advice? Have an Medical question?
    Check out the new medical advice forum http://www.justaskmedical.com/fg Over 500 active users and over 10,000 medical advice threads started. Join the community now 100% Free. Medical advice Forum

  25. 25.   Zenon Says:

    Need Medical advice? Have an Medical question?
    Check out the new medical advice forum http://www.justaskmedical.com/fg Over 500 active users and over 10,000 medical advice threads started. Join the community now 100% Free. Medical Advice

  26. 26.   Bay Says:
  27. 27.   Paya Says:

    Check out this new dating site its 100% free, a few stars have actually met people on there themselves. Read all about this totally free dating site called mate1 at http://www.datingmate1.com and find true love TODAY True Love

  28. 28.   Baynham Says:

    Future City Plus is the leader In designer eye wear and brand name Beauty products. All the products we sell are 100% authentic ! Check us out at http://futurecityplus.com/ our prices are at wholesale prices! So shop now. Future City Plus

  29. 29.   Placek Says:

    Future City Plus is the leader In designer eye wear and brand name Beauty products. All the products we sell are 100% authentic ! Check us out at http://futurecityplus.com/ our prices are at wholesale prices! So shop now. Future City Plus

  30. 30.   Stocking Says:

    cool pics

  31. 31.   Scheve Says:

    Hello ,
    Thank you very much this beatiful information.

    Best regards,

    -plc-

  32. 32.   Stoeber Says:

    Cool, will have to think about that for a bit..

  33. 33.   game Says:
  34. 34.   jonn1 Says:
  35. 35.   shay johnson nude Says:
  36. 36.   miley cyrus pics Says:
  37. 37.   miley cyrus nude pics Says:
  38. 38.   lucy pinder Says:
  39. 39.   megan fox nude pics Says:
  40. 40.   miley cyrus pics Says:

    why is education valuable, lindsay lohan hot, cggx, miley cyrus pics, 2456, miley cyrus nude pics, lvpm, ashley tisdale sex, fxxf, megan fox fhm, 754952, kim kardashian nude pics, %-DD, all halle berry dresses, 708463,

  41. 41.   nude jessica biel Says:

    nancy pelosi education, pictures of miley cyrus, %-(, megan fox pics, =PP, kim kardashian nude pics, jkeqd, kim kardashian nude pics, >:-OOO, megan fox pics, tqgudx,

  42. 42.   jessica alba butt Says:

    continuing medical education, megan fox nude pics, 65398, britney spears pussy, lyr, britney spears ass, 9954, jessica alba, 8-O, emma watson sex, %-DDD, lindsay lohan sex, yqkm,

  43. 43.   paris hilton video Says:
  44. 44.   jennifer love hewitt fake Says:
  45. 45.   jessica biel sex scene Says:

    aims and objectives of physical education, lindsay lohan hot, >:], nude megan fox, 206162, kelis sextape, %P, kim kardashian nude pics, evrvlb, miley cyrus nude pics, zlalhh, megan fox gallery, zdzy, jessica alba exposed, udy, nude jessica biel, eyd, megan fox fhm, 8561,

  46. 46.   lindsay lohan breasts Says:

    oklahoma state department of education, lindsay lohan hot, gbnwn, alyssa milano vampire, 30639, carmen electra gallery, 410, paris hilton video, =-]], jessica alba butt, 8]]], miley cyrus nude, hep, holly madison photos, gbuc,

  47. 47.   anne hathaway Says:
  48. 48.   jessica biel pictures Says:

    florida department of education, lucy pinder, :-[[, megan fox fhm, 569949, nude megan fox, 79513, jessica alba exposed, mtpaeu, alyssa milano kissing vampire, twymfe, lucy pinder video, nbtopf, holly madison pictorial, 731, megan fox fhm, =-[[[,

  49. 49.   megan fox fhm Says:

    definition of physical education, lucy pinder, copxl, jessica biel sex scene, 799, megan fox pics, 7389, lucy pinder video, yozeai, halle berry nude, 955, megan fox nude pics, gelxbz, adrienne bailon nude pics, nzo, lindsay lohan sex tape, 2073,

  50. 50.   megan fox gallery Says:

    free nursing continuing education, holly madison hot, 183405, kim kardashian ray j, 115912, megan fox fhm, 128599, kim kardashian nude pics, =-OO, megan fox pics, wyqw,

  51. 51.   jessica biel pictures Says:

    arizona department of education, carmen electra gallery, 8-)), katy perry sexy, 919, lucy pinder, =PP, megan fox gallery, 27070, megan fox nude, 7177, kim kardashian naked, 378, nude megan fox, 20894,

  52. 52.   free kim kardashian sex tape Says:

    what is physical education, lucy pinder, kgz, adrienne bailon nude pics, evf, kim kardashian nude pics, %OO, ashley tisdale sex, =-PPP, katy perry sexy, wzswon,

  53. 53.   megan fox pictures Says:

    why do we need physical education, carmen electra gallery, =-(((, paris hilton video, 30906, megan fox gallery, jee, miley cyrus pics, =)), katy perry sexy, 8549, jessica biel pictures, 19566,

  54. 54.   free kim kardashian sex tape Says:

    ruth handler’s education, paris hilton video, 026, emma watson sex, =-DD, megan fox wallpaper, pud, megan fox fhm, :-( ((, lindsay lohan hot, oegu,

  55. 55.   paris hilton sex Says:

    benefit of college education, halle berry wallpaper, 99479, megan fox nude, 0091, lindsay lohan hot, 5837, lucy pinder, doxad, lucy pinder video, bkk, jessica alba exposed, 184188, jessica alba exposed, cogf,

  56. 56.   alyssa milano topless Says:

    psychology of education, lindsay lohan hot, prooqs, kelis sextape, 8-]]], megan fox gallery, 8-[[[, megan fox wallpaper, 4740, megan fox gallery, :[[,

  57. 57.   miley cyrus nude pics Says:

    special education journals, britney spears nude pics, 386603, kim kardashian ray j, dzoi, megan fox gallery, itb, paris hilton sex, 6555, kelis sextape, 2531, megan fox pics, 631354, miley cyrus pics, 540375, megan fox fhm, 8))),

  58. 58.   carmen electra gallery Says:
  59. 59.   jennifer love hewitt gallery Says:
  60. 60.   megan fox fhm Says:

    higher education, paris hilton video, 800, lindsay lohan hot, jqs, megan fox pictures, udqw, kelis sextape, 8[[, ashley tisdale sex, 87729,

  61. 61.   miley cyrus pics Says:
  62. 62.   free kim kardashian sex tape Says:
  63. 63.   ashley tisdale sex Says:
  64. 64.   alyssa milano vampire Says:
  65. 65.   angelina jolie sex scene Says:
  66. 66.   megan fox gallery Says:
  67. 67.   holly madison pictorial Says:
  68. 68.   lucy pinder Says:
  69. 69.   megan fox pictures Says:
  70. 70.   miley cyrus naked Says:

    printable high school education worksheets, kelis sextape, 50873, megan fox wallpaper, :P PP, pictures of miley cyrus, 726, paris hilton sex, 8-DDD, lindsay lohan sex, =PPP, kim kardashian nude pics, %-OOO, lucy pinder, :-], ashley tisdale sex, 29170, britney spears vagina, bkvpy,

  71. 71.   megan fox gallery Says:

    dental continuing education courses, lindsay lohan sex tape, 8D, paris hilton video, 096926, megan fox wallpaper, 003262, jessica alba nude, 8-PP, holly madison photos, afi,

  72. 72.   miley cyrus nude Says:

    stevie wonder education, nude megan fox, >:OOO, megan fox fhm, 366756, britney spears blow job, soi, lucy pinder, 8-(((, kim kardashian ray j, 8-DD,

  73. 73.   miley cyrus pics Says:

    importance of higher education, paris hilton sex, 994, kim kardashian naked, 8-], lucy pinder, 322, megan fox wallpaper, lke, miley cyrus pics, npt, kim kardashian ray j, phcp, jessica biel pictures, 64892,

  74. 74.   megan fox pictures Says:

    archaeologist education requirements, kim kardashian naked, ovzdx, nude anne hathaway, fwqnq, pictures of miley cyrus, ajurzh, holly madison pictorial, >:], paris hilton video, =-(((,

Leave a Reply