Given the grim economic climate and even grimmer forecasts for the future, it’s not hard to predict that the U.S. will lose its status as the world’s preeminent superpower. But will we fall behind in science as well? J. Rogers Hollingsworth, a history professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, thinks so. He and a group of historians and sociologists think that the country’s diminishing lead over other nations in science investment and research output mirrors the downfall of preceding science juggernauts like France, Germany and Britain. History, they say, is primed to repeat itself.
In an essay in this week’s issue of Nature, (subscription required) Hollingsworth and his co-authors argue that recent huge investments by the EU, China, Japan, Russia and India have leveled the international playing field in the sciences, leaving the U.S. teetering on the brink of losing the status it’s held since the second World War. China in particular has moved from 15th in the world rankings in science and engineering production to second place, just in the last twelve years.
Hollingsworth isn’t wrong; other countries are handing out more doctorates, publishing more papers, and funding more research than ever before, while we’re floundering under budget constraints (and political agendas). So should we pack up the labs at M.I.T. and CalTech and send everyone to Beijing? Not so fast, he argues, citing the fact that the U.S. is still major player, with American researchers accounting for more than half of the top 1 percent of the world’s most-cited papers.
Interestingly, he points out that the “publish or perish” attitude of major research universities may actually be squashing innovation—U.S. scientists are pumping out papers, but without a corresponding increase in “major breakthroughs.” The solution, he says, is for U.S. scientists and universities to “become more flexible and more adaptive”—advice that might do us all some good.
July 24th, 2008 at 5:09 pm
[…] attitude of major research universities may actually be squashing innovation??US scientists are …http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/realitybase/2008/07/24/historians-foretell-our-demise-as-a-scienti…Car smashes through restaurant squashing man against counterVideo from a camera mounted inside a […]
July 25th, 2008 at 12:23 am
Well its time America woke up to the fact that America is & always has been ROMES (via the british Royal family, who is America’s owner) laboratory where they send people from all over the world to create what they have required to build toward their NEW WORLD ORDER. They expect this to be up & running & pretty much settled by 2012.
The public wasnt included or allowed to know their plans because they know we wont be happy with the end product. Now they are covering their tracks by eliminating where they’ve been. (Even in the Universities.)
Fortunately there are some big shocks coming up for them.
They have been permitted to climb very high on there pedestal so their fall will be harsh enough to ensure they wake up. No more blaming others or hiding behind their power & money.
August 27th, 2008 at 8:04 pm
Well, I seriously doubt we can keep being a science superpower if our children are taught that some person in the sky made everything. While the generation that got out of school before the religious people ruined it will be enough to keep Americans going for awhile, the kids that grew up thinking that a designer put everything here in six days (a population that, unfortunately, is growing constantly) are not going to be much of an asset to American science.